Good morning all. This trial is in the matter of CFI091 2024 and CFI068 2024 and is being held by way of video conferencing before his excency justice Michael Black with the sitting of the hearing taking place in Dubai. Any orders or directions made during the course of or after this hearing will be issued by the registry in Dubai on the judge's instructions. The claimant is represented by Trowers and Hamlands. Lead council is Mr. Matthew Watson. The defendant is represented by Pensent Mason's and lead council is Mr. Lawrence Page. Thank you, your honor. >> Thank you. Uh first of all, I can't see either council. U so let me just see if I can adjust my view in some way. I've just got a document on you ought uh your honor um there's an option to kind of pop out the um uh the EP feed so that you then get two windows, one with the document and one with the faces. >> Okay, pop out. There we go. See what happens there. Okay, and now I have the documents separately. Let's have a look at that. [snorts] And if I try gallery view. Ah, okay. I've found you. Uh, Mr. Watson. Um, let me see. For some reason, I can only see four. Bear with me. I'm so sorry. >> That's all right. >> Gallery size. If I uh Okay, that's the problem. Right. Good. I can see you both. Thank you very much indeed. Uh, that's fine. >> Good morning. Good morning. [laughter] >> Good morning. >> Right. So, I shall uh you're going to display the documents as you go through. So, I'll put that on another screen. Right. Uh the transcript seems to be up and running, which is good. Okay. Uh one housekeeping matter in relation to timing today. Uh I have a judges meeting at lunchtime. Uh so what I propose to do is you've you've agreed to have uh an hour and 15 minutes each for opening submissions. So if we take uh if we take a break, particularly since we have a a live transcription, we're going to need one anyway uh after the first round of submissions for about for 15 minutes and then carry on. we can carry on and uh forgive me if I use London time. Uh we carry on until uh 10:45. So that's uh 1:45 uh Dubai time. take an hour for lunch between 1:45 and 2:45 uh which should be enough time for me to have uh my meeting uh resume at uh 11:45 or 2:45 uh uh and then carry on to 2:45 um UK time uh that or >> it would be 2:50 actually 250 >> 250 I'm so sorry yes 250 UK time, >> 2:15 UK time, but we can um uh we can carry on beyond that as far as I'm concerned if we need an extra 15 minutes or so because we've lost time. Uh okay. Does that work for both? >> Yes, that should be fine then. >> Okay, Mr. [clears throat] Good. Okay. in which case uh let's start. >> Well, there are just two other quick house uh keeping matters um they should detain us. But just to update uh your honor, the first is because they're both changes since the PTR. >> Um the first is that Mr. Al Jasm is now going to give evidence in Arabic through an interpreter. >> Um >> that is scheduled for the Thursday. um an interpreter has been found and agreed and that's all fine. Um the second is that Mr. Ivankovic is going to give his evidence from Chicago rather than coming to London. Um but we're not suggesting any change to the sitting hours. He'll just have a very early start and um a lot of coffee. >> Okay. >> But unless there's anything from Mr. pack which I I propose to open. >> Nothing from me. Thank you. >> Your honor, you've had the benefit of our skeletons and what I intend to do for the opening is to identify for your honor the key issues in the battleground uh and identify some of the key documents. I was going to start, if I may, with the loan claim. As your honor will have seen, this concerns a loan agreement between Fontessa and KJM and the issues can be grouped under three broad headings. Firstly, was Contessa obliged to advance the second branch of the loan? Secondly, uh if it was not, is KGM obliged to repay the first tranch uh with interest? And thirdly, if Contessa was obliged to >> Sorry. Secondly, forgive me again. Secondly, >> I if if Contessa was not obliged to advance the second tranch, >> yes. >> Is KJM obliged to repay the first tranch with interest? >> Okay. Yeah. >> And then the third broad heading is if Contessa was obliged to lend uh what if any loss has KJN suffered? And that's because there's there's no dispute between us that if Contessa was obliged to lend, it didn't lend and that would be a breach. >> Yes. >> So turning to the the first of those headings, the central question about whether Contessa was obliged to uh advance the second tranch. It's worth just starting with the loan agreement which is at page 9004 in the bundle. And if we could focus in on clause two because that is the critical clause. Clause 2A uh states that as at the date of the execution of the agreement, Contessa had already paid one uh6 million uh dollars to KJM. There's an issue about that which I'll return to. But the critical clause for your honor's purposes is clause 2B which says that the balance of the loan will be paid within five business days and then sets out a condition precedent upon receipt that's by contessor of a satisfactory report from the appointed surveyor and the central issue is whether that condition was satisfied. Now KJM relies on two documents that were provided to Contessa. The first is a document called the admiral report and the second is a document called the corrective actions document or the corrective actions report. I'll I'll take you to both of those in the course of this opening. >> Yes. Um it's common ground I think that that second document the corrective action document is is not a survey. Um but there's an issue between us about whether the admiral report has to be read in light of it. Um but as your honor can see from from clause 2B the condition precedent is qualified by some important words. They are the contessor in its sole discretion will determine whether the report from the appointed surveyor is satisfactory. And there's no dispute between us that this gave contessa the right to decide whether the abal report was satisfactory and therefore whether the condition precedent uh is satisfied. Um and that gives rise to the first issue between the parties and it's a legal issue which is whether there is an implied obligation on Contessa to act rationally when it decides whether a report is satisfactory. That's a duty that's sometimes you know known to your honor as banana duty after the Supreme Court decision. And KJM's case is that there is such a duty and that uh contesta acted irrationally and therefore in breach by deciding that uh the admiral report was not satisfactory. So that's the way it it puts its case. Contessa's primary position is that there's no banana duty which falls to be implied. It simply had a an absolute contractual right to determine whether the survey was satisfied with the result that if there's no duty to act rationally, Contessa cannot commit a breach when it concluded that the admiral report was unsatisfactory in its conclusion. >> I don't actually think that's your best point. >> Well, I well well I'm taking the taking the points as it were in their in their logical order. Um maybe I'll get to my best point later. Um but um note what your honor has said. >> Um that is as it were kind of um the first issue. Obviously if your honor concludes that there is a banana duty, your honor have to consider the question about whether it was breached and that gives rise to three uh issues. The first is an issue of construction about the meaning of the word satisfactory because there was a new point in my learner friend skeleton which is that satisfactory only refers to the quality of the report. I did Mr. Hung who prepared the admiral report do a good job not the condition of the yacht. Um my case is it refers to both. Um >> yeah that's an that's an issue. >> Again just to be just to be fair I don't think that's his best point. >> Well I don't say it's a good point. No. Um >> no. [clears throat] The second issue and is potentially quite an important issue is a pure issue of fact which is when the admiral report was received by Contessa Contessa's case >> yes >> is that the AB report was provided for for the first time by email on the 11th of July 2024. And I won't take your honor to it, but for your note in the transcript, that's page 1287 of the bundle. Uh, and that's a year after the report was prepared. And KJM's case is that the report was provided to Mr. Revankovich shortly after it was prepared. So in around July 2023 and your honor is no doubt going to hear evidence about that during the course of the trial. But the significance is that it's common ground between the parties experts that a report a survey report that's a year old is not a reliable guide to the yachts condition. One might think that that is fairly obvious. And so Contessa's case is if it only received a report that's a year out of date, it was obviously acting rationally and saying, "Well, this is not satisfactory because it tells me nothing about the yacht's condition." Now, um I I'm not sure whether that proposition is actually disputed, i.e. that if it was received a year late, Contessa would have been acting rationally and rejecting it. But that's Contessa's case. So your honor's got that factual question of when the admiral report was received and then against the backdrop of that question, your honor's got to decide whether a contessa acted irrationally in deciding that the admiral report was unsatisfactory. It's probably worth now just briefly having a look at it. It starts at page 936 of the bundle. And there's there's no dispute between us about the essential facts that Mr. Hung uh who's from Hong Kong went to went to um the shipyard in China. He carried out a survey as it it indicates in that text at the bottom of the screen between 6th and 10 July 2023. and the report was prepared on the 10th of July or very close to it. Um, the report's about 102 pages long. I should make it clear that it's no part of my case that Mr. Hung's that Mr. Hung did a bad job. I don't take any point about the quality of the report as a report. My criticisms are all focused on the condition of the yacht. Um, if we go to page 941, your honor can see that Mr. Hung has a kind of um set of standards that he applies categorizing uh the yacht overall from good to poor with various definitions. And then the the important part of the report for our purposes starts on page 953 and there are some general remarks and you can see beneath the bullet points he starts to um identify some issues. So, there's an issue with the air conditioning. There's an issue with the transom gate. You can see the final paragraph there. There was an issue with the Roman blinds in the um port side guest cabin and starboard side hull laundry. And then if your honor moves over the page to page 953, not sorry, 954, you get his overall conclusion, which is that the vessel was satisfactory to good subject to the comments in the report. And he produces a defect list that runs over a couple of pages. So if we perhaps scroll over to 955, uh some it is fair to say are cosmetic, some are a little bit more substantive. So paragraph 17, you can see there the air conditioning issue that been identified. Um paragraph 24, one can see um the shower was leaking and needed to be replaced. Um and the rest of the report after this section uh comprises uh photographs. So you want to can see various um photographs of the yacht and its condition. And we'll no doubt go to some of that in in the evidence. Now contesttor's case is that even if it had received the report earlier, it acted rationally in saying that the report was not satisfactory because the yacht had defects and those defects needed to be rectified and contestant needed to see some uh needed to see a surveyor's report showing that those defects had been cured before it parted with the final tranch's case is that the defects were just not sufficiently serious to justify um rejecting the report. Obviously we'll address all that in closing. Show you one of the other key document on this issue at page 183. This is the corrective actions document. It's dated the 29th of February, 2024. You can see the date in the sort of second box there. That's about 7 months after the Admiral report was prepared. It's it's from the manufacturer uh who I'm just going to call Sino Eagle. And it's it's three pages long. or perhaps the operator could just scroll through the three pages. Um, your honor will see there's very little narrative. What there are is a series of photographs. Um, you don't see for instance any reference to air conditioning. Um, that's it. Thank you uh to the operator. Um, it's not suggested that this was provided to Contessa before the 11th of July 2024. So Contessa's case is it got the Apple report and this on the same day on the 11th of July 24. Um and KGM's case is well this document shows that the um defects identified by Mr. whom have been resolved and Contessa's position is quite simply you can't tell anything from this document. That incidentally is the common position of the party's experts. Um but no doubt that will be explored in evidence. So the issue for your honor is going to be whether anything in this document affects whether Contessa acted rationally in saying that the admiral report was unsatisfactory. Those are as it were the core issues on whether clause 2B was satisfied. Now, if your honor were to conclude that clause 2B wasn't satisfied, then KJM has a fallback case, which is that Contessa either waved the condition precedent or is is stopped from asserting that the clause wasn't satisfied. And I should say that um having seen my loan of friends skeleton I I don't think there's likely to be any disagreement between us on the law or waiver or a stople although um I might have some things to say about the the type of waiver. Um but we'll leave all that for closing. Um I'd like to show you just briefly how the the waiver case is put. If you can go to page 24 in the bundle, this is um the pleaded case. This is the defense and counter claim. And at little five, uh your honor can see uh the plea in the further alternative. Mor and co's request for wire instructions amounted to a waiver of the condition precedent such that contestant was obligated to advance and then at uh little Roman six in the further alternative more and co's request for wire instructions gave rise to an estoppel. So the the pleaded case is put solely on the basis that the the document that gave rise to the waiver or the estoppel is um code request for wire instructions and that was in an email. I'll just show it to you very briefly. It's a page 1296 of the bundle sent on the 30th of July 2024 by Moren Co. their lawyers in Florida who acted for Contessa and Mr. Ivankovich. And it's I I think the bit that's relied on is that statement. Would you be good enough to send us the wire instructions for the transfer of the US 2.39 million? And your honor would have seen in my skeleton that contest's case is that actually what was going on here was a slightly different transaction is that as the loan hadn't been fulfilled, Mr. Ivankovich stepped in and suggested that he would take over the purchase of the yacht directly from the shipyard. Um all of that all of the argument about this we can save for closing. um your honor will have detected from uh my skeleton that there's an additional point in relation to this waiver issue about whether um because there's an in a a clause in the loan agreement that prevents informal modifications um a waiver like this would even work. I'll just show you that clause very quickly. That's at page 9006 of the bundle. and it's clause 15 modifications to the agreement. This agreement may not be modified or amended except in writing signed by KJM and Contessa. Um and there's very in fact very similar wording in clause nine just above it. Um but nothing really turns on that. It says at the end of clause nine that the agreement may not be amended, supplemented or otherwise modified. unless duly executed by or on behalf of each party. Say materially the same. And my case is that that includes a waiver or a stopple that's not in signed writing. My learner friend says it can't have that effect. And we'll have that argument in um in closing. Now, in my loaner friend skeleton, uh there was an attempt uh to expand the case. I ought to just flag this to your honor. Um perhaps in the supplemental bundle if we go to page uh 104 and it's it's paragraph 43.1 and here the case on waiver or estoppel is said to uh rest on Steven's failure to say anything at all prior to July 2024 to the effect that he didn't think the report was satisfactory or that he needed to see it coupled with repeated assurances that he would make payment and it said that's sufficient to amount to a waiver. Um and then there's various uh subpar paragraphs which I think are the repeated asurances that are relied upon. Now, I can make this case on the facts if necessary, but I want to put down a marker now that that none of this is pleaded. And so, my my primary submission is going to be it's not open to KGM to invent a new case of waiver at trial. that that um your honor is everything under that first heading of whether Contessa was obliged to lend. So moving to that second heading of what issues arise for your honor if your honor concludes Contessa was not obliged to lend. There are two issues and the first [clears throat] is was KJM obliged to repay the first tranch of 1.6 million and Contessa's case is that KJM is obliged to repay the first tranch and its case rests on clause five of the loan agreement. I'll just show you all of that. It's in the or bundle at page 9004. Clause five. Um you want to consider the structure. At clause three, um there's an agreement that there'll be no interest charge and that the loan will be repaid in full upon the sale of the vessel. And then there at clause four there are series of conditions on which the funds are advanced. The first of which is that KJM will purchase the vessel. And then at clause five is a very poorly drafted clause. In the event that the vessel is not purchased by KJM from builder, KJM shall return all funds advanced by Contessaora to KJM under this agreement. And that's what we say uh entitles the contestant to the return of its funds. Now there's two points here for your honor. The first is an issue of construction. So KJM says that this clause does not respond where contessor decides that a report is unsatisfactory. So his case is in that event clause five is not responsive. My cases it is that's an issue of construction. We'll have the argument in closing. the the second point that KJM takes is a new point and KJM says well this is an clause 5 is an obligation to return all the funds advanced by Contessa and there's no evidence that Contessa actually advanced 1.6 6 million and that's because there's no dispute between us that the money actually came from a company called Gleno and so whilst Mr. Ivankovich says in his evidence that Gleno had made a loan to Contessa what my learner friend says in his skeleton is well there's no evidence of that and therefore it's not been proven that Contessa actually advanced the 1.6 million. Now I need to put down another marker here because in my submission this point is is also not open to KJM. And perhaps if we can go to the defense and counter claim at page 19 >> page >> and if the bundle >> yeah page 19 of the bundle and if the EP operator scrolls down to the bottom of that page paragraph nine there's a plea and this is KJM's plea pursuant to clause 2a contest is obligated to pay 1.6 million to KJM and then a clear plea Contessa paid this sum on 26th of May 2023. So there's a positive plea from KJM that Contessa paid the uh 1.6 million. And as a result of the fact that that was my case and that was KJM's case, if we go in the bundle to page five, you want to can see the agreed common ground and paragraph five is of the agreed common ground. By 26th of May 2023, Contessa had already advanced 1.6 million to KJM under clause 2A of the loan agreement. So my simple point is this. KJM cannot come to trial and say that Contessa has failed to prove something that is common ground on the pleadings. If it wanted to put Contessa to proof of that point, it needed to take the point in its pleadings. Not least so that Contessa had some notice. Um there's also an issue uh your honor about uh if KJM has to repay the 1.6 million whether interest is chargeable. Uh Contessa's case is that interest is chargeable on clause six. I set all that out in my skeleton. My learner friend hasn't said anything about it on that specific issue. Um I won't take you on a through any of that now. It's a it's a relatively minor issue. Um but we can address it if necessary in closing. So that's it were the issues that arise if uh Contessa was not obliged to lend. If Contessa was obliged to lend, as I say, there's no dispute that it didn't and that would be a breach. And so the issue is KJM's loss. And there are two ways in which its case is put. Uh loss of profit and wasted expenditure. On loss of profit, um I'll just show your honor the pleaded case. That's at page 27 of the bundle and it's paragraph 58.4. That is the totality of the case on loss of profits. [clears throat] Now in his skeleton, Mala friend has tried to construct a case by looking at some WhatsApp messages and making some assumptions to try and get to um an assertive profit figure. um that's going to be explored in evidence, but your honor might anticipate I'm going to have some things to say in closing about the sort of case that's actually open to KJM to advance, but as I say, I'll save all of that for closing. That's loss of profits on wasted expenditure. I think it's it's common ground uh that this would be an alternative claim. So it's either loss of