PUBLIC TEXT · DOCKET_PUBLIC_RECORD
Order Granting Defendant's Motion to Dismiss — Steven Ivankovich v. Jeanette Ivankovich and Schiller Ducanto & Fleck LLP
Court order granting the motion to dismiss and denying the motion for remand as moot. Document 26.
All public records Open source PDF
Mirrored text
--- page 1 --- UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA M iam i Division Case Num ber: 23-24894-C1V-M 0M N 0 STEVEN IVANKOVICH , Plaintiff, JEANETTE IVANKOVICH and SCHILLER DUCANTO & FLECK LLP Defendants. ORDER GRANTING DEFENDANT'S M OTIO-N TO DISM ISS A . Backzround This Cause cnme before the Court upon (D.E. 9) Defendants' Motion to Dismiss, filed on January 5, 2024 and (D.E. 12) Plaintiff's Corrected Motion to Remand, filed on January 22, 2024. Plaintiff Steven Ivankovich (çlsteven'') and Defendant Jeanet'te Ivankovich tG&leanetlge''l are are Respondent and Petitiolter in a Dissolution of M arriage proceeding pending in the Circuit Cout't of Cook County, lllinois. (D.E. 1-1j ! 10. In that case, Jeanette was (and still is) represented by co-Defendant Schiller. 1d. at ! 1 1. As the charging orderjudgment debtor, Steven was required to pay $400,000 for attorneys' fees and $25,000 for expert fees for Jeanette (totaling $425,000). ld at ! 12. The Circuit Court of Cook Cotmty also found Steven in indirect civil contempt and issued a Body Attachm ent Order for an Unsecured Debt, which set a cash bond that Steven, once arrested, was required to post in the amount of $425,000. Id The order does not allow Stevçn or a third party to post a bond to sectlre his release. 1d Schiller, as a creditor of Steven, is attempting to Case 1:23-cv-24894-FAM Document 26 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/01/2024 Page 1 of 9 --- page 2 --- require Steven, as malaager of a group of LLCS, to use his LLCS' assets to pay the debt Owed to Schiller. Id at ! 13. On November 13, 2023, Steven lvnnkovich commenced a declaratory judgment action by filing a two-count complaint for declaratory relief against D efendants Jeanette lvankovich and Schiller Ducanto & Fleck, LLP. ED.E. lj ! 1. Count 1 requested a declaration by the Plaintiff of his obligations as a m arlager of m ultiple lim ited liability entities concerning access to LLC f'unds to pay Jearlette, as ajudgment creditor, fOr legal fees that she owed to Defendant Sclliller Ducalato & Fleck, LLP. 1d. He seeks cladfication on whether the charging order entered by the Circuit Cottt't for M iam i-Dade Cotmty prevents him âom paying the fees out of his LLC accounts. 1d Count 11 concerns declaratory relief regarding the treatment of Steven's m embership interests, if arly, that he owned in the LLCS as m arital property- as well as a request for an injunction enjoining Florida 1aw enforcement from ezlforcing the body attachment order on the grotmd that the order violates the Florida constitution. LD.E. 1-1j ! 49. lf Steven is found to own LLC memàership interests and if those membership interests are marital property, he wants to lcnow what rights Jeanette would have to llis LLC distributions or LLC participation. Id at ! 37. Jeanet'te alleges that the LLCS' assets aze mazital property and that, as marital property, she owns at least 50 percent of whatever membership interests he owns in the LLCS. (D.E. 9j. Steven counters that any marital interestts)Jeaneûe naay have aresubordinate to the rights of his creditors- and the rights of other members of the LLCS. (D.E. 22). On July 29, 2022, the Circuit Coul't for M inm i-Dade Cotmty, Florida, entered a charging order on Creditor Pnmi Grand Too, LLC'S motion as judgment creditor of Steven,to a group of limited liability compnnies specifically, 172 Portfolio M anaging M em ber LLC, A&O Fam ily LLC, and Consilient Holdings Case 1:23-cv-24894-FAM Document 26 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/01/2024 Page 2 of 9 --- page 3 --- LLC. (D.E. 1-1q !J 23.The charging order imposed a lien on any membership interest of Steven alad directed the LLCS n0t to make any disbuzsem ent to Steven. 16l In sum, Steven commenced this declaratory judgment and injunction action by filing (1) a Complaint for Declaratory Relief that Lim ited Liability Company Assets Are Not Assets of Steven Ivankovich; (2) a Declaration of ltights of Jeanetle lvankovich lf Any of Marital ltights to Membership Interests in Limited Liability Entities; (3) a Declaration of Plaintiff's Obligation to Comply with the Chazging Order Entered by this Court; and (4) a Preliminary and Permanent Injunction in the Circuit Court for Mialni-Dade Cotmty, Florida. (D.E. 1-1q. Jeanette filed for divorce against Steven in the Circuit Court of Cook Coupty, lllinois, on October 22, 2021. (D.E. 9q. Three weeks later, on November 12, 2021, Steven filed a divorce petition of his own in the Circuit Court for M inmi-Dade Cotmty, Florida. (D.E. 20j. On January 24, 2024, the trial courts in both the Illinois and Florida divorce proceedings held a joint hearing pursuant to the Uniform Child-custody Jurisdiction and Enforcement Act to detennine which cout't had jtlrisdiction over the parties' minor children. JJ.Both judges determined that Illinois hadjurisdiction. 