Good morning all. This trial is in the matter of CFI091 2024 and CFI068 2024 and is being held by way of video conferencing before his excellency Justice Michael Black with the sitting of the hearing taking place in Dubai. Any orders or directions made during a course of or after this hearing will be issued by the registry in Dubai on the judge's instructions. The claimant is represented by Trowers and Hamlins. Lead council is Mr. Matthew Watson. The defendant is represented by Pincent Mason's and lead council is Mr. Lawrence Page. Thank you, your honor. >> Thank you, Mr. Paige. >> Good morning, I like >> Sorry, Mr. Say something. >> Before we call um uh Mr. Al Jasmine, I was just going to deal with a matter of housekeeping. Um unless my learned friend was going to deal with it. I'm actually not aware of any housekeeping matters. >> Um, it was just in relation to page 921 of the bundle. Your honor may recall this from yesterday. This is the the WhatsApp exchange with the address. um o overnight and I'm very grateful to the my learner friends instructing solicitors confirmed that that Arabic date is the 19th of May 2023 not the 19th of June 2023 as the index says and so it's probably not very important your honor but just so you have that >> right 19th of Thank you. >> You I'd like to call Mr. Jasmine, please. Can the witness please confirm whether they would prefer to swear on oath or by affirming? Thank you. >> Can you please confirm? I confirm that the witness wishes to swear on oath. Can you please confirm your name and occupation for the court's record? My name is Muhammad Jasmi and my equation is a general manager of KGM >> and a partner in KGI. >> Thank you. Please repeat after me. I swear by >> I swear by >> the Almighty God. >> Oh to Almighty God >> that I will say nothing >> I will say nothing >> but the truth >> but the truth. >> Thank you. >> Thank you. >> Need to swear on the interpreter as well. you are on. >> Um Alina, do we have an interpreter's oath? >> Yes, I do have one. You're on. >> Yes. Would you administer that, please? >> Thank you. Um uh Mr. Interpreter, please can you repeat after me? I affirm >> I affirm >> that I will interpret >> that I will interpret >> the evidence >> the evidence >> to the best of my knowledge. to the best of my knowledge. >> Thank you. >> Thank you. >> Thank you, Mr. Al Jasmine. Good morning. Uh you should have up on the on the screen in front of you uh uh an electronic bundle. Can you see that? Can you see a document on the screen in front of you? >> Yes. Uh and uh can I ask please for this bundle to be turned first of all this is page 84. Is this your first witness statement? >> Got it. >> Please then turn to uh page 100. Whose signature is that? >> Yes. >> Is is that your signature? >> Yes. And is this statement true to the best of your knowledge and belief? >> Yes. Uh let's now turn please to page 112. This is your second witness statement. Is that correct? Is that correct, Mr. Alasme? Yes. And let's now turn please to page 116. Whose signature is that? >> My signature. >> And uh is this witness statement true to the best of your knowledge and belief? Thank you. Now we're going to turn to your first witness statement in the joint venture claim. Uh this is page 668. Uh is this your first witness statement in those proceedings? And page 689, whose signature is that signature? And is that statement true? The best of your knowledge and belief. >> Yes. Now, let's turn finally to page 707, please. This is your second witness statement in the joint venture claim. Is that correct? >> Yes. Uh, and let's turn to uh page 715. Whose signature is that? >> Signature. >> Thank you. Please wait there. Mr. Watson will be asking you some questions. >> Sure. >> Good morning, Mr. Al Jasmme. Can I just check that you can hear me clearly? >> Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. And um you can see clearly the documents on the screen. >> Yes. >> And um you have an interpreter sitting next to you. But so far you've been able to understand what Mr. Paige has said and what I have said, haven't you? >> Yes. Because you asked me very basic think you know. Of course I will understand. And uh when you made your witness statements, did you read them in English? >> I translated to Arabic and after that I sign it. >> You translated it into Arabic. >> Of course. >> How did you do that? >> I do normal. >> So So you sat down with an English witness statement and yourself manually translated it into Arabic. Yes. >> And then you read it in Arabic. >> Sorry. >> Did you use any computer program to translate it into Arabic? >> Yeah. Yeah. There is a lot of program to translate from English to Arabic. What is normal? >> So the witness statement that so you signed this English witness statement having run it through a computer translation. >> Before I sign it, I read it. I translate it. I make sure 100's person correct. After that, I sign it. >> Okay. Can we start please with page 926 in the bundle? >> Perhaps if the operator can just focus on that bottom email. I assume, Mr. Jasmine, you're able to read that email without the interpreter reading it out to you. Is that right? No. No. >> Well, so sorry, Mr. Jasp. You can't you can't understand the English that's written here. >> No, not all. But he will translate to me. He's here to help me for translate. >> Right. Um, well, can you see, let's see how far your English does go. Can you see at the top the email is sent from a benkjm? >> Okay. >> And it was sent on the 30th of May 2023. Do you see that? >> Okay. >> And we see that it is to Ivan Mu at Aquilla. Do you see that? >> Yes. This is an email to the shipyard, isn't it? >> Okay. >> Well, it is an email to Sino Eagle, isn't it? >> Yes. >> And this we can see you're copied. >> Yes. >> And the subject is reacquer 70 order confirmation. Do you see that? >> Yes. That's the yacht that was the subject of the loan agreement, isn't it? >> Yes. >> And Mr. Cadra says, uh, we are pleased to enclose the signed addendum together with the transfer document of the sum of $1 million advanced payment against the Aquilla 70 as promised. So, Sino Eagle had asked for a down payment, hadn't they? Yes. >> Of a million dollars. >> Yes. >> And if we uh if I can ask the operator just to scroll up now. It should be on I think it's on page 925 to get the response. You get the response from the shipyard. Can you see that? >> Yes. And the shipyard says, "Thank you for sending the signed documents in the proof of payment transfer. I forwarded them to the CEO." Do you see that? >> Yes. >> This is the point at which KJM placed the order for the Aquilla yacht, isn't it? >> Yes. >> We just scroll back down, please, to 926. the signed addendum that's referred to here. Did you sign it? >> Yes. And presumably it was uh an addendum to the master agreement between KJN and the shipyard. >> No. >> What was it? >> It is related to the Egypt market. >> So it's nothing to do with the purchase of the yacht. >> Sorry. So, it's nothing to do with the purchase of the yacht. >> No, no, nothing to do with the purchase of the yacht. >> So, is it right that there is no written contract containing the terms on which KJM agreed to buy the Aquilla 70 from the shipyard? email order. >> There's an email for the order that have been made. >> So you're saying we've these are the only two emails that you've produced, Mr. Al Jasmi. So are these the emails Yes. >> Thank you. I want to ask you some questions now about the admiral report. Do you know what I mean by that? report. >> You mean the marine survey? You mean? >> Yes. >> Yes. >> KJN engaged Enzo Hung of Admiral Marine to inspect the yacht, didn't it? Before we request them to carry out the survey, I have obtained the approval uh from Steven and Ki O >> and Oi. >> And Enzo Hung is based in Hong Kong, isn't he? You know, >> as far as I know, yes. >> And he emailed a quotation to KJM, didn't he? Huh? Steven asked to help him to find a survey company to carry out the marine survey. Right. My question was, Mr. Hung emailed a quotation to KJM, didn't he? There must be a quotation, but I don't recall whether they send it to the company or not. >> Well, you provided that quotation to Mr. Ivankovich, didn't you? >> Yes, I did. >> And you provided that by email, didn't you? I don't recall what >> if we go to page 1 1909. >> Just scroll down a bit. Do you see there's an email from you, Mr. Al Jazzmi? >> No. Yes. >> And we can see it's to Ollle Hand, but Mr. Ivankovich is copied. Do you see that? >> Yes. And you say uh we have this is in the middle paragraph we have the surveyor's proposal already as attached which is a great all round inspection. Their next available date is the month 26th of June. If the attached is fine we will confirm their visit. Do you see that? >> Yes. >> That's you sending the quotation by email isn't it? >> Yes. >> And Mr. whom inspected the yacht in July 2023, as far as you're aware. >> Yes. >> And presumably when he finished his survey, he emailed you a copy of his report. He sent it to me and not he sent it to one of my employees because one of my employees was with him in the factory. or he sent it to actually I don't exactly remember who sent it to it. >> So you don't remember who received the admiral report? >> No. And you don't remember how they received it? >> No. >> Is that because your memory of events in July 2023 isn't very good? It's not about memory. It's about that we have employees inside the company that who are doing such procedures. And secondly, Steven asked for the assistance of Barush to find the Amarine survey company and uh notify me. Um, can I just pause the cross- examination for a moment and raise an issue with your honor? I'm looking at the transcript as I'm sure your honor is. Um, and I just want to check that the transcriber is actually a able to uh capture what's being said because um the the is no criticism of the transcriber that it's a little bit garbled. But the the transcriber will have uh a a recording and the trans the transcript will be corrected in accordance to the recording. >> Well, I just I'm checking >> the transcriber to confirm that that anything will be picked up if it's missed in real time. Okay. Okay. Uh, I understand what the transcriber is saying. >> I I think it is, and this is no criticism of you, Mr. Interpreter. >> I think if you're able to speak more slowly and more clearly into the microphone, I don't know where the microphone is in your room. >> Yeah, of course. may assist the transcriber in picking up your interpretation. >> It's clear >> that's not helpful to me because now the interpreter is front of the witness so I can't see the witness. I have to say the camera position is very unhelpful there. That's what I thought. The camera should be directly in front of the witness a and the interpreter. Um, is it possible to move the camera? Because uh, frankly, even when I saw it the first thing, I thought it was um, an inappropriate position. >> I don't know where Mr. is getting evidence from. Is he giving evidence from lawyers offices? Yes, your honor. So, just on that point, I've already been in touch with Reed Smith this morning. Um because uh I anticipate that this would be a an issue. Um I I've I'm hoping that in the midm morning break a new arrangement can be um found for Mr. Anjasmi so that he is uh looking squarely at a camera and it's a it's a better setup. >> Okay. Well, well, we'll carry on. We'll carry on now for um the next hour or so, but I would like it changed, please. >> Thank you. >> So, I just want to clarify your evidence to that last question, Mr. Al Jasmme. Is your evidence that you do not recollect how KJM received the admiral report because this was something that was dealt with by your employees? So, so I need to to check it because I'm not sure about it because this report was received by the person who Steven has appointed to to to carry out the uh or to help or to give assistance with the finding the uh survey marine company or it has been received directly by one of my employees. So I need to check this and >> yeah so the answer is Mr. Rajasi, you don't know who received the report. >> No, I don't remember. >> Could we now look at page 18 of the bundle, please? >> This is KJM's uh defense in the loan claim. Did you read this document before it was sent out, Mr. Al Jasmine? Yes. >> And presumably you signed off on it. >> Yes. >> And you were happy that it was accurate. >> Yes. >> And happy it was complete. >> Yes. >> We go to page 20, please. >> Do you see paragraph 12? It says on or around 10th of July 23 2023 Admiral Marine issued to KJM a pre-ely condition survey report on the vessel. Shortly thereafter KJM sent the survey report to Contessa. Do you see that the only email in which the report was sent was sent on the 11th of July 2024, wasn't it? >> 11 July. >> What do you mean by 11th July? The only email in which the survey report was sent to Contessa was sent on the 11th of July 2024, wasn't it? I don't remember the date. >> I can't see the witness. I'm sorry. The the interpreter is going to have to sit back at all times. I need to see the witness. >> This is really unsatisfactory. I >> I'm entirely in your hands, your honor. It's obviously the most important that you get the benefits, isn't it? We want to see Mr. Arjasmy's evidence and um >> well indeed uh on the basis that this uh will be changed very shortly. We'll carry on. >> Okay. Go back to the answer please. >> So your answer was you don't remember the date. >> You remember it was sent by email. be because it's written here 10th of July. So what do you mean by 11th of July 2024? >> So do you don't know do you Mr. Jasmi, when the admiral report was sent by email, It's in July, but the exact day I I don't remember. >> And you never sent it by WhatsApp, did you? >> WhatsApp? >> No. >> No. >> And you never sent it by post, did you? No, I don't remember. >> Could we look at um page 36 of the bundle? >> Thank you. And just highlight the Do you remember seeing this, Mr. Al Jasmi? >> Yes. And did you understand that KJM was being asked to give specific details about how the document had been sent to Contessa? >> Okay. >> Well, did you understand that that was what this document was asking? Certainly, it's about the Marian survey, >> right? Well, let's just have a look at your uh lawyer's response to this. It's at page 38. And the first thing that was said, if we zoom in at the top, can you read that? Please note that in relation to the first request, the surveyor report was handd delivered to Mr. Ivankovich in or around July 2023. Do you see that? >> Yes. >> It wasn't hand delivered in July 2023, was it? The report was delivered to Steven in July 2023. It wasn't handd delivered to Mr. Ivankovic in July 2023, was