profits or wasted expenditure. It's it's not both. Um I also don't think that there is now any dispute that the total amount that KJM paid to the shipyard was uh $1.8 million US. Uh you all might recall that paragraph 34 of my skeleton I set out in the little table the the payment instructions that have been disclosed and one can see the announcements. Um now KGM says it's wasted expenditure is about $800,000 and there are really just two issues of principle here. The first is whether KJM can prove that it actually lost any money. In other words, that the sums that it paid were legally forfeit to the shipyard. They were put to proof of that allegation, and they need to prove it. And my submission in closing would be that they haven't. >> Do we have a copy of the contract between KGM and the shipyard? >> That is an issue that I'm going to explore in cross-examination, but the short answer, your honor, [clears throat] is is no. Um uh it was sought in document production. Um there was no dispute that production should be given. Um some emails were produced. Uh questions were asked and said, "Well, well, thank you for the emails, but where's the contract?" And the answer that came back is, "Well, there is no contract. There are just some emails." Um I'm going to explore that with the witnessing uh evidence, but okay. As it's as it stands, there does not appear to be a contract, at least by contract, a written document of the kind that you know your honor would expect to see. Um the the second issue of principle on the wasted expenditure is uh whether of the 1.8 odd that was transferred to the shipyard, 1.6 Six of that was the money advanced from Contessa and in my submission that money if it if it has gone is Contessa's loss in reality not KJN's and so the the total uh wasted expenditure could only be about $240,000 which is the money that KJM spent from its own funds. That's an issue of principle. Um, I don't think my learner friend has yet said anything on those two issues. Um, so I'll leave that there. Um, but that it by way of a very brief overview, your honor, are the the main issues on the loan claim. So I was going to move to turn to the JV claim unless your had any questions at this stage. >> No, not at this stage. So as your honor is uh will be aware the JV claim concerns a joint venture agreement between Mr. Ivankovic personally and KJM and the joint venture was um to establish and operate a company in the event of a Dubai company which is the third defendant to the JV claim which we call KJI and the joint venture agreement is effectively a shareholders agreement between them. uh like the loan claim, the issues that arise on the JV claim can be grouped under three broad headings. And the first broad heading is was the JV agreement terminated on the 10th of September 2024. I should probably say terminated by KJM 2024. The second issue is if it wasn't terminated, what relief should the court grant? And your honor would have seen that essentially Mr. Vankovich asks for various injunctions to uh enforce the agreement. And the third uh heading is if the agreement was terminated is KJM entitled to any relief because it's got a counter claim arising out of what it says a breach of contract. So I'll um I'll deal with the first heading about whether the JV agreement is validly terminated. It's worth just starting, I think, with the termination notice. That's at page 1357 and it's a letter from Pinset Mason's and it asserted at two grounds to terminate. one uh was as a result of a company called Ivankovich Family LLP entering chapter 11 bankruptcy in uh Florida and that was said to trigger um uh clause K3 in the JV agreement. You can see that in the third paragraph and I'll come back and show you on that in a minute. And then uh in the fourth paragraph following the word separately there was a complaint in relation to some unpaid purchase orders. Um those unpaid purchase orders were all the aquaform purchase orders which you might have seen referred to in the documents that was all adjudicated by the Dubai court. Uh nothing is pursued in relation to that now. So your honor just doesn't need to worry about any of that. Now, in my submission, it it's it's helpful to your honor to group the termination issues that your honor actually has to decide into four based on the facts that are said to give rise to the right to terminate. And I I'll give them to you now. So, everyone's got them. The four facts are these. Firstly is the entry of four companies into chapter 11 bankruptcy in the US. So call that the chapter 11 ground. The second fact is the making of three orders in Mr. Ivankovich's divorce proceedings in Illinois. The third fact is the alleged uh late payment of Mr. Ivankovic's initial contribution to the joint venture. And the fourth fact is um an alleged failure by Minister Ivankovich to make additional cash contributions. So each of those four things is said to give rise to a right to terminate. I'll just go through them all very briefly. the the chapter 11 ground. The best way into this, I think for your honor, is the um order that was made by the uh Florida court when these companies came out of insolveny. Um your honor will see that at page 1647 in the bundle 1647. And your honor can see the the four companies listed there. They are Ivankovic Family LLC, ANO Family LLC, another AO Family LLC, and that's because one is an Illinois company and one is a Florida company. And then Atlas P2 managing member and you can see that the debtors were those four companies. And then uh Dr. Anthony Ivankovich um and that's Mr. Mr. Ivankovich's father who sadly passed away only a few weeks ago. Dr. Olga Ivankovich, that's Mr. Ivankovich's mother. And your honor might see Anthony and Olga Ivankovich. We can see where the ANO comes from in the ANO family. And various other companies proposed a plan. And um if we scroll over on to page 1648, you might be able to see in the sort of italic at the bottom that um Mr. Ivankovic as in Steven filed a confirmation affidavit in that uh as did various other people. Sorry, let me just find that. >> It's uh about four lines up from the bottom. >> Oh, got it. Yeah. upon the confirmation affili etc. Um at page 1651 under the heading chapter 11 petition you want to can see the nature of the proceedings. So the debtors that is the four companies filed a voluntary petition for relief. Um the petition date is the 10th of June 2024. That's that's common ground. And um you can see that it was a a process where the the debtors were left in possession and control of their assets. So there was no trustee or liquidator or anything appointed. They continued as debtors in possession but obviously subject to the direction of the court. And I'll show you a quick footnote because it's relied on by my learn friend page 1665. And if I could ask the operator to just zoom in if we can on the um uh footnote gives you some background to these proceedings. Um essentially um the judge expressing the view there is no doubt that rulings in the Illinois divorce proceedings precipitated these bankruptcy filings but the debt is the creditors whether or not disputed whose interests are entirely be be protected. It it's not I don't think in dispute between us that the the wider cause of these chapter 11 proceedings were were Mr. Ivank Mr. Steven Ibankovich's divorce proceedings essentially his wife said these companies are matrimonial assets and therefore um I'm entitled to share of them and that was disputed. Now KJM's case is that these four chapter 11 companies all their assets belong to Steven Ivankovic. His case is that he doesn't have a beneficial interest in them or their assets. They belong to his family, principally his late father and his mother. Now, it's not disputed that the AO family Florida company and another company called Gleno made payments to KJN on Mr. Ivankovich's behalf, but Mr. Ivankovich's evidence is that these were loans that were made to him. And your honor might be thinking, what has any of this got to do with the JVA? Um, and the reason is uh that there were it is said that um the fact of these four companies going into insolveny entitled uh KJM to terminate on two grounds. I'll just show them very briefly. If we go to page 886 in the bundle and you can see that there is an event of default at KA3 called insolvency if any venturer venturer being defined as Steven Ivankovich or KJM and it it said that that event was satisfied. Um in my submission it wasn't. We'll have an argument about that. And then if the operator could scroll up um there is a clause J on the on the bottom of the next page previous page called termination of agreement which gave another termination right um B either venture entitled to terminate the agreement effective immediately by providing written notice this only if any of the following occur. And then at three, there is a material change in a ventures management business assets or company structure. And it's said that that condition is satisfied. And the answers to that are we say, well, there was no change because these these weren't his assets or his companies. even if it was it wasn't a material change because it didn't actually affect anything to do with his performance in the JV. And then thirdly, uh you could only exercise this clause with written notice and no written notice was given. I don't think it's disputed that there was never express notice given under JB3. So that's the that's the as it were the chapter 11 ground. The uh the divorce ground relies on three orders made in divorce proceedings. I'll show you the main one. It's at page 898 in the bundle. And this was an order essentially that Mr. Revankovich pay uh $400,000 to uh his ex-wife's lawyers and $25,000 uh to them for the payment of an expert essentially so that she had funding throughout her uh divorce proceedings and um uh Mr. Ivankovich well I should be careful I express myself here Mr. of Ankovich was found to be in contempt by the Illinois court for not paying this. I won't take you to it, but that that order is at 1097 in the bundle. And essentially what we would call a bench warrant was issued at um to enforce that at page 109. Again, I won't take you to that. Mr. Ivankovich's case is that um well, that was issued in error because he had in fact paid. But again, why is this uh relevant? Um its case is that the the fact of this order having been made triggered uh the right to terminate under JB3 because there was a material change in Mr. Lankanovich's assets as a result of being ordered to pay 425,000. Now you would have seen that our straightforward answer to that is well no it didn't because after this order was made Mr. Ivankovich paid two and a4 million dollars to the JV. So the suggestion that this order affected his ability to perform is a difficult one to sustain, but that's the issue. We'll argue about it in closing. In terms of the the the payments, it's alleged that Mr. Ankovich made certain payments late. Um the starting point is the is the JV agreement. That's if we go to page 881 in the bundle and under B, your honor can see that Mr. Ivankovich uh agreed to make a an initial contribution. And you you want to concede that the initial contribution um is this is a it's a very difficult it's very hard to um express clause but it's B1 A1A you can see that the the initial contribution was for various things providing the capital to design and fabricate molds staff etc. And then D, you'll see that the amount of the contribution was $2 million. And KJM's contribution, just you can see it was entirely in kind. So it was providing a factory, a facility, staff, etc. Mr. Ivankovich was providing the cache. And I'll just show you because it's relevant later whilst we're here. If if the operator scrolls down to D. [clears throat] Yes, >> there's an agreement about additional contributions. Oh, sorry. No, no, no. There it is in the middle. Thank you. Any additional contribution that should be required by either venturer must be approved by each venture unanimously. So, there's it's 2 million up front. Anything else has to be agreed. This was subject to some >> Sorry, can you hear me? It's not merely that that KGM was to contribute uh in kind um cuz I I noticed it's understood that KGM will use the initial contribution to cover the operating expenses associated with the setup of the factory. So >> that's if initial contribution. >> Yeah. So the initial contribution is design and fabric necessary molds and vessel fabrication. Uh but it in addition it seems that that contribution is also to be used for setup of the factory. >> Yes. Yes it is. Yes. It's not it's sorry it's not limited the initial capital is not limited to design to capital for designing and fabricating molds. It was also setting up the factory infrastructure. >> Yes. It it might help you on actually to see how this was varied because um there was one variation which isn't really relevant and then there was a second variation which is at page 913 in the bundle and that deleted the original clauses some of the original clauses and replaced it with this which was an obligation to pay just a little bit more than 2 million. And it was broken down into three tranches. And perhaps if the operators scrolls, you can see that the parties had agreed that the 2 million gets broken down into various different items of expenditure. And uh if I could ask the operator to just pause on the second and third tranches. Um there's no dispute that that first tranch that we saw was I think three or four days late but I don't think it said that that actually arise that gives rise to a right to terminate. What is said to give rise to a right to terminate is the late payment of the second and third branches. You can see that the second branch is to be paid within five business days of obtaining all the approvals for the buildup. And your honor might say, what is the buildup? And if we go up to page 913 again, you see the under next to architecture work, it says description, design and drawing of the buildup and then construction consultancy and associated logistics. And there's mandatory pre-approvals from the relevant authorities such as municipality, civil defense and DEWA. And then going back over the page again there's under the heading licensing payment of regulatory and operational licenses including but not limited to industrial license chamber of commerce ministry of economic etc. the case, KJM's case, as I understand it, I mean, I should say there's never been a pleaded case about what five business days upon obtaining all approvals actually means, but the way to put in the skeleton is to say, well, the industrial license was obtained and that those were all approvals for the buildup. I don't accept that. Um on the third tranch the um uh the uh trigger is 45 days prior to the mold arrivals. Again there's never been a pleaded case about what that means. Um in the skeleton it said well um on the 10th of October KJM just resorted to using its old its own molds. This comes about because KJM says well Mr. Ivankovich was supposed to supply the physical molds but the problem with that is that there's never been any there's no agreement in the JVA that Mr. Ivankovich is going to supply the physical molds. The agreement was he provide the capital i.e. the money. Um so um the simple point is there's just no case uh that any of these uh funds were paid late. But perhaps more importantly for your honor, there is no dispute between the parties that um Mr. Ivankovic paid all of his initial contribution of just over 2 million by the end of December 2023. Um and yet this is relied on to justify termination in September 2024. And the case is put under clause uh K of the joint venture agreement. So if we go back to that it's 886 >> sorry what date in 2024 September >> September September >> it's about 98 >> and you wanted to go to >> page 886. Yes. >> So your honor can see that there's a a default uh provision the KA1 is default in providing capital contribution and the default continues for a period of 14 days. that that's why >> yes >> if you're going to allege that KA1 is satisfied you have to you have to be able to say this is when the money was due and that's that's so that you can known whether the default continues for a period of 14 days but then if you want to look at BM it is should an event of default occur as to any venturer and continue beyond any grace period resides in this agreement the non-defaulting venture shed selection have the right power and authority and our case is that the words continue beyond any grace period require the event of default to be continuing. So you can't exercise your uh power to terminate under this clause if the default has been cured by the time you you exercise it. So >> can I just get an overall shape of things? Yes. >> So, Mr. Ivankovich uh funded the joint venture to the tune of something over $2 million. >> Yes. >> Do we know how that money was spent? I mean, I've seen I've seen how it was meant to be spent. Do we know how it was actually spent? >> Mr. Vanovich would say no. Um we he has been he has been sent some uh financial high level accounts but none of the underlying material uh underlying that and that is essentially why he is here because um to put it in a nutshell the joint venture agreement contemplated that um he would have access to all the company's documents that he would be a director of the company and my >> yes I know I know I thought about I just again want to get the shape of things. So I I if the termination is effective >> then who gets to keep the two the benefit of the 2 million? >> Well it it's um the 2 million was a loan by Mr. Ivankovich to KJI. So KJ I don't think it's suggested that KJI wouldn't continue to owe him the money. Um but he and he is a shareholder. So he would remain a shareholder. So he would have uh whatever remedies are available to him under Dubai law where you're owed 2 million by by a company. >> Okay. Thank you. >> So that is so that's the issue on on termination. Um, I'm just conscious of time. Um, >> that's all right. You're on number Yes, you're on number three. >> Three. >> Exactly. >> Four, aren't you? >> Well, that was number three, I think. The >> That was number three. Yes, that was late. >> Late and number four is the additional contributions. >> Yes, >> I can deal with this quite quite swiftly. Um essentially the case is that KJM uh incurred expenditure um 873,000 odd dirhams. It's about $230,000. Um, renewing its uh factory, sorry, KJI, I should say, uh, incurred expenditure, renewing its factory lease and its industrial license. Um, Mr. Ivankovich was asked to contribute towards that and he hasn't and it's said that he's liable to do so. And the way the the way this case has been put is a bit um odd. It was originally said um this was an additional contribution and if I if your honor recalls I showed you that clause that says uh venturers if they unanimously agree uh have to make additional contributions. And then the pleading was amended to rely on a different clause and that was the case that I actually addressed in my skeleton. But then in my learner friend skeleton, the case has gone back to relying on the additional contributions clause. So as I understand it, that's the case that this was an alleged additional contribution. >> Uh sorry, the additional contribution just take me to the >> the clause is at uh >> Yeah, I've got it. It's page two. >> Yeah. >> Yes. So I I don't think there's any dispute that what needs to be shown is that um is is a unanimous agreement by each venturer in this case really Mr. Ivankovich to make the additional contribution. Um and our case is quite simple. He never he never he never agreed. Um the case is put in three ways. It said he agreed because of clause A of this joint venture agreement. I won't take you to I'll just summarize the second way in which the case is put or maybe if you want I would like to just look at that page 881. Yes. So you can see uh clause a B is a sort of representation said that that is an agreement. So K going back to KJM's is contribute the following as his initial contribution facility in the UAE for the manufacturing of vessels. C make its facility available for use of joint venture upon execution of this agreement. >> Yeah. So what's the 800,000 dirhams for? >> So uh KJI had to renew its um uh factory and it had taken a lease >> factory. Does KJM have a separate >> I don't I don't think it is KJM's factory. I think they had acquired a a new factory. >> Okay. KJ because KJM is contributing its own facilities. >> Well, well, well, quiet, your honor. I mean, part of the issue with this is that it's it's very unclear to Mr. Ivankovich what has actually happened on the ground. Um, but yes, there are various points at which the the agreement doesn't seem to match what what KJM actually did. >> So, there's an issue as to what this 800,000 was for, whether it's for the benefit of KJM or KJI. Well, I I don't I mean I don't think your honor necessarily needs to get into that because in my submission it's sufficiently clear that Mr. Ivankovich never agreed to make this capital contribution. The only capital contribution he agreed to make was about $2 million and everything above that he had to specifically agree. Otherwise, this agreement is just an open check, isn't it? for um >> for KGM. There's um it's also said that um there's an implicit agreement because these were recurring expenses and they rely on a letter that's sent by my solicitors. We can address all this in closing, but um uh there you go. They say there was an agreement to pay that money. That's from my learner friend to show. Um I should just put down a a marker here and it's more from a learner friend than it is for your honor. It's not clear to me whether it is alleged that leaving the JV agreement aside, there