1d. Accordingly, the parties are currently in the process of submitting an order in the Florida divorce proceeding dism issing that case and transferring any pendl g m atters to the Illinois divorce proceeding. f#. B. Issue There are two issues at the M otion to Dismiss stage, each of which relate to Plaintiff's two Cotmts in the Complaint, respectively. First, the Defendants argue that the Court should decline to exercise jlzrisdiction over Steven's claim because it involves a domestic relations issue that is already pending in and will be resolved by the lllinois divorce court. Plaintiff counters that this M otion to Disnliss is substantively a M otion to Transfer, and that it should be addressed Case 1:23-cv-24894-FAM Document 26 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/01/2024 Page 3 of 9 --- page 4 --- accordingly. Second, the Defendants posit that dism issal is appropriate on the grourld that Steven's injtmction request violates the Full Faith and Credit Clause of the U.S. Constitution. Plaintiff cotmters with a case f'rom Florida's Third District Court of Appeals that is m eant to show that Florida will not give Full Faith and Credit to a foreign judgment for the payment of monetary damages that enforces thatjudgment by incazceration of the judgment debtor. .C. LeMgl Analysis Count 1 The Defendants' argum ent that the Court should dism iss Cotmt 1 of the Complaint under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12(b)(1) is persuasive. Plaintiff ignpres the argument by responding to it as if the Motion to Dismiss were a Motion to Transfer, engaging in a 28 U.S.C. j 1404(a) analysis. However, Defendants explicitly argued for dismissal- not transfer- of Co'unt l of the Complaint on the basis of abstention doctrine fzom Colorado River Water Conservation Dist. v. United States, 424 U.S. 800 (1976). Although the Court could simply rule in favor the Defendants on Count l by virtue of the Plaintiff's failure to address Defendants' dism issal argllments, the Court finds it w orthwhile to address the m erits of Defendants' arguments. Colorado River abstention doctrine, in which a District Court m ay decline to exercise its jurisdiction, applies ttwhen federal and state proceedings involve substantially the snme parties arld substantially the sam e issues.'' Ambrosia Coal and Const. Co. v. Pages M orales, 368 F.3d 1320, 1330 (11th Cir. 2004). Yhe parties in the divorce proceeding are Steven atld Jeanetle. The parties in the present case are Steven, Jeanette, and Sclliller Ducanto & Fleck. Though not identical, they are substantially the sam e. The Eleventh Circuit has m ade clear that Colorado River abstention does not require that ttthe relevant federal and state cases share identical parties, issues, and requests for relief.'' 1d,. see O 'Dell v. Doychak, 2006 'Wt, 4509634, at *6 (M.D. Fla. Oct. 19, 2006) Case 1:23-cv-24894-FAM Document 26 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/01/2024 Page 4 of 9 --- page 5 --- (clarifying that Gçrtjwo cases calz involve substantially similar pal-ties even if some defendants present in the federal case are not parties to the state action.').Defendants properly note that Schiller Ducanto & Fleck is intim ately involved in the divorce cases as Jeanette's counsel and is the benefciary of the order at issue in Cotmt I of the Complaint in this case- the divorce court's order requiring Steven to pay Schiller Ducarlto & Fleck legal fees. Thus, the parties are Sçsubstantially the sam e'' for Colorado River pup oses. Further, the Defendants are correct that a threshold question that must be addressed before confronting any priority issues is whether Jeanette has a m arital interest in Steven's LLC m embership interests. Steven attempts to refram e the questions in his Com plaint, but he directly asks, C&m loes Jeanet'te have a marital interest in any Steven Ivnnkovich membership interests in the Plaintiffs?'' arld tçls any m emberslzip interest that Steven has or previously om zed in the LLCS marital property?'' (D.E. 251. The Illinois divorce court GGis responsible for determining what property is or is not lmarital propertygnl''' per Illinois law. In re Thorpe, 546 B.R. 172, 177 (Bnnkr. C.D. 111. 