it? >> July. Can I make a clarification regarding the survey report? >> Yes, please do. We delivered the report in July 2023 and requested me that not to send the report to the lawyers by email. Okay. and he's going to arrange the money within two to three weeks. But he didn't do it. And we continue. And then he promised to prepare the money, to arrange the money. But uh we didn't we we we go to nowhere and then we go to the court. >> Uh uh Mr. Jasmine, can I just ask you did you personally give the report to Mr. Ivankovich? >> Yes, I did. Mr. Ivanovich and Mr. Barouch was >> and was there in the office and I delivered I give it to Mr. Ivanovich. >> Then why did you say in your witness statement it was sent to him? >> Yes. I mean that I delivered it to him in person. >> Okay. So your witness statement is wrong. >> I handed it to him. Maybe there's a a mistake in translation. >> A mistake in translation of your witness statement. Your honor, just if I may, um I think a couple of things are going wrong here. Um uh the the witness should be shown the document if he's being asked it's wrong. And I don't think with respect to your honor actually means the witness statement. It's the pleading we're looking at. >> Uh no, I mean the witness statement, isn't it? Uh this is page 20. Or is that uh the pleading? >> That's that's the pleading, your honor. >> Okay. >> We we um we'll come to the witness statement, your honor. >> Okay. All right. I shouldn't um I I I take it back. Take it in your own time. But the pleading the pleading is inconsistent then. >> Well, I'm going to put that squarely to the witness for the benefit of the transcript. Um, Mr. Al Jasmi, you told the court that you read this uh pleading and that you were happy that it was accurate. If you had handd delivered the report, you would have seen that there was an error in paragraph 12, wouldn't you? I handed it in person. There may be a mistake, but I handed it in person. >> Right. But you accept that this paragraph here is mistaken. No, I don't accept this that there's a mistake. I don't accept it. >> Can we go back to page 38, please? Your lawyers didn't say that you hadn't delivered the report. If you had told your lawyers that you had handd delivered the report, that is what they would have said here. That's right, isn't it? Yeah, I delivered the report in the office. He he was there in the office with me and I delivered the report to him. Your lawyers also say that the survey report was provided again in February 2024. Do you see that? Steven, Steven was visiting Dubai and we were talking about the the late payment and there was amendment to the report and we have we have discussed the report. There was a correction to the report where we discussed the correction with Mr. Steven when he was with me in the office. >> Your defense and counter claim did not say that the survey report had been provided in February 2024, did it? in February 2024. This was the snag report regarding the remarks on the survey report July >> that was in July. Ah, so the document that you say was provided in February 2024 was the corrections report, not the admiral report. >> Yes. >> Thank you. And you requested the factory to give us the correction report so we can show it to Steven so we can get the late payments. >> So we can uh uh process the >> Can we look at page 134 in the bundle? >> Thank you. This is the expert report for KJM's expert in these proceedings. Did you read this document before it was sent? >> Yes, I read it quickly. And were you happy that the facts stated in it were accurate? This is a report by a survey company and they know their job much better than me. Can we go to page 142 please? can we focus in on paragraph 38 and uh Mr. Folk says I am told by a KJM marine representative that this factual assertion is contentious and that KJM's case is that Admiral report was delivered in hard copy by Admiral Marie to KJM. I am also told by a KJM marine representative that the admiral report was handd delivered to Mr. Ivankovich in person on the 27th of September 23. Do you see that? read this document. >> I read it quickly. >> And I answered your question. >> Are you the KGM representative who spoke to Mr. Folks? forks. >> Can you repeat the question, please? >> Are you the KJM representative who spoke to Mr. Folks? >> No, >> Mr. folks has been given a different story, hasn't he? >> I don't know. >> Well, Mr. Folks wasn't told that the admiral report was handd delivered in July 2023. I'm sure that the report has been delivered in July and it has been delivered in in person. >> So what Mr. Folks was told was wrong was it? report. Mr. Steven visited us in July and August and September and we have been talking about the report in all the meetings that we have that we had with Mr. Steven. Could we go to page 84, please? This is your first witness statement. And uh if I can ask the operator to scroll up just a little bit, we can see that it was finalized on the 30th of October, 2025. Do you see that? >> Yes. >> And you prepared this witness statement carefully, didn't you? >> Yes. You wanted it to be accurate. >> Yes. >> You wanted it to be complete. >> So, what do you mean by this? >> Well, you didn't want to miss out anything important, did you? The thing is that I have remembered I I put it in the report. >> So everything that you remembered you put in this witness statement. Everything that I have remembered, I put it in the report. There were other things that are not important. I didn't include it in the report. >> I I understand. Uh could we go to page 87 and uh you set out maybe if the operator could just scroll down so we could see all of paragraph 17. You you set out here the details of a meeting that you had with Mr. Ivankovic and others at KJM's offices in December 2022. Do you see that? Yes, I see. And if I can just ask the operator to scroll down, uh, at paragraph 18, you deal with a second meeting on the 7th of February, 2023. Do you see that? >> Yes. >> And that was a meeting, you tell us, at the restaurant at Jira Alcasa. Do you see that? It's a paragraph 18.1 about the third line. >> Presumably you you remembered all this. >> Yeah. Remember we meet in J >> and and we the operator just to scroll down again to page 89. There is a third meeting here at paragraph 19. And if I could just ask the operator just to slowly scroll down to page 93, you will see Mr. Al Jasmi that you've given about seven pages of evidence about the meetings that you had with Mr. Ivankovic before the loan agreement was signed. Do you see that? There's the fifth meeting operator. >> Which which loan agreement you mean? >> The loan agreement that was signed in June to do with the In these meetings, we did not talk about Aguila. We were talking about the joint venture company. >> I I I don't I don't disagree with that, Mr. Al Jasmine. My point was simply that you uh were able to give from your recollection seven pages of evidence about I think it's six meetings that you've had with Mr. Ivankovich and what happened at those meetings. That's right. What's up? Okay with the curtif. >> Yeah, I remember them because we have WhatsApp messages and we have dates, >> right? Can we scroll to page or or go to page 95 now and zoom in on paragraph 40 please? You say and this is starting at the third line. Admiral issued its report on 10th July 2023 which KJM shared with Mr. Ivankovich. Do you see that? >> Yes. >> Now those six words are the sum total of the evidence that you give on when the admiral report was provided. That's right, isn't it? This report had nothing to do with the meetings, the six meetings. I I never suggested that it did. Mr. Mr. Al Jasmine, when you prepared this witness statement in October 2025, you had no recollection about how the admiral report was provided to Mr. Ivankovich, did you? Okay. Okay. Okay. But I remember that Steven asked Par to find a a company to prepare the report. for the youth that is related to Mr. Ivanovich Sunseeker. Mr. Ivenovich asked perouch to find a survey company for his sunseeker boat. So was he was depending on bar to find the survey uh company. >> Mr. Arjasmi, you didn't give the admiral report to Mr. Ivankovic in July 2023, did you? Admiral. >> No, I did. >> If you had done so, you would have said it here in this witness statement. the curtain. No, I mentioned it. I delivered it in the office to Mr. Ivanovich and we have discussed the report in July and in August and in September. >> Well, you say that now, Mr. Al Jasmi. But you didn't remember that in October when you prepared this witness statement, did you? report. The bottom line here is that what time he received the report. He received it in July. Yes, I haven't mentioned that. We discussed what what was going on in August and September, but I delivered the report to Mr. in July 2023. >> Do you recall, Mr. Arjasmi, that the admiral report is about 100 pages long? It was a long one, but I don't exactly remember the number of pages. >> It's It's not three or four pages, is it? Actually, I don't know exactly the number of the uh papers. Uh actually, I don't work in a printing company to remember the number of the papers. I >> I I'm not trying to catch you out, Mr. Al Jasmine. It's a long report, isn't it? >> If you had it physically, it would be a lot of pieces of paper. Yes, it's a report, but I don't remember the volume or how large was it? >> And if you were going to hand deliver it, you would have had to get someone to print it or photocopy it for you, wouldn't you? Yes, for sure. There there is some somebody inside the office who has printed it and prepared it. >> And you'd have to put it in an envelope or or staple it or put it in a ring binder, wouldn't you? Steven. Okay. Mr. Steven stressed the fact that the report shouldn't be sent by email and I acted in good faith because he and I suppose that he is going to pay me. That's why I delivered it a physical copy to Mr. Steven. >> You've just made that up, haven't you, Mr. Al Jasmi? Mr. never said, "Don't send this by email to my lawyers. He told me clearly, "Do not send the report by email and I'm going to make the payment." And if you're going to hand over this chunk of paper, you wouldn't just meet Mr. Ivankovic on the street, would you? You'd meet him in a restaurant or in an office or something like that. I have handed over the reported to him in the office. But but sometimes in one day I can meet him in a restaurant and or in office maybe two times or three times a day. >> So you can't remember where you handed over this report? >> No, I do remember. I handed it over to him in the office. >> Can we go to page 96, please? >> Look at paragraph 45. You say, >> Mr. Wson, so sorry. I don't want to interrupt your flow at all. Um, just to let you know that at a moment which is convenient for you and his honor, um, I'm told that there is now a laptop which can be presented in front of Mr. chance as me to improve the the picture. >> Thank you very much. Let's do that during the break. >> Yes. I I think we're only about 15 minutes away. Um you say here, Mr. Al Jasmine, that you reviewed your diary messaging apps and you recall four of your in-person meetings with Mr. Ivankovich on 21st, 27th, 29th of July, and 1st of August 2023. Do you see that? Yes. >> And you tell us what you discussed with Mr. Ivankovic in those meetings. >> Yes. >> You don't say that you handed over the admiral report. >> I hand over to >> That's because you didn't hand it over to him. >> No, I hand over I hand over to him. You sent the invitation letter for Mr. Hand to visit the shipyard by WhatsApp. Do you remember that? >> Yes. >> And we've already seen that you sent the Admiral Marie quotation by email. Do you remember that? >> Yes, I see it yesterday. And you sent the signed loan agreement by email. Do you remember that? >> Yes. >> If you were going to send the admiral report to Mr. Ivankovich, you would have sent that by email as well, wouldn't you? Can I make a comment regarding the hand delivery? >> Well, the question is, if you were going to send the admiral report to Mr. Ivankovic, you would have sent that by email, wouldn't you? What's your answer to that question? But >> Mr. Steven was experiencing a difficult financial situation before that's what what I take into consideration before sending it by email. >> Please please make the comment if you want to as well. >> Okay. I dealt with Mr. Steven as a partner and I trusted him. >> Okay. And I have discussed the topic of the report with him >> and he instructed me not to send the report by email and I'm going to arrange the payment within uh two to three uh weeks. uh and at the end of July >> and this is just an example. I'm giving an example. >> Okay. >> Mr. Steven asked me to go with him to company. >> Okay. And after five minutes or 10 minutes after we have arrived at premises town, >> he decided to buy town house for the value of 25 million dirhams dollar. Sorry. Okay. Okay. This is an example that if Mr. Steven would like to do something, he will do it and he will continue to to do it. And I remember that he has he has asked my assistants in November down payment that the down payment that he has made to company would be confiscated because he has made late payments. Okay. And I talked to Steven and Steven talked to >> I think maybe in October or November down payment and uh not to lose the down payment. He asked me to transfer 100,000 dirhams. He asked me to transfer it to so he he wouldn't lose the the down payment he has made has made to And I was surprised that he hasn't completed Akila deal and he was telling me that there's some money that is is coming despite the fact that he can pay So I did him a favor that I kept the yacht despite the fact that he has made late payment for more than one year. >> Can I just ask sorry Mr. Watson one question um that I mean to ask did uh Mr. Vankovich explain to you why he did not want the report be emailed. Okay. Okay. It was sarcastic because he told me that I know that I have five days Uh, so please do not send it by email and I'm going to arrange the money. >> And you told me even that you have received the down payment without signing the contract. >> So it was about all it was all about trust. >> Okay. Thank you. >> Well, Mr. nostalgia as me. Everything that you just said over the last 5 minutes or so is not in your witness statement. And I suggest to you it's not true. But we've got to move on because I've only got a limited amount of time. Uh I want to make a comment on what you have just said. You can make a comment but only briefly because we have a lot of time. We have a we have a short time please. >> Okay. >> I was just an example. >> I'm just giving you an example. >> And this is a real example. >> Yes. >> That's all. >> Thank