is an obligation under UAE law on Mr. Ivankovic to pay these sums. That was how it was pleaded. It's not quite how it's put in the skeleton. Um, I don't understand how an obligation under UA law, if it existed, would be relevant to breach of the agreement, but I'll let my learner friend explain that in his opening. Um, so those that's as it were the additional contribution issue. Um and there's a final point I should just make about that which is that you will have seen um that Mr. Vankovich did in fact make a further kind of voluntary contribution to the joint venture of about 250,000. And so another answer to our to the additional contributions point is well he's already paid a further $250,000. Um but we can argue about that in um in closing if necessary. Uh those are the issues then on termination. If the JVA was not terminated, the issue is what relief. And essentially, you'll have seen that the way KJM puts his case is to say, well, the relief is all discretionary and you shouldn't grant it because essentially this joint venture is over and you shouldn't be forcing the parties to try and work together. Um, Contessa's position is that's not actually what the relief is about. The relief is about putting Mr. Ivankovic into the position that he would have been in had the agreement been performed. He would have been a director. There would have been a third party director. He would have access to the books and records. So that whatever happens to this company going forwards, whether that's an insolveny process, whatever, Mr. Ivankovich is in the position that the parties agreed he should be in with all the rights that come with that. If um if on the other hand you want to concludes that um the JVA was terminated, KJM has a counter claim and the counter claim relies on two breaches. Firstly, that failure to pay the additional contributions and secondly, a failure to market and sell boats in the United States. That was originally pleaded as a ground of termination, but it's I think accepted now that that's not a ground for termination, but is relied on still as a breach. Our answer to that in a nutshell, just so you has it, is that there was no obligation to market and sell. And in any event, Mr. Ivankovich had nothing to market or sell in any event. um in terms of the uh in terms of the way in which the case is put uh for loss arising from those two breaches. I'll just show you um my learner friends skeleton. It's the easiest place to take. It's in the supplemental bundle at page 1124. This is a um paragraph 87. So the counter claim is for the is said to be for the expenditure which it provided which should have been shared with Steven and then it said as the expenditure Mr. Jasmine is recorded as stating he's invested 10 million dirhams into KJI and then there's reference to transfers and draft financials. Now just pausing there, the pleaded case has only ever been the 830,000 dirham in relation to the additional contributions. That's the only expenditure that's ever actually been alleged. But it I think it's now said actually there's 10 million or more and so I really don't know what case I've got to meet there. And then there's a case uh a claim for loss of profits. And I won't show it to you, but the loss of the loss of profit plea was no more particularized in the JV claim than it was in the loan claim. It's simply a bare assertion of loss of profits. And you can see what's said as to the claim for loss of profits. There's been no disclosure. That's because there was nothing pleaded and no expert evidence. And KGM proposes if the court's prepared to entertain this claim, it should be dealt with at a subsequent hearing. So I think what's now being sought is a split trial. Um I might have some things to say about that in closing. Um but that is uh as it were the case on loss of profits such as it is. Um that by way your honor of a very quick caner in an hour and 15 minutes uh is the the key issues for your honor that you've got to decide the contractual provisions and the the critical documents. Um unless uh your honor has any questions for me. Um I can see the time is approaching 9:15 and that might be a convenient pl place for the um transcribers break. >> Yes. Uh that's fine at this stage. Thank you. Okay. Well, I said we'd take a 15minute break this morning. We may take shorter breaks but uh 50 minutes works in terms of the the lunch break in my meeting. So uh quart 9 London uh4 12 Dubai uh let's resume at uh 12:30 or 9:30 as the case may be. Thanks very much. [snorts] >> Thank you >> Mr. Paige. Good morning. >> Good morning your honor. Uh I can see the transcript is running so uh when you're ready. >> Thank you. Uh yes. So the court is uh trying two consolidated claims uh this week. We obviously have the contessor claim uh and then Mr. Ivankovich's personal claim. Uh the contestant claim is presented as a straightforward debt claim for the return of a deposit towards a yacht. Uh that's the equival which we'll hear a lot more about in the course of this week. Uh and $1.6 million was uh um was put forward um by somebody for that by Glen Code the actual payout. My client KJM counter claims for the loss uh it suffered when the purchase could not be completed. Uh your honor, I'm going to be inviting you to uh see the arrangement not as a bare debt claim but as a commercial venture. uh that went wrong. It was reliant on corporation and that corporation uh collapsed. Um uh in in headline terms, Contessa was going to provide the capital and KGM was to provide first of all its shipyard relationship and secondly um it was to provide the sweat equity the work required to sell the vessel lot. The two parties would then share the profit um from that endeavor. And that's in essence a very similar structure to the to the JVA uh claim um or albeit in miniature. Uh the JVA claim uh uh we we have a bigger manufacturing endeavor that the parties said um um immense work on uh the [clears throat] structure of that changed significantly with the introduction of a memorandum of association which you haven't yet been shown. Um but that memorandum of association puts in place >> [clears throat] >> u different governance arrangements from those originally uh envisaged by the JVA itself. Uh and uh and the relationship there again it collapsed. Um in the personal claim Mr. Vanovich seeks a very wide ranging declarations. The pleaded case u uh gives only a small hint of what actually has now emerged in the draft order put forward by my by my learned friend with the skeleton argument. And your honor may or may not have turned your way through to pages 41 onwards of his skeleton argument. But you'll see there that we now have um uh two and a half pages of uh declaratory relief that is being sought. Uh and this is taking the flavor of a um uh effectively a minority shareholder claim with lots of governance relationship um issues being put forward rather than simply narrative clarity relief as to whether or not termination was uh was validly given. So uh being in due course will have quite a lot to say about all of that. Um for the purposes of of this opening I I want to just give you a bit of a root map um from my perspective and happily quite a lot of what I might have needed to say has been taken away because um Mr. to Watson and I I think are largely agreed on the broad issues between us and on the broad legal disputes um between us and in that sense is is opening is is a helpful guide to your honor. Um in SB the the the reasons why the relationship collapsed is the matter about which the parties differ. We said being collapsed because of uh Mr. effectively starving the two endeavors of funds contrary to his contractual beliefs, contractual obligations. So let's start then with the contessor uh arrangement. Uh the contract there is at uh page 94. Yes, it's up on the EP screen in front of us. Uh so the the two words at the top of page uh 904 uh are a label of loan agreements but we we say that's not an act description for the architecture of the um of the contract itself. Um we have u an obligation to loan 3.99 million um in two different tranches as set out in clause 2 A and 2B. uh and of course it's 2B that the parties will be um principally um focusing on as as the trial goes on. Um then there is uh unlike um almost any other loan agreement you will have seen uh there is no fixed term for repayment. There is no interest rate. There's no other ratchet linking the length of time the capital was being deployed to Contessa's level of return. Um there's also no security. Instead, as I say, what we have is a joint commercial undertaking in which the parties shared both the risk and the reward. Contessor puts up the money, takes the financing risk, uh and in exchange for that, uh it then has a preferential position in the payment waterfall, which is set out at clause seven of the contract. That's over page on page 95. >> [clears throat] >> It gets back its money first on an interestf free basis and then it gets a higher percentage of the profits on a 60% to 40% ratio uh at clause 7B. Um there is a um a top size deduction for selling expenses and which are defined So what KJM um puts into this and takes out of it is it puts in uh its the benefit of its relationship with Sino Eagle uh and the commitment to deploy its sweat equity needed to achieve a sale and then it takes out from that uh a fraction of the profits and on uh uh our calculations the that number would have been in the high six figures. Um the number flowing to uh Contessa would have been higher if this had worked out. Um so from the outset the parties interests were broadly aligned. Both parties stood to profit but only if the purchase went ahead and only if an onward sale was profitable. So in terms of the payment tranches we have two tranches there. It's common ground that uh the first payment was made on the 26th of May 2023. This is nearly a month before the contract had been signed. Uh the page reference is uh tab 13 page 897. Excuse me. 8 9 uh six [cough] [clears throat] and we see here it's a larger adapted uh bank statement uh from Gleno family dwelling uh and the payment is there the named linker appears at the start of this document which is back in 894. Now it is of course common ground that nobody provided the second uh tranch of payment uh and uh and indeed uh it's my case that uh Contessa was obliged to provide that and indeed that uh Contessa had been warned for many months indeed uh that the initial payment would be forfeited uh if uh if the second branch was not provided soon if different deadlines are given through case first in April then in August 2024. Uh Sino Eagle's final deadline uh lapsed on the 4th of August and there was no payment uh 4th of August 2024. Uh there was no payment by that deadline and that meant that the deposit uh already paid was forfeited and the parties are now debating who is to blame for that. the within the factual detail of the contestant claim uh we have a we have the principal debate concerning the report itself and then the delivery of the report uh and how that maps on to clause 2B of the contract. So the way I put it is that the two central questions are first was contestant entitled to withhold the balance on the basis that clause 2B was not satisfied and two does this conclusion change depending on the date when the report was provided to contessor. So logically in my mind and I think in Mr. Watson's mind as well to be fair that the an analysis of the report itself comes um logically prior to an analysis of the delivery dates because we only get to a debate about delivery dates uh if uh I if the court concludes that the report was satisfactory within the um [clears throat] within the defined sense of clause 2B. So, as I understand it, head contest's headline position is that it was entitled to withhold the $2.4 million because uh uh under clause 2B of the contract, it had an unfettered discretion um to determine whether or not the report's conclusions were satisfactory. And that's a point made at paragraph four of its uh pleaded reply and defense counterplay. No need to turn it up, but for your reference, that's at tab to page 30. KGM's uh answer to that is in two stages. And and before I jump into this, I I already take in mind um your honor's comment about what your honor says may or may not be my best point. Um clearly, we'll get into the detail of that debate at uh closing. Um but I I don't resolve from from the position that that the on a proper construction of clause 2B. This is an administrative process uh looking at the quality of the report itself rather than an evaluation of the yacht based upon the report and and the two are are quite different. So we say that the report was satisfactory. Um the instruction by KGM uh to the uh surveyor was the right sort of instruction. It didn't asked the surveyor to carry out a pre-ely inspection. Uh and that then was carried out. It was a thorough inspection carried out over 5 days. The vessel was in the water and in the cradle. Um your already been taken to um some highlights of the report. It's a lengthy report with about 80 or so pages of photos and the experts agree that it is a comprehensive report and indeed I'll go back to Mr. Watson's precise words in due course but I think he he he doesn't contest the point uh either that everyone is uh in agreement that the surveyor was asked to do the right job. He carried out the task with um all due care and skill and any rejection of the report adequacy in uh in that sense um would be irrational or capricious. Um I say that on a proper interpretation of clause 2B, it fell to KJM to make the commercial decision whether or not to press ahead with a purchase. And it's here in this respect and really in this respect only that the structure of the loan agreement becomes significant and that's because KJM was to be the purchaser of the vessel not Contessa and the way broadly speaking in which the contract was to work that Contessa was properly entitled to exercise um an oversight to make sure that KJM was basing decision on uh his commercial decisions on a on a proper suite of documents but ultimately it was for KGM to decide whether or not to press ahead um with the purchase. Now, if your honor um says that no, in fact, the proper analysis uh is that the is it clause 2B requires a focus on the conclusions of the report and a conclusion about the yacht itself rather than uh the the uh the process undertaken by the surveyor. Then we said we also satisfy that test also. Uh in addition um the conclusion in the report was that the vessel was in a satisfactory to good condition. U forgive me. Um the the page the page references that Mr. Watson gave you. Did they start with a 900 or a 100 for the Admiral report? Um I've got I have worked with both at different times. Um we can look for the moment perhaps just for uh this bit differently later if we need to but the first time the admiral report appears in a bundle is at page 150 >> I think it was I think it was a 900 that he go >> 900 so >> sorry just to I I worked from the version 900 which is in the chronological run it does appear as a as an exhibit to I link my learn and friends expert report and I I suspect that's the version that my learner friend is looking at. >> Yes. So it it there are a number of documents which appear as exhibits to Mr. Folks's uh expert report and then everything appears in a chron chronological order in in uh at about 850 onwards. So I'm content to look at the the version looking starting 936. Um so in the version starting 936 in uh internal page 19 which is bundle page 954. We get the headline conclusion that the festival was in a satisfactory to good condition. the meaning of those words. Uh not a matter that is open to debate because uh the surveyor told us what he means by those words at page 941 of the bundle. So it's somewhere between satisfactory and good. uh satisfactory meaning condition average minor deficiencies not in need of correction wear and tear evident but original strength/performance not significantly affected good is uh better than that when no maintenance or repairs are required and just to benchmark what is meant by those it's worthwhile uh if you're on a scan it's also what fair condition means as >> [clears throat] >> There's also there's also an additional commercial uh piece of background, isn't there? That KJM itself would have had the resources a and the skills to uh remedy any minor snagging items that would remain after delivery. Yes, your honor. That so that is entirely correct that that when we are looking here at what whether or not the vessel is is in is in deliverable condition. Um the the benchmark we say is not is it ready for sale to an onward retail purchaser at full retail price of six or so million dollars. is whether or not the vessel has hit the standard to be deliverable to a trade purchaser for slightly less than $4 million. And that's a trade purchaser with a manufacturing facility uh who will then be marketing the boat. Now, one would hope that even the most precious of retail purchases would find the wherewithal to be able to clean the toilets, but on some of the other um issues, we say there is nothing there that would trouble um a a company of KJM experience to carry out the minor maintenance tasks. So the matters listed uh under the defects uh list which is back at page 954. Um again I don't quibble with the um with the language that Mr. P uses here. Um, but a a a language which would be more suitable in a construction context might be a snag list. And it's a minor snag list at that that he sets through. And we'll look at some of this in a bit more detail in uh in the evidence and in closing, but perhaps unsurprisingly, Mr. Watson uh because his principal focus on the air conditioning uh unit uh and that I'll just flank you your honor is at page 17. Sorry, it's excuse me, it's item 17 of the of the snag list, page 955. And there's a reference there to photograph 92. And photograph 92 is at page 1,02 of the bundle. And as I understand it, the unit is is mechanically working. Uh but in the uh in the two zones identified, it doesn't get down to the right temperature. All of that is to be seen in context. If we go back to page 954, so this is a start of our snag list. We're in the admiral report. the top paragraph there, your honor, you'll see that the weather condition during the survey was 36° C. >> And the relevance of that is what? >> Well, simply that that it's a it's a hot day. [clears throat] uh and we have uh uh it it was tested and operational. We see this at page 951 of the report. So you see here top line air conditioning system tested operational. Uh so it is working. We're just not quite getting down to the desired temperature. And uh on a hot day and say that there is nothing there in item 17 of the snag list that would be sufficient to um uh make it rational to deny delivery of the vessel to a trade purchaser. So on our interpretation of clause 2B, um a contessor had a discretion uh to check that the survey itself was properly carried out, but it did not have a veto to stop a purchase over uh to stop the purchase of a otherwise sound boat or in general sound boat. Now, as your honor has already indicated in the argument to Mr. Watson, where contracts confer a sole discretion on a party, uh, English law has uh, as a theoretical um, possibility that that truly does give it unfettered discretion. But the reality in almost all the cases is that the English law um, readily constrains a party to act in a way which is rational. And we have a long line of cases which we may or may not need to go into in closing. But we have the propaganda duty and that's developed in Equitas Mid Mid Essex Hospital and the most recently Tesco and US door. uh all Supreme Court decisions or most of them are. Um so don't need to go into any of that this morning but uh that's where we find the u uh the court's approach um to whether or not it is it it will read into contract as a matter of construction or as an implied term uh a constraint on of rationality. And just as a small point of detail, Melinda friend in his submission um mentioned only implied terms. Uh as I hope it's made clear in my skeleton argument, um we put the point both as a matter of construction and as an applied term. So threshold issue one is what does the report say? Does the report per se um show that uh this vessel was uh ready for delivery? Um once your honor has reached a conclusion on that point, we then go to the second question of when was it delivered uh and indeed whether it was delivered in a contractually relevant sense and that then brings in the waiver argument. [snorts] Um so on the date of delivery my client's case is that the uh the report was handed over in person uh in uh around July uh 2023. And we will see in the course of evidence that the parties had a large number of face-to-face meetings throughout the summer and autumn of 2023. uh and in my client's case is I say that we hand over document to Mr. Bankovich at one of those meetings. Uh and it can readily be seen um from the from the chronological run of documents that um the interest in this topic just falls away uh by um mid July and the discussion moves on. So there's a lot of focus in May and June 2023 about arranging for an inspection. First of all, that was going to be one of Mr. Ivankovich's uh employees, a man called Olaf Fur Hand, O L A F U R I believe, hand. Uh he was going to fly out. Uh and he receives a letter of invitation from Silent Eagle for that purpose. Uh and that's we can see briefly at page 899 of the bundle and you will see that's dated the 23rd of May. So it's slightly before the payment is made. He was going to come out the 15th of June. Uh and then over the page on page 900 we can see that that was sent to Mr. Hand uh