2016). Therefore, the issue from the divorce proceeding is the substantially the same as that in ou.r case under Colorado River. Upon establishing substantially similar pm ies and issues, the Court m ust engage in a six- factor analysis to analyze the permissibility of abstention. Ambrosia, 368 F.3d at 1331. Those factors are as follows: $G(1) whether one of the cotu'ts has assumed jlzrisdiction over the property, (2) inconvenience of the federal fonzm, (3) the potential for piecemeal litigation, (4) the order in which the fora obtained jurisdiction, (5) whether state or federal 1aw will be applied, and (6) the adequacy of the state court to protect the parties? rights.'' Case 1:23-cv-24894-FAM Document 26 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/01/2024 Page 5 of 9 --- page 6 --- 1d (citing Am. Bankers Ins. Co. ofFla. v. First State lns. Co. , 891 F.2d 882, 884 (1 1th Ciz. 1990:. Fudher, the itvexatious or reactive nature of either the federal or the state litigation m ay influence the decision whether to defer to a parallel state litigation under Colorado Afvpr.'' 1d. (quoting Moses H Cone Memorial Hosp. v. Mercury Constr. Corp. , 460 U.S. 1, 17 11.20 (1983) (internal quotations omitledl). Firsi, the Illinois divorce court is the proper venue for determining whether Jeanet'te has a marital interest in Steven's membership interests in the LLCS. As In re Thorpe discusses, Glrujnder Illinois law, a divorce court is responsible for determining what property is or is not çm arital property' and, once that categorization is made, Cshall divide the marital property without regard to marital misconduct in just proportions considering al1 relevant factors.''' 546 B.R. at (quoting 750 111. Comp. Stat. Ann. 5/503(d)). For Colorado River puposes, the Illinois state court has taken jurisdiction over the property in question- steven's LLC membership interests and distribution paym ents resulting therefrom . Second, the convenience of Florida as forum is not clear. Jeanet'te m akes a strong case that Illinois is her dom icile, and it is the dom icile of Schiller Ducanto. Steven is dom iciled in Florida, but this m atter does not have much of a relationship with the State of Florida outside of that fact. Third, if the case is to proceed here, piecem eal litigation is likely. The Illinois divorce court will certainly m ake its own ruling on the marital property question, even if this Coul't also does. Because this case is properly before a separate court, which has jmisdiction over a11 issues relating to Steven and Jeanette's m arital dissolution, this Court need not m ake a nzling on such an ISSID . Foudh, the lllinois divorce proceeding began on October 22, 2021.This proceeding began November 17, 2023. Thus, Illinois obtainedjtuisdiction before this Court by over two years. Case 1:23-cv-24894-FAM Document 26 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/01/2024 Page 6 of 9 --- page 7 --- Fifth, state 1aw will determ ine the issues raised in Cotmt 1 of Steven's Complaint, which raises questions of m arital property and priority of distributions, neither of which im plicates federal law . Sixth, the lllinois coul't is adequately situated to protect the padies' rights. The Illinois court is perfectly sittzated to determine whether Steven's m embership interests in the LLCS constitute m arital property. Additionally, whether Jeanetle or Parni Gralad Too LLC has priority over Steven's LLC distributions if those distributions are deemed m arital propelty is a question the divorce court carl also address. See, e.g., In re Marriage ofolbrecht, 597 N.E.2d 635, 640 (111. App. Ct. 1992) (Gsconsideration must be given to addressing the claims of a third party to alleged marital property.'). In other words, the Illinois divorce court is positioned to address a number of issues Steven m ay raise in the course of litigation that relate to protection of the parties' rights. ln addition to the six Colorado River factors, it is worth addressing G&the importance of whether the concurrent cases involve a federal statm e that evinces a policy favoring abstention.'' Ambrosia, 368 F.3d at 1331. Here, although no particular federal statute evinces a policy that favors abstention, the Supreme Court has suggested there is a Ctdom estic relations exception'' to jurisdiction, which çcdivests the federal courts power to issue divorce, alimony, and child custody decrees.'' Ankenbrandt v. Richards, 504 U.S. 689, 690, 703 (1992). As the Eleventh Circuit articulated, Clfederal courts will not review or m odify a state cotlrt divorce order even when the plaintiff couches the claims in other tenns.'' Mccavey v. Barnett, 629 F. App'x 865, 867 (1 1th Cir. 2015). See also Irish v. Irish, 842 F.3d 736, 741 (1st Cir. 2016) (GGthe domestic relations exception covers attempts to determine or m odify not only alimony awards but also the division of m arital property plzrsuant to a divorce.''). The domestic relations exception to jurisdiction tireflects an understanding that the federal fortun is inappropriate and reinforces the policy's rationale: state Case 1:23-cv-24894-FAM Document 26 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/01/2024 Page 7 of 9 --- page 8 --- courts are experts at dividing m arital property, entering the necessary decrees, and handling the sensitive conflicts that follow .'' Irish, 842 F.3d at 741. ln conclusion, Count I of Steven's Complaint is dism issed. Count 11 The Defendants' Full Faith and Credit Clause argum ent supporting dismissal is similarly persuasive. 