you. >> Could we go uh up to paragraph 44 to scroll up for the operator? Thank you. Um, here you say you were following up with Mr. Ivankovic and you say up until February 2024 and you say you met Mr. Vangovich in person on multiple occasions. You don't stay here when you're dealing with February 2024 that you provided the the corrective actions report, do you? Steven, >> I didn't mention it because there was no disagreement over the initial report uh on the side of Steven. Steven just told him he just give me a period of two weeks or three weeks so I can arrange the money and then this two weeks or three weeks uh it continued till I filed the suit >> or they they have filed their case. Uh could we go to page 74 please in the bundle? Uh this is Mr. Ivankovic's witness statement in the loan claim. Uh do you remember reading this Mr. Hazmi Steven? Yes, I read it. >> And you made a witness statement in response to this, didn't you? >> Yes. >> If we go to page 78. Thank you. If we um just scroll down, you see Mr. Jovankovic says, "I understand in these proceedings KJM alleges that shortly after Enzo undertook his survey, KJM sent the survey report to Contessa. That's not true." And then you see uh towards the bottom of paragraph 21, he says, "In an email dated 24th of February, KJM lawyers said the survey report was handd delivered to Mr. Ivankovich in or around July 2023 and was again provided in February. This is false. Do you see that? >> And if we scroll down a little bit more, Mr. Ivankerich says, "While I was in Dubai in July 2023 for a short period and again between February and March, I and I did meet with Muhammad on both occasions, I'm certain I was never given a copy of the survey report produced by Enzo, whether by hand or by any other method. The report is 102 pages long. I would recall receiving it by hand from Muhammad. So you must have read this Mr. >> Yes. And you must have thought that it was not true. >> Yes. It's not true because I handed it to him by hand. Right. And and you didn't address it at all in your second witness statement, did you? WhatsApp. If he didn't receive the report, why he asked us to make arrangements for uh the payment? Well, unfortunately, Mr. Raj Jasmine, this isn't an opportunity when you get to ask me questions. >> No, I'm not asked. >> I'm not asking. >> My question was, you didn't address these paragraphs in your second witness statement, did you? I don't remember whether I responded to this uh paragraph or or not. >> Should we go to page 113 of the bundle? So, this is your second witness statement. That's just to show you the first page. Just scroll up to 112. There it is. And you deal with two issues at 113. You deal with whether you gave an address for Sino Eagle to Mr. Hand so that he could get a visa. Do you see that? Yes, correct. >> And you you deal with that over two pages. If the operator could just scroll down to show us that. >> And then at the bottom you deal with events towards the end of the chronology, February, July. If we just scroll down now, Mr. Al Jasmine, if you had really handed over the Admiral report in July 2023, you would have read Mr. Ivankovic's statement and you'd have said to yourself, "That's not right." And you would have wanted to to write down in this witness statement what really happened. But you didn't. And that's because you never handed it over in July 2023. No, I handed the report over to Mr. Steven and I'm clear about what I did. regarding my response to the statement of Mr. Steven was putting the blame on us that we did not assist Ollie and this is not correct >> and we have >> I should say I'm not really interested in that star jasmine I don't want to cut you off but you've said what do you want to Um, your honor, I was going to move to a a new document. >> I'm sorry, Mr. Watson. The witness said something to the interpreter. I'd like the interpreter to tell me what he said >> because you have mentioned something about OI regarding uh the assistance to get assistance regarding the invitation and we we have assisted Mr. only with the invitation oi. >> That's why I clarify the point about oi and we give all assistance to oi. >> Yes. Yes, I see that. I'd just be grateful if Mr. Now, Jasmine, if you could just answer the question as to why you didn't say anything when you're replying to Mr. uh Ivankovic's witness statement and you say he's saying something is untrue. This was your opportunity to say it's not true. So, I was just wondering why you didn't say it was not true in your witness statement. This is the first time to appear in court and >> if I miss something So I may be mistaken. >> Okay. Thank you. >> Um >> Mr. Watson, you were going to suggest we take our break now. Were you? >> Yes. It's a little bit earlier than I might have done, but um if the it's a convenient point and if there's a laptop available, let's get that. >> Okay, let's take a break now. Uh it's around uh 12:15 Dubai time. Uh let's resume at 12:25 and so that the uh new setup can be uh installed at Mr. Al Jasmy's end. Okay. So we'll take 10-minute break, please. We lost Mr. J. Ah, there we are. Good. That's better. Okay. Uh, Mr. Al Jasmic looks like it's muted. I I think your honor he there's another microphone in the room. >> Okay. >> Could you say something Mr. Rajasi? >> No. >> Could you just say one, two, three, please? >> One, two, three. >> That's okay. I can hear you perfectly. Thank you. Uh, okay. Are we ready to resume? >> I think so. Right. >> Um, could we please in the bundle now go to page 1095? And these are the minutes of a meeting held at KJN on August the 23rd, 2023. And it records you being present at the meeting, Mr. Al Jasmine. Do do you remember it? >> Yes. And we can see that uh point one was something to do with the Sun Seeker and then points two and three and possibly four are to do with uh the Aquilla yacht. And there's a discussion, isn't there, about a plan to offer it uh for potential renting with an interest rate. Do you see that? >> Yes. And five records that Parish has sent documents to Morant Co. for the IMG boats. Do you see that? There's no mention in here of the admiral report having been provided to anyone, is there? Steven report. No one except me and Steven know about the admiral report and one and also one of the employees already know about it. We haven't discussed the admiral report as a sign of respect to Steven because he hasn't discussed it and in return I respect it and I haven't discussed it as well. >> Right. Can you help me with this Mr. Alasmi? Earlier in your evidence today, you said, and I quote, uh, Mr. Steven visited us in July and August and September, and we have been talking about the report in all the meetings that we have that we had with Mr. Steven, but you didn't talk about the report in this meeting, did you? July September. Okay. Okay. We didn't talk about the report in this meeting as a sign of respect. And if he didn't talk about it, I wouldn't talk about it as well. Sorry, please continue. They prepared the minutes of meeting and they didn't talk about the report and for example what is the relation uh in regard to Nathan to this meeting? >> Well, the reason that you didn't talk about the admiral report in this meeting is because you hadn't handed it over. That's right, isn't it? I gave a clear answer. The report has been uh delivered in July. >> Can we just go back to the defense page 20 please? Can we look at paragraph 15? Mr. Jasmine, this is your defense and counter claim KJN's and it says on 19th of October, Mr. Ivankovich informed KJM that Contessa was content to release the remaining balance under the loan agreement. Do you see that? >> Okay. loan agreement Mr. loan. >> No, I don't remember this. >> You don't remember that? Can we look at um your witness statement where you deal with this page 96? And if we scroll down to paragraph 46, you say, "During our various meetings at this time, Mr. Ilankovic kept giving me different explanations for failing to pay. He assured me he would transfer the balance soon. He told me he'd already made the transfer, but had lost the bank slip." Now, I suggest to you that's not true, is it? No, we have correspondences and we have emails. >> And then at at paragraph 46.3, you say in October he told Parouch over email that the outstanding balance is too significant and he would like to renegotiate the loan terms. Do you see that? >> Yes. That's not what was said in the defense, is it? message. This was a message and it was sarcastic message >> or I I think it's an email, not even a message. >> And you've not produced that email, have you? Yeah, I think I I submitted it. Well, you see that there's no exhibit reference. If you go look at paragraph 47, there's a little reference in black that's inserted by your lawyers. M AJ122 hyphen 124. where there's a document your lawyers put the reference in. There's no email where Mr. Ivankovich says that the balance is too significant, is there? I don't know whether it has been submitted or not. >> Well, it hasn't. And I'm going to suggest to you that the reason it hasn't is because that email was never sent. WhatsApp. The email has been sent and we have messages also on WhatsApp. >> I mentioned the email that I have sent that was on 29 February. WhatsApp and if you can notice there there is no mention of the payments between me and Mr. Steven as a sign of respect to him. Only just this email that had the the because the factory was having a pressure on me. That's why I send the email. >> Well, let's have a look at it. It's page 186 in the bundle. This is the email you were referring to, isn't it? >> Go. >> Yes. >> And uh you do not say in this email that the admiral report had been sent to him, do you? Okay. I haven't mentioned this in the email because if I mentioned it in the email, he would be limited to 5 days as a grace period to make the payment and as a sign of respect. I didn't mention this in the email. You say that the yacht has been ready for a long time at the factory. When was the yacht in your view ready? report after the completion of the survey report and I did discussion with Steven and he has told me that the remarks are normal. >> Okay. And I told him that the factory would make the necessary corrections. >> Okay. So as far as I know I I bought time I I gained the time from the factory. Okay. And then eventually we asked for a correction report from the factory and it has been sent to us in February. >> And I show the report to Steven in his visit in February. Okay. Uh and Steven didn't make any sign that he wouldn't pay uh the uh uh money and he has promised to pay the money. >> Can we just look at the corrective actions report? It's pa page 1183. Just zoom out. You recognize this, don't you, Mr. Al Jasmine? >> I believe. >> Yes. >> And do you see the date is the 29th of February? >> So if you were going to show this to Mr. Ivankovic in February, as you say, you must have met him on the 29th of February. February. >> I met him at the end of February in March >> and he was in Dubai and also I met him in the first week of March. >> Did you receive this from the factory on the 29th of February or did you receive it later? I'm not sure about the date of what date what date I received the report. So I need to check the date of the email that was sent from the factory. >> If we go back to 1186 Mr. Jasmine, you see that this email is dated the same day. It's the 29th of February. Do you see that? >> Okay. >> So, what is what is what does this has to do with the other thing? But when you said the yacht has been ready for a long time at the factory, had you received the corrective actions report yet or not? I was trying to buy time >> from the factories. >> That's not the question. Mr. Arasmi, when you sent this email, had you received the corrective actions report? telephone. No, because uh based on our relation with the factory, I have been informed that the corrections have been already made uh and I was informed by phone. >> Ah, so when you were saying to Mr. Ivankovich. Uh the you know the yacht has been ready, the corrections have been made. You were doing that on the basis of just a phone call with the shipyard. Okay. Okay. I have employees that are continuously in contact with the factory and they are aware that the corrections have been already made. So presumably, did did one of your employees ask uh the shipyard to to make the corrections? foreign. Okay. Yes, certainly because one of our employees uh visited the factory and he asked them to make corrections if there is something wrong or incomplete he would ask them to correct it and this was in June and this is a normal procedure with regard to any of any. >> We are sending one of our employees >> to check the uh boat or the y >> and something was uh wrong or incomplete and that's why your employees asked the shipyard to make the corrections. There was no substantial uh mistakes or wrong but there was just some remarks >> and this is a normal action with any builder or uh those factors. >> Well, they were substantial enough for your employees to ask the shipyard to correct them, weren't they? They are minor things like painting or putting some silicon. They are minor things not that substantial. So based on our experience, we are dealing with many factories in US, in Europe and in China and we we usually send an employee if he has any remarks or minor comments he would notify the factory. And this is the duty of our company to do so. >> Okay. This is for the purpose of integrity and transparency and we wouldn't allow any boat to be shipped or to be delivered without checking it and make the necessary comments. Uh you're on mute I think your honor. You're >> sorry. Always a problem. Um major I just asked a question. Uh Mr. Al Jasmine, you said that uh an employee actually was present uh with the vessel at some point. Was the employee present when the original admiral report uh was compiled? the admiral inspection or was the employee uh present when the yard gave the uh corrective report? Or was it both? payment, >> he was present in both cases. >> Okay. Yeah. >> Okay. Down payment. >> After the down payment was made >> to the factory. >> Okay. >> We sent one of our employees. And this is a normal course of action that we used to do with any deal. For example, I have two yachts that has that have arrived in Maldives today. >> Okay. Before the yachts moving from the factory, we had already sent an employee and yesterday we sent another employee >> to Maldives to hand over the yacht to the customers. >> Thank you. So there were no visa problems in your employees attending the yard. Then >> we ask the factory to give us invitation letter. Okay. and the employee would visit the relevant embassy. As far as I know, the visa takes from 2 days to 3 days to be issued as far as I know. Okay. And so far, we didn't have an issue with the visa issuance regarding our employees. Thank you. >> Thank you, your honor. Um, could we now turn to page 1207 in the bundle? Do you recognize this document, Mr. Al Jazzmi? It's a It's a memo that was sent by Mr. Ivankovic to you on the 9th of April, 2024. Do you recall this? >> Sorry. 