via um a WhatsApp and then just towards the bottom of that page Mr. Hand says I will go to the embassy tomorrow and see what happens. The the punchline from that visit is as I understand it that he was told he would not be able to uh get a visa within time. And so what then happened is KJM itself arranged for a third-party surveyor uh and uh and then repeatedly wrote to Mr. Ivankovich and Mr. Hand asking them if uh Admiral Marine and Mr. Hung in particular um uh was an acceptable choice of surveyor. So we get to the uh early July, everybody knows that the survey is being carried out. And then when the chronology picks up again in in the chron in the digital record of the um of the communications, there's a telling absence of references to the report whatsoever. Uh Mr. Ivankovich uh and Mr. Hand do not at any point uh in the summer or autumn of 2023 ask to review a copy of the report. Um what they focused on instead are financing issues and the next stage of the purchase and onward sale process. And the reason that the discussion moved on is because the report had been provided. Further, everybody was happy with the report and for the reasons we've just briefly looked at. The only question is whether or not Mr. Vankovich would be able to free up enough liquidity to be able to forward the balance so that delivery could happen. So my pleaded case offers a court uh two paths through this issue. The first is that um the court makes a factual finding that the report was handd delivered. Uh the second is that the court finds that contessor wave its rights uh under clause 2B to u u consider whether or not this was a satisfactory report. Uh now Mr. Watson challenges so moving on then to the waiver argument. Mr. Watson challenges that that point is open to me as a matter of contraction interpretation by references to clauses 9 and 15 of the contract. Uh I understood him to be saying this morning that really he focuses on clause 15. Uh and uh clause 9 adds uh adds nothing to clause 15. Now, clause 15 is a fairly typical oral, no oral bonification clause. Uh, let's just turn that back up so you can have a look at it. That is page 900 six. Now there is nothing in clause 15 um expressly addressing the issue of waiver. uh [clears throat] and indeed it is well established and the parties so the parties agree on the leading authority in this area as being MW business exchange and rock advertising which a Supreme Court case from 2024 and I again I need not to take you there but in that case we'll see in closing that the uh the leading judgments given from Lord Sumption with whom all the other u justices of the Supreme Court agree um he made uh uh his principal finding is that no oral modification clauses are in principle binding on parties. Um he then goes on to expressly to address how English law protects a party who acts on a contract as varied but finds itself unable to enforce a variation because of a clause such as clause 15. The answer in English law is that there is a safeguard through various doctrines of estoppel and completeness assumption there's the answer in uh other legal systems which I know that your honor is is very familiar with uh it it's through concepts of contractual good faith. So we of course have an English law disputes here and so it's through the doctrines of estoppel uh that we rely upon uh the test that set out by Lord Sumption and I'll just give you the page reference it but it's in a different bundle so we need not turn it up it's it's my authorities bundle page 356 the test that the court applies when considering whether or not we have u u uh Aristopple of the type here being engaged is one there must have been some words or conduct >> sorry I'm sorry the reference >> excuse me let me >> for rock I'm not sure that's right is in the supplemental bundle is it >> so your honor should have been sent uh my an authorities bundle by uh me and a list of by >> uh if if I can if I if I can um assist here. What happened is that Pinser Mason's that is Mr. Page's solisters supplied his authorities and a composite authorities bundle was prepared which is the supplemental bundle which contains both of our authorities. >> Okay. And that is that is the bundle that your honor has and which I I understood it was agreed we'd all be working from. I wasn't aware that Mr. Page uh intended to rely on his old bundle. >> Okay. Well, I need I need the reference. Then we need to translate that reference to the supplemental bundle. I don't have in fact >> the claimments bundle uh the defendants bundle. >> And my problem is slightly more fundamental. I'm afraid I wasn't aware of this supplemental bundle at all until it's just now been mentioned. Um, so if that could be forwarded to me, I'd be very grateful. >> So, let well, let's see if we can find uh >> which paragraph uh Lawrence, >> it's paragraph 16 and uh yes, it's principally paragraph 16 of the uh NWB case. >> Okay. That that that is page 728 of the supplemental part. >> 728. This is for my reference at the moment. Okay. And paragraph 16. Okay. I I have that right. Thank you both of you for your help. >> 728. Yes. And as I say, it it would be helpful if somebody could send me the papers that that you just go from the internal pageionation of the law report uh Mr. Page and then we'll sort things out perhaps over the short adj. >> Yes. Uh so internal pageionation then we have uh well paragraph pageionation u uh >> par 16. >> Yes. In fact we we can scroll back slightly and just build up the point. Uh but I don't want to detain us too for too long here. Um paragraph paragraph one of the judgment. >> Yeah. >> Uh so here we have uh Lord Sumption. Um it's clear that he's um giving a um a a judgment with which everyone else agrees. um four yes I think that's count to five judges there uh uh backing up that we have two fundamental issues of law uh the first then is dealing with this no oral modifications clause his first key finding is that uh it uh uh these are in principle binding and then at paragraph 16 he uh he sets out the consequence of that uh point to the conclusion itself is a paragraph 15. >> Mhm. >> What the parties to such a clause have agreed is not that oral variations are forbidding forbidden but that they will be invalid. I said at six there. >> Yep. Uh and uh then at paragraph 16, it may just be simplest if you want to read whole paragraphs to yourself. Okay. Yeah. I mean, you're relying upon the sentence between G&H in England. The safeguard against injustice lies in the various doctrines of a stopworn. >> Precisely. >> Yeah. Okay. >> And and then at the top of the next page, we have the the two Roman numerals which set out the test. >> Yes. >> Yes. >> And and that was what I was just starting to articulate for you there. So it's it's a two-stage test. And we say here that the test is plainly satisfied. Um [clears throat] Mr. Avankovic and then Moreno repeatedly assured KJM that payment of the 2.4 million was coming. Um [clears throat] we have at uh some examples here uh page 1,16 106. And you'll see there this an exchange with uh Arouch Hibberad Waller who's going to be one of the witnesses I call uh uh this week. Uh he's asking Mr. Vanovich um uh what's happening effectively with the payment for the Aquilla vessel and Mr. says we'll send when I land. This is an exchange in September 2023. So on my client's case, approximately a month or so after the report has been provided. There's no comment here about um uh the report, this is a promise to send payment. Uh and we have a similar statement uh at page 1146 of the bundle. Sorry, just there. It's obviously difficult to uh interpret some of these WhatsApps. Yes, of course. So, and the payment schedule for 70 Aquilla. That's what you're referring to. >> Yes. So, >> so that's that's Mr. Hydra Bad. And where's the response to that? >> If we just go back to >> We'll send we'll send when I land. >> Yes, we'll send it. I've got it. Yeah. Okay. I've got I've got I've got it. Yeah. Now I see what you're relying on. And page 1146. >> Yeah. This is We're now looking at um Mr. Hiad Waller's phone I believe. So it's it's the green now is is Mr. Hrad Waller and the white is Mr. Anvankovich. >> Yes. >> And we see there at the bottom of the page as far as the balance of the payment for the 70 Aquilla it has already set up and will go in order of the others. I will let you know when. So we have promises by words to make payment and KJM acted on those promises. uh in particular at this part of it paid over large additional sums to Sino Eagle to keep the purchase alive. You have Mr. Jasmine's evidence uh page 97 of the bundle where he refers to making 400,000 dollars of payments about 49. Yes. >> 49. And then we have uh the bank statements themselves starting at 1632 running from there through to 1639 of the bundle. So if I can ask just to scroll up slightly to get to the top of the There we are. So 63 >> uh sorry I'm looking I'm looking at page 16. So I'm not actually looking at the EP. I'm looking at the the original. So >> of course >> 1631 you start with >> if we start with 1631 that's an account statement and then we have here account name KJM. >> I can see that. >> Yeah. Uh and so these then are payments out by KJ and Marine to Sino Eagle with payment reference Aquilla. >> So I mean there had been earlier payments um uh that are that are forwarding the original money just for completeness those are at uh 16 uh 27. Here is the the meter starting point. So that's a million dollars that is paid out on the 30th of May. So the chronology is at 26th of May. >> Sorry, where? So I forgive me I'm just wrong. Of course, we've been page 16 >> 1627 of the bundle >> 1627 >> and in terms of the the chronology you want to just uh before you look at that document we have um the arrangements for the visit being made on the 23rd of May. The payment itself is on the by by um Glen Co family 20s on the 26th of May and then on the 30th of May we then have the payment out by KJM through to Simon Eagle. That was initially >> okay let me just get that. So this is these are actually dearham payments. >> Yes. And then but if you look at the narration on the >> Yes. 1 million 1 million at three. Yeah. Yeah. [clears throat] I've got there >> and then various different associated charges I suspect around that. >> So 1627. >> Yeah. And the uh we then have some other another small payment at 1630 that was $97. Yes. >> But then we have large a larger payment on the 9th of October 2023. That's 1632 of $27,000. The next large payment is at page 13. Sorry, prepare with me. Of course, 1632. Uh 27,000. Yeah, I got it. Okay, >> then uh 1634. And if you turn that up, it is in the middle of the page. It's the large the second largest payment there. We'll start with uh of 184,000 dirhams which is $50,000. >> Yes. >> And at the bottom of that page, a further payment on the same date of $145,000. Mhm. And turning over page to 1637. Yeah. We then have the final large payment of uh $588,000 plus some change made on the 13th of March 2024. So what we see in the chronology is Mr. Ivankovich promising to make payments and the KJM effectively forward paying Sino Eagle to keep the transaction alive. >> Yeah. It's not 400,000 though is it? >> No. In fact, the number comes to a lot more than that. Comes to 800,000. So we we will in closing uh just a bit of a discussion about whether or not the starting point for me is a million versus $1.6 million. But the the numbers on the bank statements uh show that in in round terms it it's about $1.85 million is paid out by my client. Mhm. Having received $1.6 million. Yeah. And uh the position then carries on through to July and August. Um and uh that is at page 1321 of your bundle. there correspondence leading up to this point but I'll show that it's a effectively lead to new more so we have two days here before the forfeit is the deposit is being forfeited and Mr. Moore of Moren Co who are the solicitors or the the legal representatives of Mr. Mr. Vankovich uh is saying that that Mr. Vanovich does wish to close on the purchase of Equilla. Then open this page um is looking for um some more information and indeed a further inspection. Now we say in fact that's just playing for time by this point. But we do nonetheless have um further statements that he wishes to proceed. Okay. So you're on the it's common ground that the second transfer wasn't made and the dispute is over why Contessa didn't do so and the stand back reason uh we say that in reality drives what's happened throughout this whole period is that is Mr. Vankovich's liquidity which came under increasing strain through 2023 and 2024 and [clears throat] it was nothing to do with reports or anything else like that and the whole argument on reports has been constructed right at the death in an effort to scramble around and try to recover the 1.6 million dollars. [clears throat] Now I make the point about Mr. rank which is um liquidity uh somewhat neutally and I don't make any criticism of him personally. It's simply the explanation on the documents as to why we've ended up the condition we've ended up. Um [clears throat] but as it is Mr. Rankovich gave a series of promises that he would make payments. He didn't uh follow through on that. He raised no concerns about the survey until July 2024. uh and he cannot fairly turn around now and rely on clause 2B. Um yes, I'm quite interested I'm quite interested in KGM's relationship with the yard if if I haven't I haven't read into the correspondence on that. The short answer, your honor, is that there is uh that there are some exchanges between KJM and the yard, but not many uh in disclosure. Uh what there is you will be taken to, I'm sure, between Mr. Watson and I in the course of evidence. >> Okay. I shall I shall I shall uh curb my enthusiasm and uh >> um what I >> So what I can say is that you asked Mr. reports very fairly whether or not there's a contract between KGM and Sino Eagle. Uh and we we neither of us are able to produce that for the court um today. So what we have instead are the emails um such as they are between KGM and Sino. [snorts] So two further two fin little points on contestants uh claim uh the first concerns um whether or not uh the $1.6 million uh is returnable if the survey can be rejected. Um again this is a point that we'll go in a little more detail in closing but the point is narrow and essentially it comes down to proper construction of clause five of the contract which is at page 255 of the bundle chronological run 94 four of your bundle. So we say that clause 5 is engaged where KJM chooses not to buy the vessel. It's not engaged where Contessa itself declines to fund the balance. And it's part and parcel effectively of the discretionary power given to contessa under clause 2B. If it exercises its discretion and is entitled to do so and just simply doesn't pay over the balance, well then it has to live with the consequences of that. It can't then say, "I don't I don't like this survey. I don't like this yacht, but I want my money back. Uh, and and part of that is that we what we don't have here is a tripartite contract with the manufacturer itself. So, there's an obvious >> Yes. I mean, it does seem it does seem odd that uh the yacht can take the money and run and then and then sell and then sell the yacht on. Uh I mean I can understand a claim for any losses that it may have in relation to uh differences in in purchase price but but actually just just taking 1.6 million seems very strange to me where there it is. Um but certainly as on this contract um we we um >> we have the argument we have the commercial allocation of risk >> uh between uh contestant and KGM on the point. >> Yes. No, I see I see your point. Who whether who who who bears that risk? Yes. [clears throat] >> And then finally on the um on the short point that contestant did not itself pay anything. Now I I accept Mr. Watson makes a entirely fair point that that uh um the previous air silicon test paid. Um the point slightly blurs between claim one and claim two. Uh because the $1.6 million undoubtedly did come from a different company and this is now being revealed through the disclosure process. uh and that of course blends in to the the the true commercial sector here in that that Mr. Avankovich uh effectively has a large number of corporate vehicles which are used interchangeably from time to time as and when uh to effectively has different piggybacks. I hope the word is seen as being majority. >> They were they were not the contracting party contest was >> but precise they were not the contracting party and it's been contested to show that it suffered or not. Um on the counter claim um both parties agree that that that if contestant was not entitled to withhold the money then KJM uh has effectively won on the liability part of it countered claim. There is then a quantum issue and we have suffered a financial loss. We've suffered a a a direct financial loss of money we paid out to the sign of eagle which we have it ourselves not seeing back and we'll have a debate as whether that's 200,000 400,000 or 800,000. Uh secondly, we've lost the benefit of our bargain which was to sell the yacht onwards for a profit and inevitably the the discussions about sale onward sale of the vessel never got tremendously advanced because we never had delivery of it. But there were nonetheless some offers which came through. uh and uh it might be helpful here just to have a look at my skeleton argument. I >> I have done and I I'm looking at the time uh and you've only got 20 minutes really to deal with the JV and I have looked at your skeleton argument. I've seen that there were two >> it works in your skeleton. >> Thank you. um in which case then I'd like to move on to the joint venture and and my plan is at this stage to take it uh more quickly um because we'll need to do a fuller page turn of the author relationship I think to to deal with some of the detail there. >> Yeah. >> Um Mr. Rankovich is Mr. Ranovich asks the court in his personal claim to make a declaration um that the termination was invalid. Um uh as I uh had understood it there is uh there is no procedural debate about between the parties as to how many of the grounds are open to me. Uh I I pursue five. We have the chapter 11 solveny point the material change in Mr. Rankovich's affairs and perhaps just dealing with these in headlines. The chapter 11 insolveny. >> Yes, >> that that is KA3 of the contract. Material change is clause JB3 of the contract. The late payment under the JVA is under clause KA1 of the contract and the fact that it was belatedly cured doesn't mean we lost our acred right and I that proposition comes from supermax off Malhhatra um yes for uh the failure in August 2024 to fund the factory lease and license and five the failure to market and sell the vessels which were manufactured uh or being manufactured. That's clauses EA and EB. Now in the Mr. uh Watson's pleading. We have uh acceptance that procedurally these points were equal to me. That's at page 563 of the bundle. So uh paragraph uh 34 is where the the issue starts. The alleged termination was not lawful or valid for the reasons given. Uh and then we have denial of paragraph 40.1. uh uh and 3 in 35.1 is an acceptance that the termination notice did give written notice under JD3 but there's any substantive debate about whether or not there has been a material change in Mr. length which is business assets or company structure. Uh 36 piece of the KA1 point about uh paper branches again termination notice did give written notice under KA1 and then Um the one point which is taken against me is a paragraph 38.1 on the marketing selling of the vessels but u that said not to have been given notice as I understand Mr. what to be saying, but the um [clears throat] he has something to say about this, but he he's able to deal with these problems on the facts. In any event, as I say, we'll get into the detail of all of this in due course, but the reality is that uh the the chapter open proceedings were themselves driven by Mr. language is uh um divorce proceedings. That's a finding made by the uh a judge in the Florida courts. And we had really two things which happened in 2023. Uh the first of those was a very large commercial bet that Mr. Vankovich made for the purchase of a Sunseeker yacht um for over $11 million that was not sold. There was a hope that that would be sold in September 2023. Uh and secondly, we have a series of uh um orders being made by the courts and steps being taken by the Vanovich companies um to protect themselves from the divorce proceedings. All of that cuts down on Mr. Vanovich's liquidity. All of that amounts to triggers under clauses J and K of the contract. All of this came to life in the summer of 2024 shortly before uh the notice of termination was issued. Uh so those are going to be the liability points for the joint venture agreement. Uh but on the final question of if I lose on liability is called the question of was was the termination validly made or will be entitled to terminate. Uh I say this is not a case where declaratory relief should be granted or certainly not uh of [clears throat] the scale and scope contemplated uh in the draft or appended to mana friend's skeleton argument. Um I've mentioned to you already the memorandum association and this is the last substantive point I wish to um discuss in my opening. So just again you're right just to sit back slightly we have the joint venture appointment itself which was um executed in uh March 2023 that is at uh page 881 one and it is right that this contemplates the establishment of KJI the joint venture company. So we go from KJM to KJI. Um perhaps the witnesses can confirm this for us but u at least Jay and I I take it to be Jasmine and Ivankovich Mr. Graphy who sits in the background for the K. Uh so the original contemplation in the joint venture agreement was that they would create a new company called KJI and [clears throat] uh it would have uh management structures as contemplated the joint venture agreement. So page 88 uh let's see uh story page 883 of the bundle. So we have the division of profits and expenses uh as allocated there on a 50/50 basis between uh Mr. Bankovich and KJM. Um then over the page on 884 of how um authority would be delegated between the parties on a day-to-day basis then board of directors and clause F three directors um initially Mr. Vanovich Mr. Al Chasmi and an independent director and then uh access the books and records of uh clause H. That what is what was contemplated but then all the parties signed up the memorandum association which is at page 1038 and there's no challenge to the lawfulness of this document. It's no it's not said to be juress or unilateral state or anything of that nature. Uh and this put in place different governance provisions for the joint venture company. So we have here still KJI Marina boats. Now we have the contracting parties being KJM, Mr. Rankovich and Mr. Al Jasmine personally and effectively the KJM interest being split in half. So now it's 25% KJM 25% Mr. Al Jasmine uh and Mr. If I van keeps his 50% and uh this puts in place a sole direship um arrangement. We can pick up look at equivalent clauses uh page 1053. 