1CFull Faith and Credit shall be given in each State to the public Acts, Records, and judi. cial Proceedings of every other State.'' U.S. Const. art. IV j 1. Further, ûtgal state may not disregard the judgment of a sister State because it disagrees with the reasoning underlying the judgment or deems it to be m ong on the merits.'' VL . v. E.L., 577 U.S. 404, 407 (2016). t'The Supreme Cout't . . . continues to reject any notion that a state may elevate its own public policy over the policy behind a sister state's judgment and thereby disregard the command of the Full Faith and Credit Clause.'' f edoux-Nottingham v. Downs, 210 So. 3d 1217, 1223 (Fla. 2017). In Ledoux-Nottingham, the petitioner filed suit in Florida state court seeldng to modify a judgment entered by a Colorado state court ordering grandparent visitation with the petitioner's minor children. The petitioner argued that the Colorado judgment explicitly violated article 1, section 23 of the Florida Constitm ion. L edoux-Nottingham, 210 So. 3:1 at 1218. There, the Florida Suprem e Court affirmed the trial court's denial of the petition p'ursuant to the Full Faith and Credit Clause of the U.S. Constitution.As the Coul't explained, tEthe question presented . . . gwasl not whether the Grandparents gwerej entitled to visitation under Florida law, but whether Florida gwas) required to enforce the Colorado order (althoughj entry of a similarjudgment by a Florida court . . . would be prohibited by the Florida Constitution.'' Id at 1223. The Court answered in the affinnative. fJ. Here, the sam e analysis applies. As Defendants properly argue, Steven's Complaint does not allege that the Illinois state court lackedjtuisdiction over Steven to enter the body attachment Case 1:23-cv-24894-FAM Document 26 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/01/2024 Page 8 of 9 --- page 9 --- order in the underlying divorce proceeding. Rather, he assels that it violates the Florida Constitm ion. That point, however, is irrelevant, since the order was entered in lllinois pursuant to Illinois law. Florida must enforce the body attachm ent order even if it violates Florida's entered by an Illinois state court with Constitution or public policy because it was validly jurisdiction over the parties. See, e.g., Ledoux-Nottingham, 210 So. 3d at 1223. Plaintiff leans heavily on Weiss v. Weiss, 100 So. 3d 1220 (F1a. 2(1 DCA 2012). This case, however, predates the Ledoux-Nottingham Florida Suprem e Court opinion and is not persuasive. Therefore, the Coul't dism isses Cotmt 11 of Plaintiff's Complaint. D. Conclusion ln conclusion, the Court dism isses Count 1 of the Com plaint because the six Colorado River abstention factors, as well as public policy, favor dism issal. Further, the Cotu't dismisses Count 11 of the Complaint because the Florida Supreme Court has spoken clearly on the issue of Full Faith and Credit as it applies to enforcement of foreign court'sjudgments that violate the local state's constitm ion. Upon granting the M otion to Dism iss as to both Counts of the Complaint, the Court need not address the Plaintiff s M otion for Rem and. THE COURT has considered the motions, the responses, the replies, pertinent portions of the record, and being otherwise fully advised in the prem ises, it is ADJUDGED that the M otion to Dismiss is G'RANTED as to both counts. Therefore, the Plaintiff s M otion for Remand is DENIED AS M OOT. .- - X of 2024. DONE AND ORDERED in Chambers at Miami, Florida, this FEDERIC . OREN O UN ITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE Copies furnished to: Cotm sel of Record Case 1:23-cv-24894-FAM Document 26 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/01/2024 Page 9 of 9
Location index
Source document filed 2024-07-01 · Mirror updated 2026-11-19 · Public-record mirror — verify current status on PACER · Label: Verified.
Mechanical index generated from this card. Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
No numbered paragraphs in this document.
Formats: Markdown · Plain text · PDF source
Independent public-records resource operated by Helm Legal Technologies. Not a law firm. Not legal advice. A filed complaint is alleged. A court order is a court order. Automated classification is not live. Corrections: /corrections.