1207. >> Yeah. Oh, >> okay. Yes, I have it. >> Okay. Yes. >> And he he's mostly talking about things to do with the JV. But if we go to the bottom of page 1208, uh Mr. Ivankovich says of the Aquilla, Casey Flipman is reaching out to finalize the purchase and coordinate logistics. Who should she contact? Will this vessel be shipped to US market for sale or stay in the GCC? Do you see that? >> Yes. >> And do you know who Casey Flitman is? >> Sorry. >> Do you know who Casey Flitman is? >> Casey Fitman. >> She is a lawyer from his law firm company. And if we go to page 1968, we see her email to Parish on the 12th of April, 2024. Do you see that? >> Come labor. >> And we can see that you're copied MJ kjm. That's you, isn't it? Yes. >> And she says, "Can you send us a copy of the agreement with builder, proof of payments made to the builder, and whatever documents you have on this yacht for our file?" Do you see that? >> Yes. >> And then if we look at 1969, we see now on the 17th of April, Mr. hand emails you personally. Do you see that? >> Yes. >> And he says, "Could you please reply to Casey's email regarding the Aquilla? Do you see that?" So, no one had at this point replied to Casey's email, had they? And she'd asked for all the documents. And you hadn't supplied the admiral report, had you? She asked if you go back. >> That's all right. >> What did she ask for? Would you please go back to the your email? >> 1 1968. She didn't mention anything about the report. >> Well, Mr. Al Jazzmi, she asks for whatever documents you have on this yacht. I mean, isn't the admiral report a document about the yacht? She's asking for the contract between the builder and the KJM. Why should I send her such documents? Contessa being KGM >> and she she is not mentioned in the contract between Contessa and uh KGM. >> Right. Well, let's have a look at what you do say in response to this. Um if we go to page 1211, you get a memo on KJM headed paper addressed to Stephen And we can see on the last page 1213 that it comes from you. Do you remember this document? And if we just scroll up a little bit to the bottom of 1212. Thank you. This is where you deal with the Aquilla and you say in reference to the email dated April the 12th, 2024 sent from Casey, please note the following. And you say, please note the status of the remainder balance in amount of 2.3 million has been communicated to yourself by virtue of email dated 19th of October 23. Do you see that? >> Yes. And um you attach that email, don't you? >> Yes. And um I think your honor has already seen that as it was said by Mr. Hyderabad Waller. I'm going to ask him some questions about that. But you also attached the seat trial report. Do you see that Cal report? >> See attachment GC trial report. >> Okay. >> Yeah, it's written here. >> Now, that had been sent to Mr. Ivankovic in March 2023, hadn't it? >> The Merc trial report has been delivered by hand >> in July. >> In July. What do you know what we mean by the sea trial report? Mr. >> Crial report this is about the factory report regarding the engines. I >> I think so. >> Well, I I just want to check that you're not getting confused. Do you see it says attachment G seat trial report and then if we go to page 1242 we got attachment G and if I can ask the operator to scroll down that's the seat trial report you can see this is the report that was the seat trial was carried out in December 202 22. Do you see that? >> Yes. >> So, you didn't send the admiral report, did you? Okay. Oh, I'm going to repeat this again and over. I have said that I dealt with Mr. Steven as a brother and I dealt in good faith and I I trusted him and I know that if I send it by email, I know that he didn't have the money or he is experiencing difficulties to make the payment. >> Let's go back to um page 121. Sorry, 1212. and scroll down. So, uh, you attach the email of 19th of October, which he's already seen, and you attach the seat trial report, which is, >> sorry, can you just give me for my note, could I just have the reference the 19th October email, please? Um yes your honor that is um sorry just give me a moment it's in my >> just help me to cross refer >> yes that is >> uh one two one >> one two one >> thank And then what you say uh so you sent you sent Mr. Ivankovich two documents that you have been emailed to him before and then you say at the bottom as for the related documents due to confidentiality restrictions pursuant to the master agreements signed by KJM and between the principal factory. Please note that all supporting documents, invoices, and other financial documents are available for on-site review at KJM premises. Do you see that? >> Yes. So, >> you were saying I'm not going to send you anything else, weren't you? >> I'm not going to send it. I'm not going to send it by email. If you would like to see all the documents regarding the transfers that have been made to the factory can come on site and review it. But I have submitted all the transfer documents to the and the transfers uh to the case management. >> Right. Can we go to uh page 97? Now if we scroll down and look at paragraphs 51 and 52, uh there came a point, didn't there Mr. Al Jazzmi, in about June 2024 where Mr. Muhammad Radwan stepped in and started sending emails backwards and forwards to Mr. Moore. Do you remember that? >> Yes. Now, we can all read those emails and and actually you're not copied to them, so I'm not going to take them through I'm not going to take you through all of them, but I want you to just look at a couple, please. Can we look at page 1287? >> Do you see that? >> Yes. >> And this is an email from Mr. Ravan to Mr. more and there's an attachment report ADMC23342 attached. Do you see that? >> Okay. >> I I don't think it's controversial. That is the admiral report. >> Yes. >> Uh and we can see what Mr. Radwan says. He says, "Kindly note that Muhammad Al Jasmi has communicated on multiple occasions the yacht reports." Do you see that? Now, presumably he's saying that because that's what you told him. >> Yes. >> Just um help us if you can. Um Mr. Radwan, he he works for Mr. Al Karafi, doesn't he? >> Yes. Mr. Al Karafi is quite an important person, isn't he? >> Yes. >> You wouldn't want to upset him, would you? >> Uh, your question is not clear. >> You wouldn't want to make Mr. Al Karafi unhappy with you, would you? What is the relation between and >> and to make him upset or unhappy? >> Yes. You wouldn't want you would want to do anything would you Mr. Al Jasmi that would make your business partner Mr. Al Karafi unhappy. Of course, I wouldn't because I didn't I didn't even cause any uh issue with Steven. How would I do with my partner? >> Well, when Muhammad Radwan asked you if you had sent the admiral report before, you said yes. But that wasn't true, was it? I handed handed over the report to Steven >> in July. >> In July. >> Well, I suggest um you didn't tell Mr. Radan the truth. And the reason you didn't tell Mr. Radan the truth was because you didn't want to upset Mr. Al Karafi. KGM is a partner in KJM and nothing to hide from Mr. or to do it from behind his back and he is aware of what is going on. >> Well, Mr. Radwan in this email says that you had communicated the yacht reports on multiple occasions, but your evidence today is that you just handed it over once in July. So that bit's inaccurate, isn't it? July, July. The actual hand over the report was in July and we discussed is it in July and August and September and maybe the discussion uh that we have uh uh regarding the report was interpreted as a handover but the actual handover was in July only. >> Well uh Mr. Al Jazzmi, the reason why Muhammad Radwan says that the reports were communicated on multiple occasions is because that's what you told him and that wasn't true. Yes, I have I have told him that we have discussed the report in multiple occasions but maybe he understood it as communicated not as discussed. I have a comment. >> Would you allow me, please? Okay. The reason why Mr. Rodwan has been interfering in this issue because he was preparing the joint venture uh documents and he is already in contact with Mr. Michael. >> Okay. >> The lawyer from the other side. for and after we run out of all options and everything, we had to send the report by email. >> Okay. >> And it has been sent through his lawyer. So they would know that there is no time and we are short of time and we are facing too much pressure from the factory. down payment. Because of our good relation with the factory, we are buying time. And it has been extended for one year and more, one year and three months. But however, Steven changed his plans and we were doing this to uh protect and to keep uh to protect the down payment that has been bailed by Steven. >> Can we go please to page 99 in the bundle? This is back into your witness statement. Look at paragraph 53 and the the third line you you comment on what you understood from all these emails. You say I understood from their communication particularly their email on 2nd of August 2024 that contesta was going to pay the balance amount of US dollar 2.39 million. Do you see that? Yes. In fact, um, Mr. Ivankovich and his lawyers had never said that Contessa was going to pay the balance, had they? No, he mentioned it and he mentioned that they need to pay directly to the factory and we do not have any objection and we have arranged an invoice for the balance amount and the invoice included the bank this bank details or the bank account of KGM detail and the bank account details of the factory as well >> and they are free and they have options whether to transfer the payment to the factory or to Kam >> and can we uh let's look at the 2nd of August even Now it is page 1321 and um perhaps if the I could ask the operator to sort of scroll down a bit so we can fit the entire email on there. Thank you. And can you see there's a a little uh series of numbered paragraphs at the bottom? Do you see that? And he says, "Can you give us the name and contact information for someone in the yard who will permit Mr. Ivanovich to send a representative to the yard to do a pre-ely inspection?" And he says, "After the pre- purchase inspection is complete, we will send the final wire directly to the young." Do you see that? >> Yes. So you cannot have thought on reading this email that Contessa or Mr. Ivankovic or anyone connected with him was just going to send 2.39 million. The the purpose of this email is to buy time because there was a notice that was sent in July or end of June because the deadline already passed. why he didn't ask for such issues before the deadline. >> Well, I'm going to suggest something different, Mr. Al Jasmi. In fact, what happens is Mr. Ivankovic says or his representatives say, "I want to see an upto-date inspection report because he'd never received one." And that's what he's asking for here. And he never said, "I'm just going to send the money." That's the reality. Okay. He has read the inspection report in July and the inspection report has been sent to to his lawyer and we haven't received any comment or remarks on the inspection report from their side. Sorry. You are you saying that you hadn't received any uh comment from his lawyers after it had been sent in July 2024? We haven't received any comment that there are any issues with the report. >> Can we look at page uh 1301 now in fairness to you? If we scroll to the bottom please, there's an email here from Casey Flipman on the 23rd of July 2024. In fairness to you, Mr. Aljas, you are not copy of this email, but it's 23rd of July, so it's after the Admiral report had been emailed to Moren Co. If I could ask the operator just to scroll down, sorry, scroll down um onto page 132 and there's a little note. Admiral Marine Consulting, the survey is for the condition of the yacht found on 2nd to 10 July 2023. Note from Casey, the survey is more than a year old and there were repairs and improvements made in February 2024. Is there an updated survey? The lawyers were saying the only survey we've seen is more than a year old. So when you said uh earlier that the lawyers had never the lawyers hadn't you said we hadn't received any comment or remarks on the inspection report from their side. That wasn't correct, was it? What is the date of this email? >> You can see that at page 131. >> 23rd of July, 2024. >> And what is the date of the email that uh uh included the report? Uh that's at page 1287 11th of July about 11 days 12 days later. According to the according to the contract, we should get response to our email within 5 days. Whether you accept the uh the report or not, it should uh the the reply should be within 5 days. So you think that the loan agreement requires an email response within 5 days? Okay. The report has been sent in July. If Steven failed to submit the report to uh his lawyers, this is his problem, not my problem. And they should come back to us within uh 5 days and they should make the remaining balance and they know that they are going to lose the down payment. Another example to clarify I said earlier regarding so to for the purpose of not losing the down payment that was made to Mr. has even asked my request, my assistance and this would apply to the same issue here. >> If he was serious about it, >> okay, we can sort it out using other options. >> He can transfer part of the uh amount. >> Okay. and he can visit the factory and I suggested to him that he can make a visit to the factory and I I would I would like to stress the fact that he make use of our kindness and our good treatment. And I said earlier that we have been in the business of yachts and visels for many years and we haven't been to we haven't been exposed to such kind of cases or court cases and we make order for a large number of yachts and vessels and there were no problems at all. >> Can we now turn to uh page 99 of the bundle? This is back to your witness statement and look at uh paragraph 55. You say uh ultimately because contestant did not advance the loan balance by the given deadline, Sino Eagle forfeited the deposit sold the Aquilla 70 to a third party. So KJM attempted through multiple calls with the factory to recover the down payment of 1.6 million and the installments totaling US dollar 400,000 uh 400,000 it paid to Sino Eagle. Do you see that? >> Yes. >> Now uh 1.6 6 million plus 400,000 is 2 million, isn't it? >> Yes. >> Now, I