1053. Yes. So that's our profit share. So Mr. Bankovich hasn't been >> Sorry. Can we just Sorry. So sorry, sorry. Sorry. Let's need to take this a bit more slowly. >> Uh sorry. This so where do you say the sole directorship is? >> So I I actually I've slightly jumped on. I thought better just to show you the the counterpart of what I've given you. >> No, no, no. Better. Let's let's go to the sole directorship. >> That is 1043. >> 1043. Okay, that's article 9. >> Yes. >> Right. Let's have a look at that point. So use the words director and manager. >> Yes. >> Yes. I mean uh UAE companies have general managers who may or may not be directors and they usually have powers of attorney pretty much in terms like this. Where does it say that he should be the sole director? >> Well, it it appoints him as director. It doesn't appoint anyone else as director. >> I know that. Uh and indeed the actual J executive director and that was going to be Mr. Jasmine. So it may be said against you that this is actually appointing him the executive director in accordance with the JVA. [clears throat] Hence the expression manager and all of these powers. Well we we say it is more exclusive than that because this would have been the document in which other directors were to be appointed also. [clears throat] >> Um >> okay where do I see that? So what we what we all so we get the appointment and management powers at article nine which are wide ranging then article article 10 the company's director in the uh in the singular uh yes let's have a look for some reason >> that's at page 105. >> I'm having I'm I'm sorry. I'm having problems again that I had before with pages disappearing. 10 500 of the bundle. >> 105. That's Yeah, that's gone blank for me for some reason. That's annoying. Let me see if if I change. Ah, okay. If I I've got it now. If I change the magnification, it goes back. So the company's director shall prepare. So what are what am I looking at? Article 10. >> Article 10. >> But I also recollect a a reference to a board of directors. There's the 111 there. Company shall have a general assembly composed of all partners. General Assembly shall be convened at the invitation of the director or board of directors. So it contemplates there also being a board of directors. So we have and this will be a point I'm sure we'll come back to in closing. Uh but just to track through the term direct that starts at page 1039. 1039. Sorry, forgive me. Yeah. So we have to have any appointment being pursuant to this memorandum. [clears throat] >> Okay. Means the director or directors means the director or the director of the company appointed pursuant isn't different to what the appointment pursuant to the joint venture agreement. >> Okay. So see okay it's interesting. Yep. Then we have the management of the company governed at article nine. >> Mhm. Uh and article 92 is the term of the appointment that is renewed. Yep. >> [clears throat] >> Then article 10 we've got the we've looked at already the financial management powers of the director. >> Um article 11 this is about the convening of the general assembly. Yep. Okay, I get I get you you're a bit short of time. I don't and I've pressed you on this. So So I've got I've got the gist of of where you're going and you'll expand upon this later, but uh I now understand what you're saying. >> So what what we are Yes. Exactly. So, so we'll be saying about the memorandum of association that in effect the the parties had one agreement when they put in place the joint venture agreement about how the joint venture company would be run that was then effectively varied through the establishment of the KJI itself and its memorandum of association and that is now the governing document of the company and it's not uh rise or proper for this court to come in and say well through the JDA we now impose different arrangements on AJI because its covering document is something quite different. Um uh the court will have many times seen a a two-tier process where you have a shareholders agreement and a company uh company articles but we don't have that here. We don't have the interlocking nature in the uh in the share agreement about how people are to vote uh at general meetings. it is a different sort of structure. Um so uh all that means ultimately that that we say this is not a case for departure relief or certainly not on the scale sought by friend. Uh KGI as of now is so far as we can tell insolvent uh and uh not trading. Its audited loss for the year to 31st of December 2024 which is the most recent uh audited date is [clears throat] just short of 9 million dirhams. page reference for that is 1706. And if you just glance up on the screen, you're you'll see here this is an extract from the audit uh uh towards the bottom of that top of that page, we have the net loss of the period. Uh and then there's a range of different levels of detail uh that we'll discover uh in the orders as well. Uh, nobody wants this relationship reserved. Clearly, my client doesn't want it reserved because we terminated. Um, Mr. Vanovich makes no pretense that he wants to carry on being in business with KJM. So this is all simply about uh uh an expos facto u u uh inquiry into the governance of the company and nothing in the JVA will help him on that. He is a shareholder in KJI. He has rights under that. uh and uh >> I think he said he was denied them though. That's what we've got to have a look at I guess. >> Well, the the the reality is that that the parties are deadlocked. So that the the because they have a 50/50 vote between them, there is no tiebreaking provision. So even on basic provisions like can an auditor be appointed? Well, they can't agree on that. Uh and the the um default process under the commercial companies law have come in to resolve that. that the company can't be wound up by its members until they have a majority vote for that purpose. Um so that there is nothing at this stage that the court can declare that would bring an end to the matter and we are in a situation where where clarity relief uh is not appropriate. Now this will not be the first time indeed I think within the past year the court has um uh and you personally your honor have been asked to make your clarity relief and have declined to do so even where other elements of the case have been satisfied and I have in mind particularly the Albahara uh case and the reinsurance dispute um the facts there were different because there was a um separate set of proceedings in the charger court um but one one has an equivalent here that if the clan relief is ordered um then what uh and and um the court will find itself managing the relationship between these parties um far better. We say that that the parties confine themselves to the uh um KJI memorandum [clears throat] association that sets out their proper rights. Um there is nothing contractually that en entitles anyone to wind up the company of a different sort of application that needs to be made if that's a process that that were to happen the appointment of an administrator or a liquidator. >> Well, we can we can discuss the relief. >> We can discuss that in closing. Uh and in terms of counter claim, as Mr. Watson says we have put forward some numbers uh as to the amount of money we have put in and I'll make good those numbers uh with our um uh u with the audit report in due course um where where those numbers have been audited in terms of how much money we invested into the company. Um [clears throat] s that's all I propose to say I'm four minutes over time on my on my o >> Thank you very much indeed. Okay. Well, as I u said this morning, we'll uh adjourn for lunch now uh Dubai time uh until um 2:45 uh and uh which will be 11:45 English time. Okay. Thank you very much indeed, Mr. Watson. Yes, your honor. Uh, I am here. I'm not sure about my learning friend. Ah, Mr. Paige. >> Good afternoon, everybody. Excuse me, I had a technical issue there. >> Um, I can also say because we're due, your honor, to hear the um evidence of the two experts. I can see that Mr. folks who is expert is there. Mr. Folks, you're going second, so you you don't necessarily need to be on camera >> until you're called. Uh and then Mr. Jameson, the claimments expert, I can also see. Um and so unless um your honor has any um housekeeping matters that have arisen over the short adjournment, I propose to call Mr. Jameson. No, I'm I'm fine. I took five minutes longer than I I thought I would do. So, we'll we can make up the time at the end of the day. >> I I'm sure that'll be fine. I assume the associate is uh Yes. >> Your honor, please may I proceed with swearing in the witness? >> Yes, please. >> Thank you. Mr. Davidson, please can I confirm whether you would prefer to swear an oath or by affirming? Um, so in the oath, please. >> And can I please confirm if you have the holy book with you? >> I do. >> Thank you. Can you please confirm your name and occupation for the court's record? >> Andrew Jameson, um, yacht loss adjuster. >> Please repeat after me. I swear by >> I swear by >> the Almighty God >> the Almighty God >> that I will say nothing >> that I'll say nothing >> but the truth >> but the truth. >> Thank you very much. >> Thank you. Uh Mr. Jameson, can I ask you maybe just to sit a little bit closer to the um the camera because you're a little bit faint at least to me. Um, and just make sure that you you deliver your answers as loudly as possible. I I wonder if the EP operator could bring up page 117, which I think we're already there. Can you see that, Mr. Jameson, the document? >> Um, your honor, I can. >> Is that your report in these proceedings? >> Yes, it is. >> Can we now go to page 124? Is that your signature? Yes, it is. >> And could we now go to page 321? >> Is uh that the joint memorandum that you prepared uh jointly with Mr. Folks? >> Your honor. Yes, it is. >> And uh could we now go to page 331 on the right hand side? Is that your signature? >> Yes, it is. >> And the final question, Mr. Jameson, um, taking your report and your comments in the joint memorandum together, do they represent your true and complete professional opinion on the matters to which they refer? >> Yes, they do. >> Thank you, Mr. Jameson. If you wait there, I'm sure Mr. Paige will have some questions for you. >> Good afternoon, Mr. Jameson. Um, just on one tiny housekeeping matter before we start. Um, I don't think Mr. Folks needs to be on camera. So, probably just take his camera off. And Mr. Watson, in fact, I think probably your question for you whether you would like Mr. Watson and I both to remain on camera throughout the trial or whether we should both dip in and out uh whether or not we made submissions. >> Uh, I think councelor should remain on camera, but there's no need for Mr. Folks to remain on camera. Thank you. Um, Mr. Jameson, good afternoon. Uh, so you are a director of a loss adjusting company. Is that right? Your Yes, it is. Uh, and you just introduced yourself as a yacht loss or as a loss adjust. Is that correct? >> That is correct. And that's how you describe yourself in the reports as well. Uh, paragraph two of your report, page 117, page we're on there. Uh, I have over 12 years experience in the yacht loss adjusting sector. See that? >> Yes. >> And that's correct. >> Your Yes, it is. >> Uh, and we turn through to your CV, which is page 132 of the bundle. We can see here that you have many years of experience uh providing uh claims work for insurance after damages or insulence. Is that a fair summary? >> Uh yes it is. And uh if we just look at your previous work for Matthew Daniel the third bullet point down you survey approximately 300 yachts basically 9 year period you worked there you see that >> yes I do >> and all of [clears throat] them uh all of those inspections were linked to various forms of damage due to incidents yes your yes that's correct And uh in your work at LWI uh it's the same story. This is bullet bullet point six. Uh sending starting surveying over 100 yachts. Uh again all of those been linked to forms of damage or due to incidents. Yes, >> that is correct. Uh and your CV doesn't list any pre-ely uh condition surveys. Is that right? >> That is correct. >> So you don't have any professional experience of surveying new built yachts prior to their first delivery. Is that correct? >> That is correct. >> And if we compare this to Mr. Hung and Mr. Fox, um Mr. H you uh his CV is summarized. You can look at this at paragraph 14, page 120 of the bundle. [clears throat] And you can see there that he was holding himself out on the iM database as someone who specializes in preurchase and small craft surveys. You see that? I do. >> Yes. And and he's got a mechanical engineering degree. See that? >> Yes. >> That wasn't very clear. Your >> and and you agree that that he has a mechanical engineering degree. That's what the the website uh said and we recorded that information. >> You're he does. >> Uh now, uh Mr. Fault, let's just have a look at his CV briefly. That's page 146. And uh we can see there the first bullet point that he uh his work includes uh preurchase condition finance and insurance surveys on GRP constructed vessels under 24 meters. see that top of the page. >> You're right. I do. >> Just what does GRP mean? >> Uh glass reinforced plastic >> and that's fiberglass to Yes. Correct. >> Yeah. And fiberglass is what what we have here for the aquilla vess. >> Well, do you know that or you understand that? What's that based on? based um your honor that's based on the um the report from the admiral report stating that's what the construction material is. So we can see there that that he's been doing this work in Moranti and then industry experience uh if we go to the next section 20 years experience in uh fiberglass construction from 20 foot to 40 m and again the equivalits within that range doesn't it? It does. Yes. Thank you. We can see from Mr. Fal's report paragraph 22 which is page 139 of the bundle he starts that paragraph by saying having conducted numerous PPIs on various vessels made and models PBIS being pre-ely inspections. Um so he's saying there he's conducted lots of before. Um uh and you said he's entitled to make that statement. You don't challenge the fact that he's allowed to say that he has conducted numerous uh premium inspections. >> Correct. So you don't question either Mr. Folultz's competence or Mr. Hull's competency. Uh, your honor, no I don't. >> And do you accept that both men are more experienced than you in carrying out pre-ely inspections? >> Uh, your honor, I do. >> Uh, and, uh, when looking at ports uh, uh, and the investments for that purposes, uh, they can call on their own direct experience. Accept that? >> I do. uh and uh by contrast you cannot call them your own direct experience because you haven't changed tax service to set that >> for PDIs I I agree yes so let's move on now in terms of the yacht you haven't seen the yacht yourself have you >> I have not and nor has anyone from your organization correct um what you have looked at are six documents and you list them at paragraph 13 if you uh uh three pleadings a case memorandum to report you see that page 120 do you recall that >> I do so you haven't looked at any with the statements that right >> uh that is correct >> we haven't looked at any party correspondence Correct. >> Sorry, can you repeat? Apologies. >> You you you haven't looked at any correspondence between the parties. Is that right? Is that right? >> That is correct. >> And uh do you recall that your instructions invited you to uh uh ask for documents if you wanted it? If you wanted them. >> Um yes. And we see that at page 129 of the bundle, paragraph 3.4, it's a long second sentence, but starts in the second line towards the end. It says, "Please do let us know as soon as possible." That follows on from if you want more documents. So, some of the documents you haven't seen include Admiral's uh Admiral Marines engagement terms. Do do you accept that you haven't seen those? >> I don't believe I've seen them. Yeah. And we can see that at page 328 of the bundle. See the first box on the page with your comments. So without sight of the terms of engagement, I'm unable to comment. Yeah. Yeah. And uh so you didn't see them, you didn't ask for them. Uh and uh do you feel we needed to see them? >> Um I don't believe I needed to see them because >> Sorry, your honor. Um I didn't I didn't believe I needed to see them um because it I believe it fell outside of the scope of the questions asked. Well, the the matters not agreed there at Admiral Marine's engagement terms in red, but you you you chose not to look at them in order not to be able to copy. That's a fair summary, isn't it? Jameson, can you hear me? >> Yeah. Sorry. Can you can you please repeat the question if that's okay? >> Yes. You you chose not to look at those documents or call for them in order not to be able to comment on that point. That's a fair comment. >> Um yes, your honor, because I felt it um was outside of the necessity to comment on it. Do you read the entirety of Mr. Thomas's report? >> Sorry, the apologies. Uh, your your audio. The entirety of which report, your honor? >> Mr. Folultz's report. Um, I read the um main body of the report associated to the um or surrounding my my instructions and fair to say skim read some of the extended version of the report that fell outside of my my my question should I say. So you've come to give evidence today having not actually read uh your uh the entirety of the report of your colleague who's also giving evidence to the court. Is that what you're saying? I read the entirety of the port but concentrated on the the elements of of the uh the condition of the vessel and and the the main sections because there were from from my recollection there was um uh comments uh concerning the um witness statements which is something I I or the interactions with companies that I it was not part of my instruction or questions. Did you have a look at his appendix? >> Um, are you able to bring it up if that's okay, sir? >> Well, um, I think the first page, page 149. Does that ring about? >> Yes, that does. Yes. So you you read as a >> Yes, you are. If we turn to uh page 279, this is page 130 of his appendix. And you'll see it is the uh the engagement terms from Admiral. You see that? >> I do see that, your honor. >> So, if you read this document, uh, have to say if the court you didn't see it, >> I don't recall seeing that document before, your honor. >> So, do you want to change your evidence as to whether or not you have in fact read the uh the government's exhibited Mr. Fox is import straightforward question. Did you give a truthful answer when you said you'd read the documents uh that the citizens see Mr. Fox report? >> Yes, I I did give a truthful answer. Yes. But you except you were mistaken because here we have the uh the engagement terms from Admiral and you told me previously you hadn't seen this. Like I said I I I concentrated on the report that was um for the items in Mr. folks report that were that were um necessary for for the questions that were that were asked in my my my terms of engagement. And so I I'm I'm sure I may have seen this before, but I I I didn't um should we say pay any um pay any time to it, so to speak. >> Okay. Well, let's look at it now then, shall we? Uh >> yeah. Yeah. >> So the admiral, this is their quotation. You can see on the uh on the page in front of you and you can see that Admiral was saying they conduct a pre- delivery condition survey and seat trial. You see that top of the page? >> Yes. >> Yes. And and I see they're going to spend three days carrying out the task. Yes. >> Yes. Uh now if we turn over the page uh the terms and conditions of service uh top paragraph read that to yourself there please your honor. Yes. >> So that's a task he set himself. And now the the third paragraph, just the first sentence, the survey will be a factual report on the inspection carried out and the opinions expressed will be given in good faith as to the condition of the vessel as seen at the time of the survey. Yes. >> Yes. Uh next paragraph uh first sentence. This report carries no warranty regarding ownership of the vessel or any warranty regarding outstanding mortgage charge or other debt there may be on the vessel. It's not interesting the financial aspects. Yes. Yes. Next paragraph. This report will not address stability vessel performance or