think we know from the bank transfers that you've produced that actually the amount paid was only about 1.8 million, wasn't it? No, more than this amount. More than 1.8 survey report. I paid for the surveyor report. I paid for the travel expenses for the employee who was checking the yacht. Okay. >> If you need the breakdown, yes, it's approximately 2 million US dollar. But Mr. Jasmine, you didn't pay uh when you paid for the survey report or paid for travel expenses for the employee. You didn't pay that to Sino Eagle, did you? >> No. >> And you would always have had to have paid for a survey report and paid for travel expenses, wouldn't you? There was no mention of the survey costes in the financial statement. But when we are talking about the losses, the total loss, it's about2 million US. Um, you say that Sino Eagle forfeited the deposit in August 2024, don't you? >> Steven, >> I didn't mention it. There was an email and we forwarded this email. This email was sent by the factory and we have been forwarding this email to uh the lawyer of uh uh Steven. You have been unable to point to any contractual term that required payment by KJM by any particular date. Have you? I was shocked when Steven filed his case. >> Okay. As I said before, we have been dealing with Steven with honesty. >> This is not an answer. I'm sorry to interrupt you, but you've given some very long answers. This is not an answer to my question. >> He's just to make clarification. He's >> Well, the the question is you have been unable to point to any contractual term that required payment by KJM to Sino Eagle by any particular date. Now, that is true, isn't it? So to answer your question, I need to make clarification. Okay. Go on. Steven has transferred 1.6 million before signing the contract. >> Okay. after the transfer of the payment. He said, "My lawyer will be arranging the contract." And then his lawyer already completed and drafted the contract and tell the uh time. Okay. and according to my research. >> Okay. This is the way he's dealing. >> Okay. >> And he make use of of us as a company and they make use of our friendship. >> This is my response. >> Mr. Mr. Jasmine, you are an experienced businessman. You know what a contract is. Now, I'm going to ask you another question. You say that Sino Eagle forfeited the deposit, but you have been unable to point to any contractual term that entitled Sino Eagle to forfeit the deposit. Have you? foreign. Okay. Mr. Steven is the one who asked his lawyer to prepare the contract and we acted in good in good faith and we left the process of drafting the contract to the lawyer of Mr. Steven. >> But my question Mr. Al Jasmine is about the contract between KJN and Sino Eagle. Mr. which had nothing to do with that contract eagle. >> Okay. Yes, it has. It hasn't entitled to forfeit the amount because of the email of the letter it has sent uh in regard to the late payment and we have received their email. That's why they have they are entitled to forfeit the uh amount. >> The the shipyard has got a wind fork here, hasn't it? Because it's kept the 1 8 million and it sold the yacht to a third party. If the factory made windfall or becoming making a good profit this not my mistake this not because of my mistake >> you didn't instruct any lawyers to try and recover the deposit from sino eagle did menagle. No, I didn't because it's clear and because of this issue we have lost market in Saudi Arabia and in Egypt and because their letter was very clear. Well, you continue to work with Sino Eagle, don't you? Okay. Um, as a company in the business of building uh these yachts and uh in the business of buying and selling yachts and vessels, I have made contract with other companies because I have to obtain other agencies because I already lost uh this relationship with >> and the friendship and the trust with uh sin eagle. Mr. Al Jasmine, I I think you understand the question and it's going to go much quicker if you just answer it. The question was, you continue to work with Sino Eagle, don't you? >> That's a yes or no question. >> Yes. Yes, I >> The reality is, you just let this money go because you didn't want to disrupt that relationship with Sino Eagle. Isn't that right? 70. >> I already lost two markets, Saudi Arabia and Egypt because of this Akila. >> Did you ask Sino Eagle to give you credit on other transactions for the 1.8 8 million that you had paid. >> No, I didn't. >> Um, your honor, that's probably a convenient point for the um lunch adjournment. You're on mute. Okay. You want to take it at this stage? >> Okay. I was going to run. >> I mean, I'm very happy to to continue if your honor would want I've come to a natural break. I was going to move on to the JV. Um >> Okay. Well, in that case, you're going to move on to JV. I I do have a a question and I'm content to take lunch at this stage, which is 135 Dubai. Uh okay. Um, let me just uh look at this. Uh, could you uh please go to page 1121. So this is the email of 19th October that was a next to uh Mr. Jassim, your um memorandum we looked at before. You remember this email, do you? >> Yes. >> Yes. Okay. And it's not from you. It's from uh Parouch, but uh it's to Mr. Ivankovich. As per your request, the balance for the Aquilla is 2.399 million. amount received USD 1.6 million. That's the 1.6 million he'd paid actually before even the contract was signed. That that's correct, isn't it? >> Yes. >> Um was that 1.6 million paid to Sino Eagle? uh pay when we receive the money. >> After we received the the payment, we paid it for the booking of the youth $1 million US. >> Okay. Sorry. >> So, what about the 6 million >> and the remaining amount was sent in installments? So as of the 19th October 2023, you hadn't paid 1.6 million to Sino Eagle. Is that correct? >> Yes. >> Yes. Okay. Thank you very much. I I I have no other question. if if it assists um your honor um over the lunch adjournment. I think at paragraph 36 of my skeleton, I set out a little table of all the the payment transfers from KJM to Sino Eagle with a cross reference to the um uh the bank transfer document. I don't understand that that table is contentious. So, >> no, I I I reinvented that wheel myself too without looking at the Okay, there you Thank you very much indeed. Okay. >> Yes. I think both both MS and I have tried to be teachers pet by doing the same exercise. So that that for me is a paragraph 51 of my skeletonism. >> Okay. Well, I I'll compare I'll compare your efforts with mine and and just to make sure that they're all um consistent with each other. Okay. So, look, it's nearly uh 20 to 2 in in Dubai. So let's come back at at 223 Dubai time. Okay. So we'll take the lunch break now. Thank you very much. >> Oh, Mr. One thing, please don't speak to anybody about your evidence during this break. While you're giving evidence and while you're under oath, you mustn't discuss your evidence with anybody. >> Okay. Thank you very much. >> Thank you. >> Don't see Mr. Paige. Ah, there you are. >> Sorry. >> Okay, let's proceed. >> Could we please go to page 672 in the bundle? >> This um Mr. Al Jasmi is your first witness statement in the joint venture agreement claim, but it in fact you you set out the same uh account of meetings as you did in the the loan agreement. And can you see here you you talk at paragraph 18 about a meeting on the 7th of February 2023. Do you see that? >> Yes. And this meeting took place before the joint venture agreement was signed, didn't it? >> Yes. >> And uh at paragraph 18.2, you talk about some of the things that you say was said and you at the end of that paragraph, you say, "Mr. Ivankovich had also put forward a preliminary highlevel framework for the joint venture which included the following. Mr. Ivankovich would pres pro provide the design and the physical molds for the boats. Do you see that? >> Yes. Now if we just go forward in your statement to page 678, you deal at the top here at page 27 with the execution of the JV agreement and you say the executed draft reflected the framework previously we have previously discussed with Mr. Ivankovich mainly that and then at 27.5 you say Mr. of Ankorich would supply the moles for the leisure boats that will be manufactured by KJI Marina. Do you see that? >> Yes. >> So your evidence is that the joint venture agreement reflected your discussion that Mr. Ivankovich would supply the physical molds. >> He will supply the mold related to the aquaform watercraft. This is what he told me. which is the manufacturer in it. It used to have been requested and ordered from China, but Mr. Steven would like to design it and manufacture it in Dubai. >> Right. Let's have a look at the joint venture agreement. at page 881. And can you see there at A under B, Ivankovich declares he has the financial resources to provide the required capital for the funding of the fabrication, design and manufacture of vessels. Do you see that? >> Yes. That's about the provision of cash by Mr. Ivanovich, isn't it? >> Yes. >> In my statement, I just state the facts that has happened. >> Right? Well, if we look down at page 881 at the bottom here, it says if Ankovich is to contribute the following as as its initial contribution. A the initial capital to design and fabricate necessary molds and vessel fabrication. Do you see that? >> Yes. >> So, what this is recording is that Mr. Ankovich is going to provide the capital to fabricate the molds, not the molds themselves. In regard to the aquaor, Mr. Ivanovich committed to bring the molds and to manufacture it in Dubai. >> So >> this was this was before the joint de venture company. So your so your evidence is that Mr. Vankovich committed aquaform to supply the molds. Is that right? According to Steven, he owned 50% of Aquafur and evidence to this that in May his WhatsApp he sent him a message on WhatsApp that he owned the Aquaform 100%. >> Well, Mr. Al Jasmine, you've litigated that in Dubai and you've lost and I'm not going to go back over it. Um, if we just scroll down uh the page, you see again a little D at the top there, the amount of initial contribution is $2 million for for setting up the factory infrastructure and preparing equipment for production such as molds. So, I'm going to put this to you. You're right in your evidence when you say that the joint venture agreement reflected what you had discussed, but you had never discussed Mr. Ivankovic supplying physical molds for the joint venture. >> Can I give a comment? Well, I I've I've suggested to you that you never discussed Mr. Ivankovich supplying physical molds. You you can answer that question. >> Can I give a comment on this? >> Yeah. Yes, of course. You you answer in the way that you want to. As long as it's a not a long speech, please. after signing the joint venture contract in the end of September or in the beginning of October >> purchase order. I received a purchase order. >> Okay. From Aquaform. >> From Aquaform. watercraft where there requested 20 ports for the molds that I have ordered. Okay, and two British orders for accessories for two boats purchase order which is order for about 40 boats which is >> that are in USA according according to Steven. >> Okay. This would be manufactured here and would these parts would be sent to USA. Right. I I don't understand how that's an answer to my question, but as time is short, you've had an opportunity and I'm going to move on. Um, in the joint venture agreement with Mr. >> If not for Mr. Watson to give comment on the the witness's answers, um, he may or may not like the answer, but there it is. >> In the joint venture. Sorry. All right. >> I was going to say let's proceed. In the joint venture agreement with Mr. Ivankovich, it was agreed that there would be three initial directors, wasn't it? >> Yes. >> Uh Mr. Ivankovic, you, and an independent director. >> Yes. >> And you signed that agreement in March 2023, didn't you? >> Yes. And then I think if we go to page 9001 in the bundle, I think this is the WhatsApp message you were referring to a little bit earlier, isn't it? >> Steven Le, >> this was sent by Steven to me. >> Yes. So this is from Steven's phone. So his messages are in green and your responses are in uh white and he says FYI, I have been working on this for the US. You and me are obviously directors. Let me know your thoughts. And he sends you an organization chart. And then he says, would to create something similar for Dubai when we know where pieces fit. So his statement, you and me are obviously directors. He's referring to the JV there, isn't he? >> Yes. >> And this is sent in on the 24th of May, 2023. >> Yes. >> And you I think you give it a little kind of heart emoji. Do you see that? >> Yes. >> You you obviously approved of what he was saying, >> speaker. There's JV there. Yeah, of course. >> Can we go back to your witness statement now? Um, page 679. And if we just look at paragraph 29 at the top, you say, "However, after the JV agreement was executed in March 2023, I could not get hold of Mr. Ivankovic until around July 2023. Had you just forgotten this WhatsApp exchange, Mr. Arjasmi? >> No. Meaning related to the JV payment. >> Will you say I could not get hold of Mr. Revankovich until July 2023. And we have just seen that you were exchanging WhatsApps with him in May 2023. That's right, isn't it? >> Yes. >> So when you say in your witness statement, I could not get hold of Mr. Revankovic until July 2023, that was wrong, wasn't it? No, I was mean the payment payment of the jail. >> Well, that's not what you say. You say I do not know where Mr. Ivankovic was and why he was unresponsive. >> Yeah, because he's also I called him, he's not answering the phone. >> Well, okay. He said, we can see he's sending you WhatsApps, Mr. Al Jasmi. Um, if we go down now to paragraph 30, you say that Mr. Ivankovic and you visited the notary public in Dubai. Do you see that? >> Yes. >> And you say although the JV agreement provided that the JV company should have three directors being Mr. Vanovich, me and an independent director, when we visited the notary public, Mr. Ivankovich said he would prefer not to be included as a manager on the JV company's license. Do you not want to be involved in its admin and day-to-day management? Do you see that? Do you see that, Mr. Al Jasmine? >> Yes. >> Mr. Vanovich wanted to be a director, didn't he? >> That time, no. because uh I I'm not wrong. I sent him somewhere end of June or first week of July. >> I sent him the momentum of association on WhatsApp in the end of June or beginning of July. Okay. I asked him if he would like to make any amendments when he was here uh in Dubai before signing the memorandum of association and I asked him to be the director but he told to me no you are the director. >> Sorry may I just ask are