overall design and no warranty is conveyed under these headings. Yes. Yes. So in short, the survey was all about the condition of the vessel. In no sense was Admiral Marine going to be providing a recommendation whether or not to purchase the vessel. Yes. Yes. Okay. Uh who is the uh report going to be addressed? >> Sorry, can you repeat your question please? Do you know who the report was going to be addressed to? >> Um I believe uh KJ Marine. >> Okay. And so second paragraph on this page 218. The report will be prepared specifically for the clients and that's KJM Marie. Yes. >> Yes. uh and is for their use only. It remains the copyright of atmie. Yes. >> Yes. So the the concept behind the report is that uh this uh surveyor will carry out a full survey into the condition of the vessel. Yes. >> Yes. >> Uh and uh that's then provided to KJM and KJM only. Yes. I I believe so. Yes. >> Uh with uh any commercial decision about whether what to do with the vessel after that is a matter for the client. Yes. >> Yes. >> Let's have a look now at uh another report you uh you may or may not have seen and that's a Volvo Penta CR uh report. Have you seen that before? I believe I have >> you have seen that. Okay. So that's I've not listed in the six document search uh paragraph 13 of the report. Going to have a look at that again. That was back at uh page 120 of the bundle. So you see it's not there. Yes. So, when did you see the volvo report? Um, sorry. Can I, your honor, can I clarify when you say the Volvo Penta report, do you mean the Admiral report that comments on the C trial >> or is this a separate report? Apologies. So, so this this is the um it's the C trial document from December 2022. I can show you a copy of it if you like if you could go >> to to page uh 858. Ah, no apologies, your honor. I've not seen that report. Um I I assuming that you were talking about the sea trial section in the um the admiral report. Apologies I've not seen this report. >> Okay. So this is the first time you've seen this document. >> That is correct. >> Okay. Now this document was also exhibited to Mr. Faltz's report. Are you aware of that? >> Uh I wasn't aware of that. So when again when you said you had been through the exhibit uh for Mr. Foster report is that actually correct? >> Um it is but I don't remember seeing this document. >> Well let's have just have a look at it in that version. That's page 259 of the bundle. Now before we look at this again um do you know the relevance of this report? Why would anyone be looking at this report? >> Um sorry can you understand um can you clarify um what my the question as in when you say the relevance of it? Well, why might anyone be interested in conducting a sea trial into this vessel? >> Oh, to to sorry, your honor. In order to be able to ensure that the the vessel is operating as per specifications of of the vessel. So you said there's quite an important point that uh is it mechanically working uh is a is a fundamental question when it comes to the the um um uh extent to which this vessel is ready to be delivered. Correct. >> Uh Mr. Folks the report, didn't you? >> Sorry I you're you're you keep cutting out apologies. Can you I'm I'm I'm very sorry. Uh do you know that Mr. Folks looked at the report? >> Did I know if Mr. Folks had looked at this report? >> Yes. >> Uh I'm not aware of it. >> Well, let's have a look at paragraph 18 of his report. I think just pause there, Mr. Jameson. I think it might be due to the background noise of my air conditioning. I'm going to turn that off and then maybe you'll hear it better. Paragraph 18 of his report, page 138 of the bundle. If you read the whole of that paragraph to yourself, Please. Thank you. And do you see there that he's has looked at both the admiral report and the sea trial data and it's taking a holistic view of the two documents that he concluded that a full PDI was conducted with all aspects of the vessel reported on. Yes. >> Uh yes. >> So do you agree that his conclusion was based on more evidence than yours? Um, yes, I I do. >> Let's have a look at the document again. We'll take it back at page 858, please. Page 859, we can see here that the length is u 21 m. Yes. Yes, you're right. >> Uh, and over the page 860, we can see that the temperature, the ambient air temperature when it was tested was 5° centigrade. Yes. >> Uh, yes, Ron. >> And do you know the temperature uh the ambient air temperature when uh the admiral report survey was carried out? I believe it was about 34 degrees, your runner. >> So quite a lot higher. >> Yes. >> So it's two tests in very different conditions. You accept that? >> I do. >> Uh and uh we see here also page 860 it describes a new boat. Yes. >> Uh yes. And over the page, page 861, the text is very small. But if we zoom in on the top table, uh, under full throttle, headwind or upstream, the boat speed got up to 26.4 knots. Yes. >> Yes, Charlie. and downstream which is a third table we got up to 27.1 knots. Do you see that? >> I do. >> And then the two little tables, we can see them on the page in front of you. Uh we have both the port and starboard engines being uh the RPM they're being calculated and a few other elements uh at uh full throttle. You see that? >> I do. and all of that matches the expectations of these engines. Do you accept that? >> Um I I I assume that that's what the parameters are. Well, let's look back at the uh the engine data 859. You see there the the engine serial numbers and engine types are stated. >> Yes. Yes. And uh uh do you think it's possible to go go off and research what the performance specifications are for uh uh these engine types? >> I do. >> Yeah. Uh and that's not a step you have taken though. >> No. >> No. Okay. So you can't help the court as whether or not uh the performance is in line with the expected performance. Is that is that fair? That is fair to accept that you could have reviewed the information in these two documents I've just shown to you. The Volvo report and the uh the quotation for Admiral Marine. >> Um I could have done had I asked for them. >> Yes. Or indeed if you just simply look through Mr. Fox's report in detail. Yes. Uh, and if you had done that, that would have provided you with further information and evidence about the jets. Correct. >> Correct. Now, let's look at the admiral report itself. Um, so I think you you've already um accepted that um this survey type is within his listed capability. This is a vessel 21 m it's and his capabilities are up to 24 meters. We saw that earlier. You agree with that? >> I do. >> Yes. Uh and uh if we have a look there at page 936, please. We can see on page one he summarizes his instructions and he says that he attended uh the Cathan over the for five days from the 6th to the 10th of July. You see that? >> I do. >> Then on the next page he gives some data about the vessel. >> Yes. >> Yes. And um the bottom row there on the on paragraph two gives an expected speed of 28 knots. You see that? >> I do. >> And uh the the engines are by Volvo Penta which explains why it was Volvo Penta carrying out the earlier uh inspection. Yes. >> Yes. >> Uh and then uh the next few pages we have photos of the arrangement of the yacht. You see, excuse me, diagrams of that. You see that? >> I do. >> So, it's over three levels. Yes. >> Um Yes. On on the plan. Yes. >> Um then on page 941, he gives a a published uh a grading scale. Um and you see he gives a reason for why he's doing that. is to achieve consistency of reporting. Yes. >> Yes. >> So that when he uses the word good, everyone knows what he means by the word good. [clears throat] Correct. >> Yes. Correct. >> And same for satisfactory. Yes. >> Yes. >> Same for fair. Yes. >> Yes. >> Same for unsatisfactory. >> Correct. >> And also for poor. >> Yes. >> Thank you. Uh page 942 if we stay at the top there. Uh he is starting his note section and he's being clear there that that he's reporting on the condition and state of the vessel uh in his opinion as found during his inspection. Yes. Yes. >> And he's not making any assumptions about works which might happen to the vessel in the future. Yes. >> Correct. >> And that's entirely in line with with your professional understanding of what surveyors would do. >> Yes. >> Correct. Yes. >> Uh and uh he's also saying here that when he's reporting on the condition state of the vessel, he's comparing it with vessels of a similar age and type. Yes. >> Correct. Uh and we see here we've already talked about who the report was prepared for and we now get paragraph two uh effectively the handshake of the terms of engagement. The report has been prepared specifically for KJM Marie. You see that? >> Yes, I do. >> And it was drafted up on the final day of inspection of 10th of July. Yes. >> Correct. >> And it's for its use only for KJM's uh use only. Yes. >> Yes. And in your professional experience, that's entirely conventional that a surveyor is writing its report for its client and not for a third party. >> That is correct. >> And if a third party wanted to rely on the report in some formal way, they would have to engage the surveyor separately. Yes. >> Um, correct. >> Thank you. the then if we turn over the page starting at 944 we then have a deckby- deck inspection and this is setting up effectively the detail of his work. You accept that description >> of the of the way it's set out? I do. Yes. Uh and with uh the headline view, the top of 944 we have the main deck and that inspection goes through to 945. Then we have the lower deck starting at 946 and the transom deck is a 947. the fly bridge 948 and then we have uh other matters being looked at from 949 onwards. So firefighting equipment. Yes. You see that? >> Yes. >> Tank capacities. Yes. >> Yes. >> Machinery and equipment. Yes. >> Yes. >> And then the condition of hull. Yes. >> Yes. And then general conditions and overall comments. Let's see that right at the end of 952. Yes. Yes. So let's just look at a few small ones there. Uh the I'm only going to look at the ones which are potentially contentious. Uh on page 947 you see there at the top of that page uh he's saying air conditioner we're bastom marine type air handling unit that's a description of the mechanical unit he test he observed correct >> uh yes >> and then tested and operational means that he tested it and he found it to be operational. Yes. >> Yes. Uh and we can compare that with item 12 uh where it says not tested for PowerPoint. See that? >> Yes. >> Yes. And [clears throat] uh and for some items uh rather than the word operational the word good is used sometimes. We see that for example at page 11. >> Yes. >> You see that? >> I do. And and again, do you agree with me that when when he's using the word good, he must be using it in the word he has already told the reader he'll be using it. Back at page 941, >> you want to Yes. >> Thank you. Uh if we then look at a couple of points want to flag up here um the firefight equipment and life-saving appliances. If we just have a look at that at 949 and we can see there that some of those are not cited or not fitted. You see that? >> I do. >> And the fact that he's um reporting that is not seen shows rigor this report. You agree to that? >> Um yes. We then on the machinery page of 950 uh item one if you look uh it's actually the second paragraph starting engine hours in the middle of that cell. >> Do you see that? >> Yes, I do. >> Engine hours port 9.2 and starboard 9.4 hours. Is that a description of how many hours of usage the uh the engines have had >> up until the point of the survey? Yes. >> Yes. Exactly. Uh and uh and he's also saying just above that that he found that the uh during the sea trial he got the port engine to 2,410 RPM and the starboard engine to 2430 RPM. Yes. Yes. >> Going to knots of the 28.1 knots. You see that? >> I do. >> Yes. So, uh, so far this is all consistent with the data we saw from the Volvo Penta survey. Yes. >> Yes. >> And that was had been taken six months earlier. Correct. >> Seven months earlier. >> Apologies that I didn't see the date of the Volvo Penser. >> Oh, in fact, eight months earlier. But I'm correcting myself here. Uh let's just have a look at that briefly. That is uh back at page 857, excuse me, it's 858. So towards the bottom of this page. So we see there trial 1st of December 2022. You see that? >> I do. Yes. >> Yes. And then and we now know that eight months later, the engines are achieving [clears throat] the same output. Uh and there's been almost no usage of this vessel. Um well, perhaps no usage whatsoever of this vessel. Um back at 950, you can see that. >> Yes. Uh and if we look at uh item five on this page, generator uh the generator hour usage is port 61 me 61 hours, starboard 57 hours. Yes, >> your yes. >> And um just pausing here, both of these figures at item one, item five, these are all entirely consistent with this being a brand new vessel that's been sitting in solo equals yard. Correct. >> I I don't I I can't comment on on other vessels. >> I'm not asking to comment other vessels. I'm saying this vessel the data that's been provided this and the fact there's been no change for 8 months in uh uh in output and the fact that the number of hours of usage of the engine uh remains very low by July 2023 suggests that this no one has been using this vessel between December 2022 and July 2023. You accept that? >> Your honor, I do. Uh and uh would you also accept that the um the generator has barely been turned on during this period given the hours of usage at 61 hours and 57 hours? Yes, >> your honor. Yes. >> So is it fair to infer from the 8-month period between the first and second reports that uh the the vessel has been stored in a way that has preserved its condition? Yes. Um your honor, no I don't agree with that. >> No. Why not? >> Why not? Um because if you're storing a vessel for such a time period, um there's no comments on how the generator engines or actually the vessel's engines have been winterized and preserved. Um if for example you have an an item of machinery that is effectively in humid humid temperate conditions there is an an element where you can get an increase of corrosion built up on the internal surfaces of the engine components. Um and when you effectively operate the vessel after such a long period of time without dewinterizing it had it been winterized um you're not preserving the internals of this um of the vessel. >> So does Mr. Hong identify any corrosion in his report? >> He does not. >> So um do you consider there had been any corrosion or not? Um I'm using the basis of my experience um when I see mainly superyachts not moving for for many many months um they have um without winterization or or pre or routine lubrication of the um engine surfaces um there has been and I've seen buildup of corrosion in the in similar situations. >> Well Mr. Mr. Jameson, with respect, we we're trying to help uh u his honor, Judge Black with this yacht, not a different yacht. So, we have a snapshot of its mechanical working order in December 2022. You've accepted that. Grizz? >> I agree. >> And we have a a very detailed report of its condition in July 2023. Correct. >> Correct. And we have seen here that the mechan mechanical condition is uh unchanged. Yes. >> From the performance. Yes. >> And we've seen that the generator has been tested and operational. Yes. >> Yes. >> We've seen that the usage has been almost non-existent between those two uh snapshots in time. Yes, >> your honor. Yes. And uh and we've there's no mention of corrosion in this report. Yes. >> Correct. >> So it's fair to assume there hasn't been corrosion. Yes. >> I I can't comment on on how the vessel or the vessel's machinery has been stored from the Volvo Penta um seat trial report or the sea trial in December through to the condition survey in July. >> Well, Mr. Jameson, you can comment on whether or not you consider this to be a full complete and accurate report. Uh the ad whether you consider the admiral report to be full, complete, and accurate. Do you consider it to be full, complete, and accurate? >> I do consider it to be almost full and complete, but obviously there's no comment on the internal um workings of the generators and engine for example. So you are speculating the engine might have degraded. Yes. Uh that I'm I would say speculating but there could be that that could be a factor potentially. >> And uh we would surely see that somewhere in the engine uh report, wouldn't we? >> Uh only if the report was provided with um or oil samples for examp as as an example. And you made no mention of this in your uh your own report, did you? >> No. >> No. Okay. So, you're saying in fact that um this report is inadequate in some way that he should have carried out uh oil sample testing. >> I'm not saying it's inadequate. Um, I'm just saying it's not it doesn't prove fully the condition of the engines internally um in in the report, but doing the best you can, seeing what we can see for the Volvo report and this Admiral report, it looks like both reports show a vessel in full working order. Correct. >> Correct. And if there has been any deterioration, it's been so small that no one spotted it. Correct. >> It's not been looked for. Correct. >> What do you mean not been looked for? And Amanda's walked around this vessel for 5 days. How's he not looked for it? >> Well, there's no mention, as as I said before, there's not been any mention of any uh oil samples taken from both the generators and the engines. >> Right. Let's then uh uh move on to where it was inspected 952. We can see item one there. The underwater external hole was inspected on the cradle. Can you see that? >> I do your honor. So it was inspected both out of the water and in the water. You agree with that? >> Yes, the vessel was correct. >> And moisture readings were taken over 24hour periods. That's also at 952. You see that in cell one? >> I do. >> And they were found low. Yes. >> Correct. >> So we have uh that's all encouraging news. Yes. Yes. >> Um uh so pausing here, if someone had sent you to survey this vessel, uh given your normal day job, you'd be quite surprised, wouldn't you? Because you'd be saying, "Well, this vessel hasn't been damaged in the way that you normally see for loss adjustments." >> Correct. And let's now have a look at the defect list at page 954. And we have here of defects. Um would you agree that it's fair to call these snags rather than defects? >> Um yes. On the most part, yes. And each of these uh items are cross referenced to a dated photograph. You've seen that >> in the admiral report. Correct. Yes. >> Yes. And have you been through each of the defects and the photographs and match married them up? >> Um I believe so. Yes. >> Well, yes or no? >> Yes. uh and and you're satisfied that that uh he he he is right and complete in his uh in his conclusions. Yes. >> Yes. >> So would you agree that the report as a whole is consistent with what would be in expected for an IMS uh survey? >> Yes. Particularly for this class of vessel. Yes. Um, yes. >> You agree that there is a comprehensive photographic catalog of the vessel? >> Yes. >> And you agree that it's a a complete report? Yes. >> Yes. >> And there's nothing in your report identifying any failing in this report? Yes. >> Any fail? Um, correct. >> Any any omnition in this report? So if we just have a look then at the uh the joint report. Uh bottom of page 323. Uh the following is a list of matters agreed during the discussion and then over page. Um so you agreed on the reasonable standards for conducting a yacht survey. Um you agreed on the identity credentials of the surveyor and you agree that the report represents a reliable representation of the yacht condition in July 2023. You see all that? >> I do. >> Yes. >> Yes. uh and uh we've just been through the um the detail of all of that and we've accept that uh so many to you need to go back through that again. So what we've already looked at this morning or this afternoon um makes good those propositions of the matters you've agreed with Mr. Fox. Yes. >> Yes. And we if we turn through to page 329 in the middle of that page completeness and detail of the admiral report. See that in the left hand side? >> Yes. >> The right hand side it says this is Mr. Fox's comment. In my opinion the admiral report demonstrates that the surveyor had methodically inspected the vessel covering all aspects. Yes. >> Yes. >> And you say this point agreed. Yes. >> Yes. >> And there's no qualification there about uh oil or corrosion or anything [clears throat] else. Yes. >> Correct. >> And uh in reality, the admiral report does accurately reflect the condition of the boat as at July 2023. That's right, isn't it? >> Correct. >> It was a thorough, professional, and complete report. Yes. As far as the um the the survey report goes, yes, correct. >> Uh and judged as a report, it was a satisfactory report. You agree with that? >> I do agree. >> Now, going back to the uh report and the content of it, we've looked at the grading scale. Uh and let's have a look again at page 954. So we can now see uh there in bold capital letters he used the words it the condition of the vessel is generally satisfactory to good. You see that >> I do. Um, and if we cross refer that to I think 95 941, we we have to get to the word fair before there is uh a requirement for deficiencies to be of some consequence and in need of correction in the near future. You see that? >> Yes. >> And he doesn't at any point say that the vessel the vessel's condition is fair. You agree with that? >> I do. >> Um, so it's better. You agree with me that that that he his conclusion is that the vessel's condition is better than fair. >> Correct. And his grading uh is based on the condition of the vessel as is. There's no assumption that these would be remediated. You accept that? That the that the snagging list would be remediated. You accept that? >> Sorry. Say, can you please repeat the you >> that his [snorts] his grading of the vessel um is based on the actual condition of the vessel. It isn't based on any assumption that the vessel's snag list would be remediated. You accept that? >> Yes. Uh so on his given it public scale all of the uh defect list items did not need correction because the condition was was better than fair. Yes. >> Sorry. Did you say that the the the um defects didn't need correcting? >> Uh let me take them in in stages. So we've looked at his grading. Remember that got up on the screen in front of you. >> Yes. >> And if the grading is uh fair, [clears throat] then there are deficiencies which are in need of correction in the near future. Yes. Correct. Uh if it's satisfactory, then any deficiencies are minor and not in need of correction. You see that? Yes. >> And if it's good, then there are no maintenance or repairs required. You see that? >> Yes. >> So, a satisfactory condition does take into account potentially some deficiencies, but but it but it includes those deficiencies do not need correction. You agree with that? >> You I do agree with that. >> Yes. And his conclusion is that the vessel is satisfactory to good. Yes. Correct. I'm >> sorry, I'm not following. Uh, you say that the defect list does not need correction. >> Yes, you are. These are questions I'm I'm putting to uh Mr. Jameson. >> I'm Well, I I'm confused where he says work should be done. How can how can you say it doesn't need correction if he says that the first item main deck stainless steel requires further polishing? may not it may not impact upon the overall rating of the vessel as satisfactory to good but isn't he saying that [clears throat] these matters need to be done hatches require further alignment oh you yes I don't doubt that there are um that he's saying there are deficiencies in the vessel uh and therefore that that that resolving these 24 items will improve its condition but my point is that uh when he describes the condition of satisfactory to good, the technical meaning of that is that when one reads all of the rest of the defect list items, one has to bear in mind the overall rating is satisfactory to good. That he's saying, >> but he says that these matters, whether you call them snags or not, need to be attended to. >> Yes. >> There's no suggestion. There's no suggestion that these matters don't need to be attended to. Is that >> uh so uh >> that's the way you're putting it. >> Um what I'm putting to the witness is that the that the rating is not undermined by the defect list that the rating takes into account. >> I understand that defect >> list. But the way you were putting it sounded to me as if you were saying that these matters do not require attention. No, I'm so I'm not saying that no one ever need polish. Um uh the the >> It's not a matter ever needs polish. It's a matter that it needs polishing. >> Yes, it does need polishing. Yes. >> And it's a matter that you know if you go to seven the gap whereas the gap main lounge foldup stairc is excessive felt strip should be added. >> So that doesn't mean that felt strip shouldn't be added does it? >> Correct. Yes. So what it means is that that >> the even allowing for the missing felt strips uh on on the staircase. This is a satisfactory to good vessel >> but the the standard of the vessel would be higher if that item was resolved. Now it is a matter for the the purchaser of the vessel and indeed the contract underlying it as to what then happens and who carries out these these works. Um, so it should I should try to continue your honor. Sorry, you're muted again. Sorry. Yes, of course. So, Mr. Jameson, in your report, uh, how do you describe the condition of the vessel? Um I believe >> the adjective you use >> I I believe fair is the adjective I use >> now uh that's not an adjective you define is it >> can you can you is it possible to bring bring it up on how >> yes paragraph 19 of your report page 122 >> thank You see second line down. >> Sorry, I apologize. Number 20. >> No, it's it's the end of paragraph 19. So she all the power of 19 to herself. Correct. >> So yeah, the question I just asked you is uh do you accept that you don't define the word fair in your report? >> No, I do not. >> Um do you accept that if we compare your adjective to uh the grading scale of Mr. Hung's report. Uh it uh he reached a different conclusion. >> Uh correct. >> And he's the one who saw the report who saw the vessel. Yes. >> Correct. >> And uh uh you you've accepted that that he gave a full and complete report of the condition of the vessel. Yes. >> Correct. So your word fair there is uh making an assumption about most reasonable buyers. Do you see that? >> Um correct. >> And that's a retail buyer. >> Correct. >> So an end user. Correct. >> Correct. Uh and uh you're saying um so you're assuming therefore that a retail buyer would be uh concerned about the level of finishing. You see that? >> Uh your honor, I would. >> So you're making a a quasi commercial assessment there of this vessel, not about its technical condition. See that? Would you agree with that? >> Yes, I do. >> Um you except for Mr. Hung found otherwise and he found that the vessel's actual condition was satisfactory to good. Agree. >> Correct. >> I agree. um on the defect list itself. Um uh to accept that a if there had been a 5-day inspection of a vessel where not a single snag had been found, that itself would raise questions. >> I would agree. Um, it would be bizarre in suggesting that someone hadn't looked at the vessel properly if they couldn't find any fault of it after spending 5 days going around the microscope. >> Yes, >> I would have uh Yeah, I I would be suspicious of that. >> And in part, a pre-ely inspection exists to generate a snag list to protect the the end retail purchaser. You agree with that? >> I do. So the fact that we have 24 itemized and photographed snags shows a survey process working. You agree? >> I agree. >> Um you agree that the uh the snags were predominantly cosmetic in nature? >> Um predominantly yes. >> Uh and nothing in the snag list uh indicates that the vessel was unseatworthy. Yes. as per my report. Correct. >> Uh the AC, the ignition system, um you agree that was tested? Yes. >> Uh it says so in the report. Yes. >> And that it was found to be operational. Yes. >> Correct. >> Uh and item seven 17, excuse me, of the snag list. Let's have a quick look at that. That is a better reference. I'm using page 955. We have two elements being flagged here on item 17. You can see that Yes. >> Yes. >> The first concerns the chiller that it didn't hit its designated water temperature. Yeah. >> Yes. >> And the second is that that one of the cabins the air handler is intermittent. Yes. >> Yes. >> And we've already found that the trial was conducted whilst uh the ambient temperature was 36°. Yes. Yes. >> So, would you accept that an intermittent cooling shortfall in one room during a 36° centigrade uh heatwave is a snag and not a defective substance? >> Sorry, you broke Apologies, you broke up during this the second. Can you repeat it again, please? Would you accept that an intermittent cooling shortfall in one room during a 36° centigrade uh uh heatwave is a snag and not a defect of substance? Um, your honor, I it says it's um intermittent and so therefore I would consider that would be not related to the temperature potentially potentially temperature outside but potentially at the the the problem with the actual air handling unit itself because all the others seem to well there's no comments on the operational capabilities of the others and it's fair to assume that everything else is operating to an expected standard. Yes, correct. Now, we've looked already at uh Mr. Hung's client. That was KJM. Yes. >> Yes. >> So, Mr. Hung prepared a report on the premise that KJM would be the purchaser. Yes. >> Yes. >> Uh and uh he describes uh vessel as being a luxury vessel. Talk to show you that word. It's I paid reference to page 150. >> Yes. He's noting there the quiver 70 luxury. You see that? >> I do. and page 156 um his report first paragraph um is he's comparing it in his mind with vessels of a similar age and type you see that >> yes [clears throat] how much do you know how the the the price for the vessel looks agreed >> um sorry as in as in retail or between KJM and um Ceno Eagle. >> Well, I'm asking you um the between KJM and Sono Eagle or the price in fact strictly speaking between Contessa and KJM. What was the price agreed for the vessel? >> I I if I can I I don't remember off hand. >> Uh it's in your report page 118. You look at that paragraph 4. >> Yeah. 300 >> total >> third >> the 3.99 million. >> Yes. >> Yes. >> Was this the retail value of the art? >> Um I'm assuming it's not. That was the price to for for KGM to purchase it. >> And do you have any idea whether that was a fair price even as a trade price? Um, I I don't have any experience on this side, so I wouldn't know if that's a fair price. >> Um, do you know what the retail value of the yacht was? >> I do not. >> And you're not able to help the court on that issue at all. >> Um, okay. Let's move on. Um, one uh couple of final topics. So, your report assumes Sorry, Mr. stage. Can we just talk about timing? Um, [clears throat] you've had uh one and a quarter hours, so half the time of the afternoon session so far. >> Yes, I shall uh I shall take I think no more. I am sly behind schedule. I hadn't been meant to be quite so long. Uh 15 more minutes if I may. Your honor um Mr. Okay, that that adds half an hour to the whole day. Um, which by my record said that would take us to 6:00 Dubai time with a break. Well, I I I will if I can go as quick as possible. Um, apologies if I am being slightly pedestrian in the speed of this. Um, I I'll miss Jameson, let's try to then cut through. Your report assumes >> I don't have to recall Mr. Folks tomorrow if ne that's the problem. >> Yes, Mr. Jameson, your report assume that the report was received in July 2024. You accept that? >> I do. >> Um and the the first question you were asked in your report was how reliable a one-year-old survey might be. Yes, >> correct. But you weren't given any information about how the vessel was stored or used during the interim period. Yes. >> Correct. >> So you weren't able to comment on the actual condition of the vessel in July 2024. Correct. >> Correct. >> Um you agree that the actual delivery date of the report is a factual question for uh the judge. Yes. >> Apologies. Can you repeat the first part of the question again? Do do you accept that the actual delivery date, the actual date when Mr. Vanovich received the report is a factual question for the judge? Yes, >> I believe so. Yes. >> Uh and you can't help the court on when precisely it was received. That's a matter for the factual witnesses to give their evidence on. >> Your honor, correct? uh in what you have seen today with me between the December 2022 report and the July 2023 report we haven't identified any actual change in the vessel's condition have we >> in the performance correct not the condition >> so any conclusions you have about it condition in July 2024 are based on the fact that you don't have any up-to-date data for that period. Yes, >> correct. >> It's based on missing information rather than any observed change. Yes. >> Correct. >> In your report, you say that it's common place for issues to be revealed 12 months post delivery. Remember saying that? >> I do. >> Uh and that's not applicable here, is it? Because we didn't get to post delivery. Yes, >> that's correct. >> So, your opinion is that it would have been prudent uh well, so you you can't help the court determine whether the yacht was actually materially defective in July 2024. You said that >> correct. when one is looking at a 12-month-old pre-ely survey, uh it's not automatically unusable, is it? >> Correct. And we've just we ourselves instead of dialogue, we've just had a look at the Volvo report and that's helped us reach further conclusions about the vessel um and its change over time. That's right, isn't it? >> Correct. So if someone did receive a year old report and the age of it generally worried them um the solution would have been to reattend u and carry out another survey. You agree with that? >> Correct. >> And that survey would be by another qualified surveyor. Yes. Um, your honor, I would um when I when I've seen reports for condition surveys that have raised concerns about certain items, um the the reattend it's the same surveyor ideally should reattend because they've got um they can compare it to their original findings. I think >> so. Best practice is the same where should reattend not someone new but and it should be a surve ideally. Yes. >> Uh let's just have a look at a couple of documents on that point. Uh if we look at page 1,321 of the bundle. So I think this is an exchange you wouldn't have seen before. Is that right? >> Correct. Uh, and you'll see there item one, um, asking for a Mr. Mr. Rangage to send a representative to the yard. You see that? >> Yes. Yes. That's You see that's page 1322. Says that. Yeah. Um, there's no mention there of the original surveyor. You you you said that >> correct. >> I can uh move on correct in actions document briefly. Uh so I think it's common ground that this isn't a um I would describe this as a builder's snag closure record. Is that a fair description? >> Apologies. as in this this um email here in front of you. >> No, let's have a look. The the the Sino Eagle document, page 1183, what we're calling in this a corrective actions document. >> Uh it's a it's prepared by the builder. You agree with that? The manufacturer? >> Yes. >> And it's it's their um snag quotient list. You see that? >> Yes, I do. >> Um and it's with common ground. not a survey. You said that. Um correct. >> Uh thank you very much for questions. >> You're on mute, Yara, I think. Sorry, but you know what I'm going to ask. I >> I do. I have only a few questions by way of re-examination. The only question and I'm thinking of the transcribers is whether they'd prefer a 15minute break now or we press on for another 15 minutes. Say >> let's take let's take the break. Let's take the break now, shall we? Uh we'll take a we'll take 10 minutes. Uh so uh I make it 13 uh 07 uh London. So we'll come back um at uh uh 27 minutes past. >> Thank you. Sorry, my arithmetic is bad. I meant 17 minutes past. Can any >> I think I think the transcribers corrected your arithmetic before. [laughter] >> Um, so we we all understood. >> Yes. 10 minutes, not 20 minutes. And thank you to the transcribers. Very kind. Okay, we just need Mr. James. >> I'm here. Mr. Jameson's back with us. Oh, good. Okay. In which case, um, Mr. Watson is going to have a couple of questions. >> Mr. Watson, you're on mute. >> Thank you, Mr. Page. Um, Mr. Jameson, early on in your cross- examination, it was suggested to you that you don't have any professional experience of surveying new build yachts, and you answered that that was correct. To what extent does your work entail uh reviewing pre-ely inspection reports? Um, your honor, I would um ask for um delivery pre purchase reports um for all of the yachts below 24 meters that I have losses on um or instructions on in order to be able to understand their condition prior to the incident should we say. How many uh pre-ely inspection reports do you think you've reviewed in your career? >> Um I would assume not pre-ely inspections. Um not many. I would assume 10 to 15. >> Thank you. Could we now go to page uh 119 in the bundle? Um, this is your report and if the operator scrolls down to see paragraph 12, um, you set out at paragraph 12 the issues on which you were instructed to express an opinion. Issue one, where a survey report relates to a survey that is a year old, how reliable is it as to the condition of the vessel? And then issue two, to what extent can the corrective action documents a be considered a survey of the vessel and b demonstrate the issues defects in the survey report were rectified. Now you were asked questions about the sea trial report and the terms of the engagement uh of Mr. H. In your professional opinion, uh what if any relevance does the seat trial report have to those two questions? >> Your honor, with the in regards to the seat trial report, um they I mean sorry, they don't have any re relevance to these questions. >> And in relation to the terms of engagement again, uh to what extent do you consider they have any relevance to those questions? >> Your honor, none. Could we now go to uh page 954 in the bundle? This is back into the admiral marine report. You were asked about this and in the course of your cross- examination, his honor pointed out that if we look at the defect list, say item six, um Mr. Hunger said hatches require further alignment. Number seven, felt strip should be added. And if we go over the page, page 955. Um, look at say 14, it says, uh, port side hull, guest cabin, a gap found excessive and to be rectified. And we can see the language to be rectified at 15 18 requires attention. 21, an intake blower should be fitted to the inlet vent. And then 24, the shower hose were replaced with new. Do you see those sentences? >> Your honor, I do. >> If we go back up to page 954 now, I wonder if the operator could zoom in on the fourth paragraph just above that table. Thank you. You were asked a question about what you understood Mr. Hung's conclusion to be and I just want to clarify so that the court has the benefit of your evidence what Mr. Hung says is in the opin in his opinion taking into consideration the age of the vessel and activities this vessel is considered to be generally insatisfactory to good condition at this time considering normal wear and tear and subject to comments as contained herein is your view that Mr. Hung's conclusion was that the vessel was satisfactory to good in its present state or that it was satisfactory to good subject to the rectifications that Mr. Holm identifies as being carried out. >> Your before the witness that question I think that was a classic of the genre of what one might call a leading question. [clears throat] >> I've not suggested his answer at all. it it's not just it's not just arguably a leading question. It it it's a question of interpretation of a document which I think is for me and not for the witness in any event. >> In which case I'm very happy to leave it there. >> Um uh could we now go to page 947? you were shown next to um uh number eight in the top air conditioner tested operational. Do you see that? >> Yeah, I do. And we can see from the heading that that's lower deck. And you weren't taken to page 945 where you can see at number 14 air conditioner. Uh tested operational cooling capacity found insufficient. We can see under the headings is main deck. And could we now go to page 955? Uh you were taken to uh number 17 and it was it was put to you um that if the air conditioning was failing in only one room, you were asked whether that would be a snag. And I just want to show you page 953. And you can see just under that bullet point, Mr. Enzo Hung reports on the cooling capacity in the main lounge and then in the port side hull guest cabin. Do you see that at the end of the sentence? >> Yeah, I do. Um what where the air conditioning system is not functioning optimally in more than one room is your evidence that that is a snag or a more serious defect. >> I think again you want to we we um [clears throat] these are all if Mr. wasn't a free phrases question of a hint that these are entirely >> I think actually I think there's a more interesting question if I may say so which I will ask um so Mr. Jameson, assuming that the cooling capacity of the main lounge was insufficient, what remedial steps would need to be taken um and I can lead and I'll [clears throat] I'll tell you what I'm thinking about. Um, is there any indication that actually the air conditioning system is inadequate in terms of output or is it something that can be dealt with by by way of a repair or or an adjustment? >> Your honor, >> or are you unable to answer those questions on the basis of the information provided in the report? Your honor, the I I'm I can hypothesize with regards to um why it could be insufficient because Wabasto is a well recognized air conditioning manufacturer on yachts. >> Yes. Um and so one assumes that if they were to replace the air handling units if they were 40 um and it's or should we say if the air conditioning handling unit was in operation and found to be good but it wasn't able to reduce the temperature enough. One assumes that it could be the size of the vessels as in the the the open area within the the vessel's main saloon because uh and also the insulation of the vessel um may not provide sufficient insulation to be able to stop the hot air or sorry the the the sun from overheating the um saloon area should we say. But but I mean what we don't know and correct me if I'm wrong is whether or not this is a matter of under specification or uh or or adjustment or repair. >> Your honor that is correct. >> You agree? >> I agree with you. >> I have no further questions. John, >> thank you very much. Okay. Thank you very much indeed, Mr. Jameson. Your your evidence is over. Thank you, Mr. Paige. Uh, I'd like to call Mr. Faultz, please. Just do you may have um made I've taken my jacket off. I hope that's a disturbed one too much. I'm afraid the >> No, I'm not I'm not I'm not I'm not horrified. It's okay. [snorts] >> We're both zooming into uh Dubai and the the weather is especially Emirati in Israel as well. Uh so Mr. Folks uh if I could ask you please Well, sorry to swear you in first. Hopefully the associate is is listening in. Well, I can't see him on screen