you aware of the difference between a director and a manager? Director the manager is managing the company on daily basis. >> So is that an answer that you are aware of the difference between a manager and a director? manager. He told me that you would be >> No, no, no. Just answer. Please just answer the question. Just answer the question. Are you aware of the difference between a director and a manager? >> Yes. >> Manager, director. >> Yes. >> Yes. >> Okay. And are you aware that there is nothing in the uh memorandum of association of this company that uh prevents the partners from appointing anybody a director of the company? Yes, this can be discussed with the board of directors in the general assembly meeting and the decision will be made according to voting. >> Thank you very much. >> Well, you you said a moment ago that Mr. Ivankovich had changed his mind. Um, he said he wanted to be a director in the JV agreement. He said he wanted to be a director in May. He hadn't changed his mind in July, had he? The momentum of association is drafted in Arabic and English. If Mr. Steven has any objection, he would raise such objection. >> Mr. Radwan helped to prepare the memorandum of association, didn't he? >> No, that's not correct. Well, he's a lawyer, isn't he? for the momentum of association. There are offices in the notary public where they are preparing this kind of memorandum of association. >> Is that a yes or a no to the question is Mr. Radwan a lawyer? >> And said Raban Muhammadi >> Mr. He's a legal counselor. >> And you're not a lawyer, are you? >> No. >> No, I'm not. >> And you're not an expert in corporate governance, are you? >> No, I'm not. >> And Mr. Radwan had taken the lead, hadn't he, in negotiating the JV agreement itself? in uh Steven. >> Yes. Radwan and the lawyers from Steven's side >> and Mr. Radwan sent the memorandum of association to Mr. Ivankovic's lawyers, didn't he? WhatsApp. As far as I remember, I sent the memorandum of association to Steven, but I don't remember whether Mr. Rodan sent the memorandum of association uh by email to the lawyers of Mr. Steven. >> Let's have a quick look. um page 1068 in the bundle and and the operator I have to scroll down see July 31st from Muhammad Radwan to Casey Flipman with you uh Michael Moore and Mr. Vangovich in copy. Uh he says please note the first phase has been finalized. All official documents have been formulated by the government registar. Uh kindly find attached here with copies of master documents. A commercial license of KJI B articles and memorandum of associating KJI. And he goes on to ask for the release of the second tranch. Do you see that? And he sent this because he's dealing with the legalities of establishing KJI, isn't he? He sent a head to the lawyers after the completion of the memorandum of association. >> And Mr. Radwan said to Mr. Ivankovic, "You cannot be named as a director in the memorandum of association because you do not yet have an Emirates ID." That's correct, isn't it? director. I don't know what what was going on between them because Adwan has nothing and didn't interfere in the memorandum of association. Well, you say that Mr. Radwan had nothing and didn't interfere in the memorandum of association, but he clearly had something to do with it because he's talking to Mr. Vankovich's lawyers about it in this email, isn't he? what he did he just sent it by email after uh the signing the contract the association that's what all he did well I suggest uh Mr. Al Jasmi that what happened was that there was a meeting and either Mr. Radwan or you said to Mr. Ivankovich, you cannot be named as a director until you have your Emirates ID. And that is why he is not named as a director in the memorandum of association. This is incorrect. The lawyers received the memorandum of association in July >> and they made no comments from their side. >> Mr. Ivankovich obtained his Emirates ID in October 2023, but you didn't do anything after October 2023 to appoint him as a director of KJI, did you? This company is working according to the commercial law of United Arab Emirates and in the last general assembly meeting we were discussing this uh issue but he hasn't got enough votes to be appointed as a director. >> The first uh general assembly meeting was held. >> Can I just follow up on that? >> You may. >> So So Mr. Jas, does that mean that both you and KJM did not vote for Mr. Ivankovich to become a director? That's what that means. Yes. >> Yes. >> Yes. So you So you and KGM did not want Mr. Ivankovic to be a director. >> Otherwise you would have voted for it. KGM >> the KJM is the one who rejected. But if you had voted in favor then there would be 75% because I think you had 25% KJM had 25% uh and uh Mr. Ivankovic had uh 50%. So if you voted with Mr. Ivankovic there would have been 75% which means that he would have been made a director. in the last general assembly meeting. I voted for the KJM and there was So KJM and myself is 50%. >> Yes. So you and KGM did not want Mr. Ivankovich to be a director. Otherwise you would have voted for him. So I I appointed KJM as a proxy to vote on my behalf. >> Yes. But that's not an answer to my question. My question is that you didn't vote for Mr. Ivankovic to be a director. So you must not have wanted him to be a director. Is that correct? >> Yes. Correct. >> And why didn't you want him to be a director? >> Uh because he caused troubles to us more than one time. >> Okay. And there were serious and critical topics that were discussed in the last general assembly meeting. >> I would like to share you the points or the critical issues that have been discussed in the general assembly meeting. If you >> No, that will I'm sure Mr. Watson will deal with that. So, you're talking about the last uh meeting, but what about the first meeting? >> The invitation to convene the first general assembly meeting was for the appointment of the uh financial auditor. >> Okay. And I'm sorry, Mr. Watson. I'll I'll let you take it in your own uh your own. >> It's fine, your honor. Um the first general assembly meeting was held on the 20th of March, 2025, wasn't it? Do you remember that >> was end of February on that? >> Well, let's have a look at your minutes. 1418. Thank you. We just see at the top there, first Ordinary General Assembly meeting of KJI held Thursday, March 20th, 2025. You prepared these minutes, didn't you? >> Yes. >> And Mr. Ivankovic wanted there to be a vote at this meeting on his appointment as a director of KJM, didn't he? >> Yes. And we reply by letter to all. >> Yes. Let's have a let's have a look at that. Uh 1413. This is this is your letter, isn't it? Sorry, maybe if the operator could just scroll up slightly so we can see the KJI heading. You you wrote this, didn't you? Perhaps if we start at the top maybe 1412 you see subject response to the notification from Mr. Ivankovich. >> Yes. >> And your answer to him which is at 1413 is no. You can't have a vote on whether you're going to be a director. We're just going to discuss the appointment of an auditor. >> Yes. >> And then the the next meeting was on uh the 4th of April, 2025, wasn't it? >> Okay. >> Well, should we have let's have a look at your minutes? I think they're at 1471. You prepared these minutes, didn't you? >> Yes. >> And uh we can see agenda item one, the appointment of an external auditor, the company proposed three audit firms and then their three names. Those are the three that you had proposed, weren't they? >> Yes. >> Yes. And if we go over the page to 1473, you can see at the top that again Mr. Ivankovich had raised several points and the first was a request to add and discuss items on the agenda. Mr. requested the following. The appointment of Mr. Steven as a director of the company in addition to appointing a third independent director and discussing his remuneration. Do you see that? And your response to that, if we just go over the page at 1474 next to the word first, because you say the chairman, and I think that's you, reply to the summary thereof as following procedural aspects, article 11.6 explicitly stipulates that no items outside the agenda may be discussed unless during the meeting serious facts arise that necessitate deliberation. So your view was that um Mr. Ivankovich's appointment of a director was not a a serious fact that necessitated deliberation. Is that right? >> Yes. Yes. >> And if we just go back to Mr. Jankovich's request on 1473. He also wanted to discuss the audited financial statements and in the event they are unavailable discuss the company's balance sheet as well as a profit and loss account. And your view was that wasn't a a serious matter for discussion either, was it? with without financial auditor I cannot do it. >> And the third item that Mr. Vankovich wanted to discuss at this meeting was hearing the director's report that's you on the company's activities and financial position and that was something else you thought was not a serious matter for discussion. >> Okay. Okay. Can I reply? Please February. The actual operation start started at the factory at the beginning of February 2024 or at the end of January 2024. Okay. >> Regarding the report of the director, the factory hasn't yet started its operations. Steven visited the factory and he was after the the factory has become operational >> in February 2024. And if we just go to page 1476, we get to the vote about the only agenda item that you allowed, which was to do with the auditor and the representative of Steven voted against making a resolution. This is a two about the appointment of an external auditor due to lack of information about the candidates. The chairman, that's you, stated he bears no legal obligation to do so and there is provision in the UAE companies law that requires him. I think you mean there is no provision in the company's law that requires him to do so. So what had happened is Mr. Ivankovich's representatives had said, "Tell us about these three firms you're suggesting." And your response was to say, "Well, I'm not obliged to tell you anything about them, so I'm not going to." That's what happened, isn't it? Okay. You have the names of the candidates for the for thei financial auditors. they can carry out carry out their research and get information about those candidates. >> Yes. You're not you Mr. Anjasmi are not going to voluntarily provide any information about them, are you? I'm not obliged to give information about the financial auditors according to the commercial uh companies law of United Arab Emirates >> and your your view isn't it Mr. Al Jasmine is that you're only going to give Mr. Ivankovic a 50% shareholder the the bare minimum required by UA law. That's right, isn't it? He already has 50% of the ownership of the company. >> That was probably my poor phrasing of the question. Um, you're only going to give Mr. Ivankovic the minimum information about this company that you are obliged to give by UA law. That's right, isn't it? That's your view. Fore they give him the names of the candidates he is asking. Let's have a look very quickly at the auditor's report. Uh >> sorry before we do that before we leave the minutes. Um can I uh Mr. Alas did you write these minutes yourself? >> My personal assistant the secretary in the office. >> Okay. And is he a lawyer? >> No, he's not a lawyer because these minutes quote uh articles from the UAE company's law. Yes, we did uh uh search for the articles of the law and we added it. >> Okay. So, you personally or your you say we or your personal assistant? >> A minister says secret. >> We together. >> Okay. And you didn't have any legal advice? No. >> No, I didn't. >> Okay. Thank you very much. Your honor, I should perhaps just clarify for your honor. Um, there are a number of statements in the minutes about assertions of UA law. Um, many of them we don't accept, but I'm obviously not going to debate you what UA law actually is with this witness. So, um I I don't propose to deal with many of those. Let's move to the um >> I was only concerned about the authorship. >> Um well, we can um if you just scroll down on the screen on 1476 and that's your signature there on the right, isn't it Mr. Arjasm? So, >> you reviewed these minutes and signed off on them. >> Yes. Okay, let's go to >> and who's >> an employee in the company. >> Okay, thank you. >> Right now we I think we'll go to the financial statements 1702. So, Unity Auditing was one of the three that you had proposed, isn't it? >> Yes. >> And you selected this one, didn't you? >> Yes. >> And arranged for its appointment. Yes, we have chosen this auditor according to the situation in the company >> when it comes to financial position for financial reasons. That's why we have chosen this auditor. >> And if we just look at his auditor's statement under report on other legal and regulatory requirements, he says as required by the UAE federal law number 32 of 2021, we report he's got number of bullet points. The third bullet point is the bank has maintained proper books of account. And then the fourth bullet point says the financial information included in the director's report is consistent with the books of account and records of the bank. And then the last one is is based on the information that's been made available to us. Nothing has come to our attention which causes us to believe that the bank has contravened during the year ended 31st of December applicable provisions. He seems to think he's auditing a bank, doesn't he? Could you please repeat this question? >> This auditor seems to think that he's auditing a bank. This auditor is approved by the ministry. >> I'm sure he is. Um, but it's an auditor's job to spot errors of detail, isn't it? I mean, I suggest we can see even from the first page, uh, this auditor is not of the same caliber as say Baker Tilly, is he? As long as this auditor is approved by the ministry and already we have three candidates we have chosen or selected this auditor. Okay, let's go to the next page. 1703. And you can see there's various numbers there um in relation to what's said to be a a balance sheet for the company. Presumably, you must have given this auditor some documents to allow him to prepare this information. Sorry. To prepare these financial statements. >> Yes. Sure. >> And you've not provided those documents, Mr. Ivankovich, have you? Would you please repeat the question? >> You have not provided Mr. Ivankovic the underlying documents that you >> I'm sorry. I mean you asked to repeat the question. I'm afraid that the witness and the interpreter had a long conversation there. I'd like to know what was said in that conversation, please. >> Yes, because he he he said that this report was given at the general assembly uh meeting and they have no objection to