at the moment. Is this is his camera on? >> Yes, >> my camera is on. >> Okay, then I need to get more a bigger gallery size. >> So, you want to you can you there's a button you can press saying pin for me. >> I've It's all right. It's all done. >> Mr. Folks, please can I confirm whether you would prefer to swear on oath or by affirming? >> Yes. >> Would that be uh on oath or by affirmation? >> Uh on oath. >> Thank you. And can you please confirm if you have the holy book with you? >> I can confirm. >> And can you please just show um the camera your holy book? >> I haven't got it in front of me. Okay. May we proceed with the affirmation? >> Affirmation's fine. >> Thank you. Can you please confirm your name and occupation for the court's record? >> Uh, Matthew Graeme, folks. I'm a marine surveyor. >> Thank you. Please repeat after me. I affirm >> I affirm >> that I will say nothing >> that I will say nothing >> but the truth. >> But the truth. >> Thank you. >> Thank you. >> [clears throat] >> Mr. Folks and good afternoon. >> Good afternoon. I hope in front of you. We're going to turn up. There we are. Page 134 of the bundle. This your first report this matter. >> Are we sharing a screen? >> Yes. Can you see a shared screen if it's me? >> Yeah. Yeah, >> you you can >> agree. Yeah, I can. Yeah. >> And can you see it says the first expert report of Matt Folks? >> Yes. >> If I can ask you please to turn through to page 144. And if you scroll through to 145, whose signature is that? >> That's my signature. And uh is the content of this first expert report uh true to the best of your knowledge and belief? >> Yes. >> And uh the remainder of the expert declaration given paragraphs 51 to 56 is to be concerned that they are accurate as well. >> Yes. >> Now if we turn through please to the joint report joint memorandum. This starts at page 321. Uh and your signature is a page 331. Do you see that? >> Uh yes. Yes. >> And again, can you confirm that uh the expert declaration you set out in your report applies equally as joint memorandum? >> Yes. >> Thank you. [clears throat] Please make that. Good afternoon, Mr. Folks. A few a few questions for you. I'm council for Contessa. >> Um, I think you're aware, aren't you, that this dispute concerns an Aquilla 70 yacht? >> Yes. >> Um, and I think you're also aware that Contessa was involved in the purchase of a different yacht called a Sunseeker. Do you recall that? >> I do. Yes. And that was being purchased from a company called One Water Group, wasn't it? >> I I honestly do not know all the details of who actually bought the boat. I just have one person who I was in contact with. Who was behind the scenes? I've got no idea to be perfectly honest with you. >> Um, and were you aware that Mr. Parro Haidabbad Walla was involved in that transaction. >> I was. Yes. >> And do you know what he did on that transaction? >> What was his role? >> Not specifically, but I would imagine he is a boat broker. So maybe he was connecting people, boats, dealers together. However, I can't be 100% sure on that. You inspected the Sun Seeker yacht, didn't you? >> I did. >> And you reported on its condition. >> I conducted what's called a PDI, perhaps not in the same format as what we are looking at today, but a format that the Sunseeker Factory work too. You you didn't know Mr. Ivankovic before that Sunseeker transaction, did you? >> I didn't actually in in fairness, I didn't actually know Mr. Ivankovic during that transaction as well because I was only in contact with one person. >> Who was the person that you were in contact with? >> Holly Hand Olaf Hand. >> Did you ever have contact with Mr. behind her about >> uh on one occasion when I think both uh Mr. Hand and Perouch is Christian name both came to the factory um the Sunseeker factory a bigger pardon to to view the vessel. So they both came together. Could we go to page 107, please in the bundle? Sorry, that's that's my fault. 1075. Can we zoom in on the bottom email? We see that's an email from you to Olllehand and to Parish. >> Yeah. and you say, "Hi, all updated list attached. Areas like master cabin, saloon, some of the um exterior I'm not in a position to snag yet." Do you see that? >> Yes. >> You've been looking at the yacht, haven't you? >> Yes. Yeah. >> And if we look up at the very next email, Parish says, "Uh, hi Matt, thanks for such a detailed effort. All in there on the 14th for sea trial and general look around. Yeah. >> You see that? >> Agree. Yeah. >> When you when you said um you uh they both came to the factory to have a look around, is that um the look around that you're referring to there in that email now? Is that what's being >> I mean, if I can be perfectly honest, it was three years ago. I've dealt with hundreds of boats in between time, but yes. So they came to the factory to view the vessel at the time of construction. Um yeah, both of them. I can't actually recall whether they came out on sea trial. I know I sealed the boat because I have to seat tile all of them. So I I presume they did. >> Did Mr. Hyderabad Waller recommend you for this transaction? >> Um I can't honestly remember. He is somebody that I've known. Sorry, go on. >> No, please continue. >> He is somebody I have known previous to this uh contact. Um I'm trying [snorts] to recall how how I first met him. I can't honestly remember to be honest with you. You know, it was through the boating world. >> How long ago when did you did you first meet him? >> I can't honestly remember to be perfectly honest with you. If you want me to hazard a guess, there were two boats in the Middle East which had some uh issues which I was asked to go out to have a look at on behalf of Sunseeka and maybe uh that was my first contact with him. But that was perhaps um before 2020 definitely you know before 2020. And how many uh transactions have you worked on where Mr. Hydrobatwaller was involved? >> Um I mean it's I'm not involved in the transaction. I'm literally just a surveyor. I'm you know just making sure the boat is built to the standard that it should be built to. So, um, the Yacht 100 was the only vessel I worked with him directly on with this. So, yeah. So, one in answer to your question. >> You You said the Yacht 100. I assume you mean the Sun Seeker. >> Yeah, Sunseeker Yacht 100. That's what it That's the boat in question. >> You said that was the only vessel you worked with him directly on. What do you mean by directly? [clears throat] Well, he he was, you know, I'm in contact with him. You can see in front of you the emails. So, that's what I mean where we're twoing and throwing. I'm sharing information. I'm updating him on the condition of the vessel. Um, I don't believe I've worked with him in any other capacity other than this one. other than the fact when maybe when I was representing the factory, the Sunseeker factory and going to have a look at a couple of vessels in the Middle East uh where that is possibly when I first met him and sorry to sound vague but obviously I meet lots of people and and I deal with lots of boats. >> Well, I suggest that you came to be working on the Sunseeker transaction because Mr. Hydraad Wallet had recommended you for it. That's right, isn't it? >> Quite possibly. Yeah. >> Mr. Al Jazzmi approached you about carrying out the survey of the Aquilla yacht, didn't he? >> Um, Mr. Sorry, Mr. >> Mr. Al Jasmine approached you about carrying out the survey of the Aquilla yacht. >> I don't recall that. Did did Mr. Haidider Abadwala approach you about carrying out the survey of the Aquillaot? >> Not that I'm aware of. No. >> Can we look at page 918 in the bundle? And if the operator scrolls down, this is an email that you won't have seen, Mr. folks. But it's an email dated the 13th of June 2023 from Muhammad Al Jasmi. And the uh third bullet point perhaps if we can zoom in so that Mr. uh folks can see it says at the same time we encourage that the survey be carried out and that it should be done promptly. As you may be aware, we have tried to rope in the surveyor who is currently involved with the Sun Seeker 100. However, it appears that there are procedure issues for visas for some group members like him and Ollie at the moment. Do you see that? >> I do see that. Yeah. >> Now, you were the surveyor involved with the Sunseeker 100, weren't you? >> I was. And um you know being perfectly honest I don't I don't remember being part of this conversation or discussions but I may stand I may stand corrected on this but >> do you think it's possible that they did ask you and you've just forgotten? >> It is possible. So after we after I finished the yacht 100 um there were a couple of boats that uh Mr. hand and I'm I'm 99% sure it wasn't this boat in question that they asked me could I could I go and have a look at them on behalf of the client. Um and nothing actually materialized at all. So that that you know normally in all honesty if somebody asked me to do a job I would say yes to it if I have the time and the knowledge. Um, I don't recall this particular brand or these conversations, but as I said, you you may be right in this instance that I may have been asked and just didn't do it or whatever. When we go to page 137 now in the bumble and look at paragraph five, you say, "Before my instruction in this claim, I had no previous relationship with the parties or their legal representatives. Bearing in mind that you had worked on the Sun Seeker transaction that Contessa had been involved in and that Mr. Haider Abadwaller had been involved with. Is that statement accurate? I raised this uh with um our team here and I when when the information came to me that I actually recognized it in all honesty it was Mr. hand's name that I recognized, nobody else is. I raised this and said, "Is there a conflict of interest?" Um, and it was a I explained what I'd done for Mr. Hand in the past and it was agreed there was no conflict of interest, so I continued. >> Well, I suggest it's not what you've done for Mr. Hand. I suggest it's what you've done for Mr. Hydra Bad Waller in the past. He's the person you know, isn't it? Well, I mean, very loosely. Yes. >> Can we go to page 119 bundle, please? And look at paragraph 12. This is Mr. Folks's report, sorry, Mr. Jameson's report. Um, presumably you read this before preparing your own report. And do you see that he was instructed to answer two questions? >> Yeah, agreed. >> And now can we look at um page 136 and focus in if we can with the operator on paragraph 3. And you address two different issues, don't you? >> I Yeah, agree. >> Did you draft those issues? Were they uh were you instructed to answer those questions? >> I believe I drafted these. I mean I was my my area of expertise is obviously in this instance was to review the admiral marine report but obviously surrounding this report there was some information that was included in this package which was felt to be relevant which is why um the second remark is whether contestant is entitled to withhold the final loan which is why I've commented on on on other areas as 12. >> Um, well, if we look at that question too, where the contestant was entitled to withhold the final loan balance, I mean, that's a legal issue for his honor ultimately, isn't it? It's not an issue for you as a surveyor. >> Correct. And your issue one, whether the Admiral Marine report andor the corrective actions report constituted a satisfactory report from the surveyor as required under clause 2B. Do you see that? >> Yes. >> Well, what's required under clause 2B is a legal question, isn't it? >> Correct. If we go now to page 141 in your report, we have a you have a section that is headed witness statement review. And you go through, don't you, over the next couple of pages, perhaps if the operator could scroll through to remind you to comment on all the witness statements that have been served in these proceedings, don't you? >> Correct. And if it if we go to uh we get to page 144, you give your conclusions where you say the dispute hinges on when the admiral report was shared with Contessa and less so on its contents. Say if it was shared in a timely manner, I feel the content satisfactory and sufficient in terms of Contessa's obligation to re release the loan balance. And then you also suggest what contestants should have done about asking questions. I mean these are conclusions about the legal issues in the case generally aren't they? >> Correct. >> Have you given expert evidence in legal proceedings before? >> I have been expert witnesses before an expert witness before but it's never actually come to trial. It's always been resolved prior to trial. I mean, you know, it's your job as an expert not to express views on matters of law, don't you? >> Agree. >> And you knew it's your >> I think you're being I think you're being slightly unfair actually, Mr. What's for this reason that the conclusion is not so much uh about what um the commercial decision was but the adequacy of the report depending upon the timing of disclosure of the report and what um and what Mr. Fox is saying I is that if the report were disclosed close to the time that it was um that it was compiled uh then in his expert opinion I I it was an adequate report. On the other hand, he says very fairly um if there was a delay between the making of the report and its disclosure then he said I would suggest the admiral report was not sufficient. I I take that as as as um uh evidence within his expertise and not uh a legal issue. >> Well, your honor, he goes on paragraph 49, he says in terms and sufficient in terms of contestant's obligation to release the loan balance. >> Well, yes, that may be a step too far, but I don't read it. I I think that's a gloss on the underlying expert view. with the underlying expert view is the effect of time, the passage of time upon reliance on a on a report. That's what I take from it. >> Well, I I'm going to suggest um to Mr. Folks, and he can maybe give his answer that in preparing this report, he's gone outside the bounds of what he should properly apply on. Um well as I said before you know I'm I am a marine surveyor. I commented on the the survey report provided to me but also I was given additional information. If I've overstepped then that's you know I stand corrected on it but I was given all this information and so I was just trying to do the best job I could with the information I was given. >> Perhaps let's move on to a different topic. If we go to page 140 now in the bundle uh and paragraph 30. So if we scroll down on the screen you deal here with the corrective actions report. Do you see that? >> Yeah. And you say positive feedback from the manufacturer Sinoe Eagle in the form of the corrective actions report confirms that corrective actions have been implemented in the vessel in response to the findings listed in the Admiral report. Do you see that? >> Yes. >> And that was the view you came to on originally seeing the corrective actions report, wasn't it? >> That was my original view. However, that when we did the joint ex uh expert witness statement, as you have probably seen, um I've corrected it and said that it it is a shame that some of the photos within this corrective action report do not align with some of the defects listed in the original admiral report. So, I have correct. >> Sorry, go on. >> No, no, no, please finish. All I was saying was so I that particular statement um is not 100% I would say from my side. So I I did correct it. So and and it is within the joint expert witness report as well. >> Let's look at that um page 327. And if we scroll down, we see um the second box from the bottom uh where it says the corrective actions report lacks detail to verify that rectifications correspond to the defects identified in the admiral report. And and you both agree that don't you >> agree? Yeah. And then uh if the operator goes down to page 329 uh there's a box at the bottom. Perhaps we can zoom in on that to corre corrective actions where Mr. Jameson says I was unable to agree your original statement in the report um as the corrective actions report does not provide any detail or that has been independently verified. And then you say to clarify, I tend to agree with the Jameson statement. The corrective action report does not align with the defects listed in AMA report was not undertaken by an independent surveyor. This cannot be classed as a survey report and therefore is not reliable. Do you see that? >> I do see that. >> So your final conclusion is that the corrective actions report is not reliable. >> It's it's not reliable. Um but what I would go back to is the nature of the snags identified are from experience having done hundreds of PDIs are particularly lightweight what and compared to what they could have been. Um but in answer to your to your question I yes I agree that the corrective actions report could have been much better could have been slightly more reliable. just just going over the page. Uh you do say that the uh Admiral report was fit for purpose. >> Well, I'm coming back to that. >> Okay. >> I don't know whether you I don't know whether you you have a question in mind first, but >> I do. Presented to Contessa with a time. You you don't know when it was presented to Contessa. >> Uh I've been told that it was handd delivered in September. >> You've been told. Yeah, I know. I know that. But you don't know from your own. >> No. No. No. No. Your honor. No, that's an issue that's an issue um within these proceedings. >> Okay. Thank you. M >> M Mr. Folks, when you were preparing this joint statement, >> why did you write that the Amiral report had been presented to Contessa within a timely manner? >> Uh because that's the information I was given. you. It's not your job to assess whether that's accurate or not. >> Well, I mean, I've been asked to comment on things. So, uh whether you feel it's beyond my area of expertise, that's entirely up to you. But, you know, I was asked to comment, so I commented. So, >> aren't you just aren't you just arguing KJM's case at this point? I mean I'm I always have tried to be fair which is why um you know I've I retracted the the statements about the corrective actions you know and also I've also been fair in terms of if the sur the survey report in my view is is satisfactory it's very comprehensive however the timing of which it was delivered uh is obviously open to discussion which is as you are saying beyond my scope of expertise. though. >> But you don't say here that it's open to discussion. You assert that it was presented within a timely manner >> because of the information I was given. >> And um as his honor noted, the other thing that um I think you say when you qualify um your conclusion on the corrective actions report was that the number of defects defects was small and minor. Perhaps if the operator strolls back up, we can just see that. You see, however, the number of defects in the admiral report was small and relatively minor. Do you see that? >> Uh, well, yes. Yes, I do see that. Can we just look at page 330, which should be the next couple of pages down, and then there's a box, and your comments are on the right, and you say, "Ideally, the original surveyor would have returned to the vessel to close down a small number of defects, however, may be deemed acceptable given the number of magnitude defects that the supporting evidence items can be closed down in house. See that? >> Yes. Yeah. >> So, I just want to break it down. Presumably, it was and is your view that the defects identified in the AB report needed to be remeded. >> They do need to be remeded. You know, you're buying a a brand new vessel, you expect everything to be um in A1 condition. So, yeah, they they needed to be rectified. And um I think it must be your view that uh any buyer would want some evidence that those defects had been rectified. >> Correct. >> And I think in your view ideally that would be uh the original surveyor returning to carry out a a second survey. In an ideal world, it it would be the ideal a good situation that the original surveyor returns to the vessel. >> Presumably though, you're saying that the um the shipyard might just supply its own evidence. That's another possibility, isn't it? >> That is a possibility. And I'm only drawing on experience that having done numerous PDIs and especially perhaps due to the proximity of the surveyor and the vessel that if they could provide uh evidence, photographs, documentation, etc. to show that they have actually um addressed the defects, [snorts] then there is a case to say that actually some of them can be signed off remotely. >> But you and Mr. Jameson agree that the corrective actions document is not reliable evidence, is it? >> It doesn't align with the admiral report 100%. No. >> Well, it's not reliable evidence, is it? >> No. >> Thank you. I've got no further questions from Mr. Folks. >> Thank you very much. Any re-examination, Mr. Page? >> Nothing from me. >> Well, thank you very much. your evidence, Mr. Folks. That's that's that. Thank you. Uh well, in that case, we can draw stumps, can't we? For the day. Um uh you don't unless of course either of you want to start the factual evidence. We only have about 20 minutes. >> Um >> I'm in your honor's hands on that point, but it's Mr. Watson's witness. I mean, it's 2 o'clock, which was the original uh slated um end time. Um bearing in mind it might take five minutes just to set up the link. >> Um and let's get start a fresh start. We'll get a fresh start tomorrow morning at uh 8:00 a.m. UK, 11:00 a.m. >> uh Dubai. Then as you say it it is the schedule finish time and uh I shouldn't keep the stuff called stuff too long anyway. So we'll um uh we'll meet again then tomorrow morning uh at uh 11:00 a.m. uh 11:00 a.m. BST. No, sorry, 11:00 a.m. GST and 8:00 a.m. BST. Thank you both very much. >> Thank you.