it. But the question that has been asked whether the underlying information that were given to the auditors were also given to Mr. Ivanovich. >> Yes, I know what the question was but um what was the witness saying to you in Arabic? >> Yeah, that's what I said at the beginning. He said that this report was given and was discussed in the general assembly meeting. That's why I repeated the question because the question was different. >> Okay. Thank you very much. >> I'm going to try one last time Mr. Al Jasmine and I know that you provided these financial statements to Mr. Ankovich. But my question is, you have never provided to him the underlying documents that you provided to the auditor to allow the auditor to prepare this report. Okay. Mr. requested the appointment of the director and to discuss the appointment of the director in the first assembly meeting. But we told him that this first assembly meeting for the appointment of the financial auditor. >> Okay, I'll move on. Um, page 1720, which I think is the last page in these accounts. Can you see there's a heading called going concern and about four lines from the bottom there's a sentence which says the shareholders resolution dated 31st of January 2025 approved the continuity of the company's operations. Do you see those words shareholder? Okay. >> Okay. >> Yeah. Yes. >> I can see it. What What is the question? >> Well, my question is this. Earlier you agreed with me that the first general assembly meeting was held on the 20th of March 2025. So when the auditor refers to the shareholders resolution dated 31st of January 2025, is that a mistake by the auditor or is there a shareholders resolution that we don't know about? March. So what is the resolution? What is it about? Is there a shareholders resolution dated 31st of January 2025? doesn't matter. I'm sorry. >> Yes, of course. This is support from the KGM. I was doing the translation of the resolution. Okay. So there is a shareholders resolution for KJI that is dated the 31st of January 2025. Are you sure about that Mr. Al Jasmine? >> No, I'm not sure. >> It could just be another mistake by the auditor. Okay. >> You don't know. >> I I need to check it. >> I'll move on. Um let's go back to your witness statement. >> I'm sorry. Before you you leave this document, >> um 27. It says, "Approval of the financial statements. These financial statements were approved by the shareholders on November the 3rd, 2025. Um, did Mr. Ivankovic approve them? The representatives of Mr. Steven, they did not vote for the appointment of the this auditor. >> That's not an answer to the question. Uh I'll try again. Did Mr. Ivankovich approve these financial statements? No. >> So the financial statements were only approved by 50% of the shareholders. Is that correct? >> Yes. Correct. >> Okay. So that's another mistake in in the auditor's report then, isn't it? Yes, it's a mistake, but I need to check it. >> Okay, thank you. >> Well, I can help you with that and help your honor. Page 1730. Uh, these are Well, I I'm going to phrase it like this, your honor. These are Mr. Al Jasmy's minutes of this meeting. They are not agreed as being accurate in all respects. But you can see from item two, >> this is the meeting I should say on um on the 3rd of November 2025. Um the financial statements for the fiscal year ended 31st of December 24 and it's recorded that um the representative of Mr. Ivankovich rejected with no reason. It's a rather tendentious way I would suggest putting it. But the conclusion was these um financial statements were not accepted. >> Yes. >> Thank you. >> If we could go to page um 687 please. Mr. Al Jazzmi here you deal with your reasons for terminating the joint venture and you say at paragraph 57 if you could perhaps just zoom in on that that you instructed pinsmasons to send a termination notice due to three reasons and you say uh delays paying capital contributions failure to settle the purchase orders. Those are the Aquaform purchase orders, aren't they? You're referring to there. >> You please repeat it again. >> When you say Mr. Ivankovic's failure to settle the purchase orders, the purchase orders you're referring to are the aquaform purchase orders, aren't they? according to the JV contract. We we he is the one who selling the visels and we are building it. He's buying the vessels from us and he's going to sell it later. >> I I understand what the issue is about and as I say that was all litigated in Dubai. Let's leave that maybe. And the third reason you give is the liquidation orders. Do you see that? >> Yes. >> And then let's have a look at the termination notice itself. It starts at 1357. And we can see in the first two paragraphs a reference to the letter that you'd received from Aan about uh the entry of Ivankovich family as a chapter 11 data. Do you see that? And then uh it says separately there's reference to and then you refer to the purchase orders and then over the page there's a sort of general reservation of rights. There's no reference in this letter to delays in paying capital contribution is there? No. According to what is stated in this notification? No, it's not there. >> No. So you you hadn't instructed Vincent Mason's to terminate the agreement because of late payments with capital contributions, had you? Ben Mason's already Vincent stated two items or or two or three reasons >> but there are other reasons as well >> and there's no mention in this letter of anything about Mr. Ana which is divorce is there? >> Yeah. Divorce is not there according to the notification. >> That's something that you discovered after these proceedings had commenced, isn't it? anchor purchase order. No, this I I came to know about the divorce after uh denying the bitch's orders. So I tried to do my search and I find out about his divorce. Oh, and I couldn't understand the fact that at the beginning you told me that Aquaform is under his control and they started to send me orders and then later he denied any relation to Aquaform. marketing and Steven and the purpose of creating the factory is the fact that we the factory is going to receive orders British orders from Steven and he is going to uh to to to buy the vessels and is going also to still on the market the vessels >> and there's no mention is there in this termination letter of anything to do with the renewal of the factory lease or the industrial license is there >> no there's no mention >> just bear with me um your honor I think um those are all my questions for this witness. >> Thank you very much. Uh right, Mr. Pace, do you have any re-examination? >> No, your honor. >> Good. Uh Mr. Jasmine, thank you very much indeed for coming to uh give uh your evidence. uh your evidence is now over uh and you're uh free to leave or stay as you as you please. Um and so right we move on to the next witness I think Mr. Page. >> Yes. Hopefully Mr. Hyra is available. >> May I just make a procedural suggestion your honor? Um it's 12:40 now. Um, I think we were usually going to take a break at 12:45. >> Okay, we'll take a break while we change witnesses. >> I I I thought that and then we can just um I hope not to be too long with Mr. Hire about I'm so sorry, but I I rather than avoiding issues after the break, if I if we could just locate Mr. Hybrand Waller and perhaps swear him in if he is available rather than us sitting here for 10 minutes after the break. Is that >> happy to do that? Okay. >> Um, can I just check? Is anyone listening in able to tell us whether Mr. Hybr wallet um is here? No. Okay. Um, your honor, perhaps then it is better we break now. I can make investigations and hopefully uh this witness will be on screen by the time we we reconvene. Ah, >> hold on. Ah. Oh, here we are. >> Okay. Well, why don't uh we take your suggestion and uh why don't we we swear we swear Mr. Hyde Wooler in and indeed you can introduce his evidence into the record uh and then we can rise for 10 minutes and then we begin fresh with the cross- examination. >> Thank you. Is the court associate um able to swear in this witness? >> Yes. >> Thank you, your honor. Um I will proceed to swear in the witness. Um please can the parties confirm the witness's uh preferences in terms of whether they will be taking an oath uh in the holy book of choice or affirming when giving evidence in today's hearing? >> Affirming. >> Affirming. Thank you. Can you kindly confirm your full name and occupation? >> Shaspa, head of sales, KJM Marine. >> Thank you. And please repeat after me. I affirm by what I believe. >> I affirm by what I believe. >> To say the truth. >> To say the truth. >> And nothing but the truth. >> Nothing but the truth. >> Thank you, your honor. Mr. Hyra Waller, good afternoon. Uh, on the screen in front of you, you should see a witness statement. Uh, can you see it? >> Yes. >> Uh, is that your witness statement? >> Yes. >> And let's turn now, please, to page 104. This is the last page in the same document. Whose signature is that? And is the content of this witness statement true to the best of your knowledge and belief? >> Yes. >> Thank you. Um Mr. Well, I believe that we're now actually going to take a short break. Um but after that, Mr. Watson will have some questions for you. >> Thank you very much. Okay. It's just before quarter 2 4 Dubai time. So we'll start again at 5 to 4. >> Yes. And it is perhaps just worth mentioning, your honor, that now that this witness has been sworn in, he's under purder, formally speaking. >> Yes, Mr. H. Well, you're not meant to discuss your evidence with anybody uh while you've been sworn in and you're you're sitting in the witness box as it were. >> Thank you. >> Okay, we'll take a 10-minut break. Okay. Shall we proceed? Good afternoon. I think it is where you are, Mr. Hyderabad Waller. Can I just check that you can hear me and uh see documents on the screen? >> Yes, Matthew, I can. >> Um, could we please go to page 102 in the bundle, which is the second page of your witness statement. And uh you have a heading at C events after loan was executed and you say that in around October 2023 you were asked to look into the matter. Do you see that? >> Yes. >> And then you you tell us what you did. You say you started by reviewing the loan agreement. Do you see that? >> Okay. And then you say at paragraph nine, I knew from KJM that the inspection report and the related builder corrective actions report had already been issued by an independent third party, Admiral Marine Consulting. Do you see that? >> Yes. >> This might just be a a sort of infilicitus language. Um, but you're not suggesting, are you, that the corrective actions report had been issued by Admiral Marine, are you? >> No. >> And then you say, uh, the balance remained unpaid by Mr. Vankovich. I reviewed these reports and concluded that the corrective actions have been completed and we needed to complete the transaction in a pro manner. Do you see that? >> Yeah. >> Well, the corrective actions report was issued on the 29th of February 2024, wasn't it? >> I'll have to recheck. It's probably there in the evidence. >> Well, don't you know? >> I can't remember it right away. Did you check when you prepared this witness statement? >> Yes. >> So, you did check when you prepared this witness statement. Well, can we have a look at page 1183? Do you see in the second box near the top? Perhaps the operator could highlight it. Zoom in. Thank you. See the date 29th of February 2024. >> Yes. So let's go back to your witness statement at page 102. Just scroll down. So when you say at paragraph 7 that in October 2023 you asked to look into the matter and you reviewed the loan agreement and then the admiral report and then the corrective actions report. You can't have been reviewing the corrective actions report in October 2023, can you? >> Maybe uh there was information about the corrective uh actions being taken place. So wait a minute, paragraph nine, you say the related builders corrected actions report. Are you saying that there's another report from October 2023? Is that what you're saying? >> I don't know of one, but I'm saying that corrective actions would have been taken. >> You say I reviewed these reports. So surely you must be intending to refer to the corrective actions report in February 2024. >> Cannot be Do you when you made this witness statement, Mr. Hyderabad Waller, did you understand the importance of being careful and accurate in what you say? >> Yes. Why then did you say that you had reviewed the corrective actions report in October 2023? >> The report could mean many things. Oh, help help. >> Yeah. Information by email, information by phone calls, it could mean anything. >> So when you So when you say reports, you mean could be phone calls, emails, anything. >> That's right. It's been reported. Oh, it's Oh, so you're not Well, you see at paragraph the top of paragraph nine, you refer to the related builders corrective actions report. >> Yeah. >> You saying that where that the word these reports just refers to reports generally that you receive time time to time, >> right? >> You're making this up, aren't you, Mr. Hydro Badwaller? >> Why would I? I mean this is just you've well I suggest you've just made a simple mistake in your witness statement and rather than accept that you've made a simple error you've tried to uh torture these words to give a totally different account. >> I don't think so. I know my job so we know what we do. Reports mean many things. And we go to page 103 which is just over the page. And at paragraph 13 you say you issued uh actually no sorry paragraph 12 you say at the top there in our communications Mr. Anankovic had continuously expressed an interest in completing the purchase of the Aquilla 70 whenever I asked for the payment status. Do you see that? And you refer to some documents there. Do you see that? >> Exactly. Sorry. Paragraph 12, you say, "In our communications, Mr. Ankovich continually expressed an interest in completing the purchase of the Aquilla 70." And then do you see in brackets there's a there's a a reference to the documents that were exhibited to your witness statement. Did you did you look at those documents >> when you prepared when you prepared your witness state? Sorry, I should have said Let me in fairness, let me ask that question to you again. Did you look at the documents exhibited here when you prepared your witness statement? >> Can we look at those documents? I can tell you now. >> Well, are those the documents where you were asking about the payment status? >> Get your question. Okay, let's have a look. 1323, please. This is an email that I think we've now seen many times. It's on the the 2nd of August, right at the end of the transaction from Mr. Moore. You're not copied on it, are you? >> I don't see that. And actually, if we scroll down the the chain just slowly, I don't think you're you're copied anywhere, are you? And if we go back up, thank you to the operator. And if we go back up to the top 1323, Mr. Mr. Vanovich was saying here, yes, he would like to to uh close on the purchase, but he wants a pre-purchase inspection first, doesn't he? And that had been his position throughout, hadn't it? >> I'm sorry, Mr. Hydra. I don't think we picked up that answer. >> It appears so. >> Let's return to your witness statement, page 103, please. In paragraph 13, now you say, "Issued regular reminders to Mr. Ivankovich with respect to the balance amount. On average, I recall that reminders were sent at least once every two weeks." Do you see that? >> Yes. and then you refer to an email. And let's have a look at that at page 1121. This is the document that you were referring to, isn't it? >> Yes. >> This is the only email you ever sent Mr. Ivankovic about the balance, isn't it? >> Very likely. I'm sorry, Mr. Hydra. We didn't pick up that answer. Can you just try and speak a little louder and closer to the microphone if possible >> as an email? I think this is the only one >> I think for Yes. >> Sorry. I think your answer to the question was very likely. >> Yes, >> wasn't it? >> Thank you, your honor. >> I I'm sorry, Mr. I think what what might be going on here is because the laptop doesn't have the microphone on, it's the room speaker which was closer to where the interpreter was previously. So perhaps if >> uh that system could be brought closer. There we are. >> Thank you very much, Mr. Paige. That's very helpful. So Mr. Hyderabadwala, you were not sending regular reminders by email, were you? >> Yes, because it's very clear in the agreement that Steven would default if he was not informed in 5 days. uh and then we had obviously uh a friendship, a respect and he was never prepared with the money as per our verbal discussions. >> Right. Uh in this email you tell him the total loan amount don't you? >> That's right. And you tell him what has already been paid. >> Yes. >> And you tell him the balance. >> Correct. >> You don't say please pay the balance, do you? >> It's implicit. >> You don't say the balance is due, do you? >> Why would I be sending the information just randomly? Well, it's rather interesting, isn't it, Mr. Hyderabadwaller because your email says as per your request. So, it rather suggests that Mr. Ivankovic might have asked you for some information. >> Well, he asked for the balance information, so it was spelled out correctly. Everything is there as you saw. You don't mention anything to do with the Admiral report in this email, do you? >> Yes, because of the same reason as I said before. >> This was not a request by you for payment, was it? >> It is. >> Let's look at another set of documents. >> Before you move on, Mr. Baba, when you wrote this email the 19th of October, did you believe that $1.6 million had been paid to uh the ship builder? So that's a question which I don't get involved in my position at the uh organization. >> So you didn't know what was due and what was not due. in respect of the Aquilla 70. >> Well, um, as per the information I had, there was a balance due and then the yacht would be delivered, >> but you didn't know when it was due to be paid. >> It was obviously urgent by that time. >> How do you know that? >> Because we had been discussing this often. But did you know that actually the 6 million hadn't been paid by that time? >> Sorry. >> Did you know that your company had not paid the66 million to the ship builder by on by the 19th of October 2023? >> I cannot recollect that right now very precisely. >> So you didn't know what the payment schedule was? Uh not to my knowledge. No. >> No. Okay. Thank you. >> And we look at um uh page 1122. It's actually the next document in this bundle. And this is a WhatsApp exchange between you and Mr. uh Ivankovic, isn't it? And your messages are in white. And uh I think his are in green. Do you see that? >> Yes. >> And you say that Muhammad's in Kuwait has a client who's interested uh if possible would like a worksheet with down payment and monthly payment amount with max term possible for eventual transferring. And Mr. Vanovich says, "I I will have someone work on it tonight." And you say, "Thanks." And then over the page on on 23, you ask for a template for the worksheet. Do you see that? >> Yes. >> And then over page again, you sort of suggest some kind of outline terms. And the response is, well, we'd need a larger upfront deposit. Do you see that? >> Right. >> And uh nowhere in these messages do you refer to the loan agreement? You see that? >> Yes. >> You don't mention that a balance is outstanding, do you? >> Yes. >> You don't ask Mr. Ivankovic to pay any money. Do you? >> I mean, when you're an international businessman, you should know that you should be making payments at the right time. Nobody needs to keep informing you. >> Right. Well, if we just go back to your witness statement at page 103. Oh, sorry. Before we leave that, sorry, sorry. Um, um, I should have just at 1124. We can see, can't we, that these messages are all 30th and 31st of October. Do you see that? >> Yeah. >> Right. Now, let's look at your witness statement, page 103, paragraph 14. You say, "Having reviewed my WhatsApp correspondence with Mr. Vankovich, I've identified four different occasions on which I followed up with him with regards to the balance amount, particularly on 31st of October, 2023. Do you see that? >> Yes. We've just looked at your WhatsApps on the 31st of October 2023 and you didn't follow up with the balance amount, did you? >> Indirectly. I did. >> All right. So, should we go back and have a look? Um, let's go back to 1124. Zoom out a bit. Where where are you indirectly following up about the balance? >> Well, we are talking about um purchase plan. So, he does get the idea that he needs to pay up and he has been told multiple times before to pay up for it. >> That's just not true, is it, Mr. Hyderabad? >> The way you look at it, that's the way I look at this. Okay. Well, we can all read these messages. Um, let's go back to page 103. Uh, you say 31st of October, 14th of November, 30th of November, 4th of December. Let's just have a look at those. So 1144 this is the 14th of November and you ask Mr. Anankovich, how can we proceed with the matters of the 70 in the factory? Do you see that? >> Why don't you just say when are you going to pay the money? >> Why don't I say directly why don't you pay the money? Is that your question? >> Yeah. I mean how can we proceed with matters of the 17 factories a very loose >> the context is very clear I mean there's no doubt in the context I mean you can take these informations in silo and question them but everybody knew what was the issue with the it was a big issue so it was very clear what he had to do whether I tell him directly or indirectly He has to get the message because after all he's the international businessman with so much of success. So he should be getting that information. >> And you don't say here hang on Mr. Ivankovic you've had the admiral report since July. Uh this sum is owing. You don't say that do you? >> Again it was known to him. You don't keep repeating these things with clients. Well, you work in sales, don't you, Mr. Hyderabad? >> Yes. >> I mean, if if someone really owes you money and they're not paying, you make it very clear that they owe the money. And why they owe the money, don't you? >> That sounds like uh, you know, loan recovery department. We sell yachts. There's a certain conduct that's required. on the 14th of November 2023. You hadn't seen the corrective actions report yet, had you? >> Not uh probably not of Akila, but other information related to the boat. Very likely. When you said in your witness statement that you followed up about the balance amount on the 14th of November, that was wrong, wasn't it? I think it says here how do we proceed with the matters of the 17th the factory and then let's have a look at um page 1147 so you say here this is now on Mr. Ivankovic's phone. So, he's talking to you. So, your uh comments are in uh white and his are in green. And you say on the 30th of November, really need your help with completing the Aquilla 70 payment. Then you say plan is to bring it here in time for new year etc. to market it effectively, etc. Do you see that? >> Yes. Again, no reference to the Apple report, is there? >> Because it's done and dusted. Keeping it specific like the way you like it. And if we then if I just ask the operator to scroll down over the next few messages from uh 148 down to 149 and he asks you we can see about a a different um transaction and we keep going down please. We get to the 2nd of December and there's various sort of comments. Keep going down please. All the way down I think to 1157. No discussion about the um Aquilla at all. Well, it's good you brought that up because yesterday we were told that we were badgering. So, we've been respectful then, right? And then at um 1161 you get in the statement uh that the payments he says as for the balance it's it's set up and will go in order of the others. He's not he's not saying I'm definitely going to pay is he? He's not saying you're going to get the money tomorrow. >> Well, uh, look, I mean, you want to read these in silo and in plain English, it's subjective because finally the context is how we interacted with Steven and whenever there was payments to be made, it was always this thing about setting up payments, etc. So I guess I believe that at least he knew that I would think of it in that way. >> You just say >> sorry >> or he was just something that was set up. He was setting something else up >> right and you just say okay thank you. You see that >> there's to say >> so let me get this straight Mr. Ivanker has apparently received the Admiral report in July 2023. And as I think you probably heard Mr. Al Jasmine say, money is due in five days. And here we are in December and he still hasn't paid. and you say you've chased him about the balance and he doesn't give you a straight answer and you just say okay thank you I mean if you genuinely thought that money was due and owing you would have been making that very clear wouldn't you Mr. Miners also >> well uh again the context is not just what we see on the screen here. The context is overall relationship and everything that was going on. And I guess uh we have to keep everything else in mind while doing these follow-ups. But it's very clear that what we are supposed to be is done and someone's not paid up. Can we just go back finally to um page 103 and at the bottom here you say that ultimately sinoal lost patients terminated transaction the initial payment of US dollar 1.6 million and the installments totaling 400,000 just pausing there did you hear my exchange with Mr. Jasmine about the amounts that had been paid. >> I was likely told by that time. Yes. >> Okay. I'm not. Don't worry about it. Um you say that the the sums that have been paid to Sino Eagle were forfeited. Do you see that? I think you you um said in answer to um his honor, I don't think you you saw the sale contract between uh Sino Eagle and uh KJM, did you? >> Sorry, can you repeat the question? >> You didn't see the sale contract for the Aquilla between Sino Eagle and KJM. There's a master distribution agreement that allows us to purchase boats individually. It's not a single brokerage kind of a deal that requires a contract, >> right? So, so the contract to purchase the Aquilla, is that contained in the master agreement? As I understand that if we send emails confirming an order with uh payment information, the order is done. Right. >> I don't think I've got any further questions witness. Thank you, >> Mr. Paige. any of your examination >> just a very uh small amount your honor. Uh so Mr. Hybrand Waller you were shown some WhatsApp messages uh after which the uh his honor asked you about um your knowledge of payment obligations to Sono Eagle. If I just show you two other pages please. First page 1144. And uh do you recognize this this exchange of text messages? >> Yes. >> Sorry, I can't hear you. >> Yes. >> Uh and who is it between? >> Uh this is me sending messages to Steven in green. uh and uh your if we then go over the page uh and your comments there. So let's now go back to 1144 please. After this message saying we have to send them a wire. Uh, did you speak to anyone about that message? >> Very likely I would have informed the team. >> You mean internally in KGM? You mean internally in KGM? >> It's your evidence, Mr. Hagra. Well, I'm afraid I'm um The very thing I'm not allowed to do is leave you at all. Uh, my question is simply, did you speak to anyone about it? Oh yeah, definitely. >> Who did he speak to >> again? Mohammed Aljasi for sure because I report to him. >> Thank you. If we just turn over the page and then 116 please. uh and the message there at 1146. Uh did you speak to anyone else about that message? >> I would have definitely informed Muhammad Jasmine >> and what do you recall saying to Jasmine? Well, it probably would have been that once again Steven is doing what he does with payments and uh all he has said that it's either in the pipeline or it's set up or something of that sort and we have to buy more time from Akila. >> Thank you. No further questions for me. >> Thank you very much. Thank you very much. That's the end of your evidence. You're free to go. Thank you. Right. Okay. So, that is the end of the live evidence. Is that right? >> Yes, your honor. That's correct. >> Okay. So, um I can give you a choice. Um either we can blast on tomorrow with closing submissions or of course we set aside Tuesday next week. Um I'm entirely in your hands. uh we can uh if you want time to prepare your submissions and indeed speaking notes and and references to uh transcripts, I'm happy to sit uh on Tuesday next week for the closing submissions or I'm quite happy I if that doesn't work for either of you to go straight into closing submissions tomorrow. Up to you. >> Well, I think um and I'll let Mr. today speak for himself, but I think the proposal was to um just carry on tomorrow morning. >> Okay. Well, that's fine by me, Mr. Paige. How do you feel about that? >> Yes, you want to. That is my side's preference as well. >> Okay, good. Well, in which case then we will adjourn now. Uh it is uh precisely 4:30 Dubai and we will resume at 11:00 Dubai tomorrow morning. Uh and I understand Mr. Watson from the timetable you will indicate how long you are going to be in submissions and how long you'd like to reserve for reply. >> I I will do so say tomorrow morning. Yes. >> Okay. Thank you both and I'll see you tomorrow morning. >> Thank you.